Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
News
News Article
Accepting Nominations for "Best of" Polls [CLOSED]
It was about 6 years ago since we did our last (and only) "Best of" polls for shounen, shoujo, seinen, and josei. The nomination process will be done through Google Forms, and it will require you to log in with a Google account. In a few weeks, I'll close the nomination forms and we'll get started on using the site poll on MU to vote. For each poll, the choices will be the top 10 nominations for each category.
Shounen: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1Fom70QH6rKgjh1kJjxvtvK2fy 14TXE_CcyCEa9cU0v4/viewform?usp=send_form
Shoujo: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1r7CfHjdu6pFPbehr-g5XIPbUPtL tM1NGRpdVj-OnbKw/viewform?usp=send_form
Seinen: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1zY5HhUlcN-eQ9GEtxV9NIVupW v3N3aN5P5TQdjdMz9s/viewform?usp=send_form
Josei: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1KhfFTJmlpXiDtWkwX1RxYRh 3H7RkTclg-axT126KJiw/viewform?usp=send_form
Winners from 6 years ago:
Shounen: One Piece
Shoujo: Skip Beat!
Seinen: xxxHoLic
Josei: Nodame Cantabile
Edit: Closed
Shounen: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1Fom70QH6rKgjh1kJjxvtvK2fy 14TXE_CcyCEa9cU0v4/viewform?usp=send_form
Shoujo: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1r7CfHjdu6pFPbehr-g5XIPbUPtL tM1NGRpdVj-OnbKw/viewform?usp=send_form
Seinen: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1zY5HhUlcN-eQ9GEtxV9NIVupW v3N3aN5P5TQdjdMz9s/viewform?usp=send_form
Josei: http://docs.google.com/forms/d/1KhfFTJmlpXiDtWkwX1RxYRh 3H7RkTclg-axT126KJiw/viewform?usp=send_form
Winners from 6 years ago:
Shounen: One Piece
Shoujo: Skip Beat!
Seinen: xxxHoLic
Josei: Nodame Cantabile
Edit: Closed
Comments (limited to first 100 replies)
» deadphoenix on August 29th, 2015, 1:22am
Are manwha and webcomics also accepted in the nominations? Like Tower of God? Or is it manga only?
Don't tell me that novels can be in their.....................
Anyway why isn't this nomination also for hentai, yaoi, shounen-ai, shoujo-ai and yuri. That would also be nice.
Don't tell me that novels can be in their.....................
Anyway why isn't this nomination also for hentai, yaoi, shounen-ai, shoujo-ai and yuri. That would also be nice.
» KaoriNite on August 29th, 2015, 5:29am
Could we get a Yaoi category?
» Miale on August 29th, 2015, 9:41am
Omg this is a great chance to review all the titles I have read (hundreds of them). Found many nostalgic series... And to my surprise, even though I mostly read shounen and shoujo, most of the series I love best belong to the seinen category 
I had a really hard time to choose just 5 of them. While with shounen, I have to think hard for the 4th and 5th options since I don't know which one is good enough.
I had a really hard time to choose just 5 of them. While with shounen, I have to think hard for the 4th and 5th options since I don't know which one is good enough.» lambchopsil on August 29th, 2015, 11:14am
Manhwa, manhua, and webcomics are accepted, assuming they have the correct demographic listed on them
We will not be doing yaoi, yuri, hentai, shounen-ai, or shoujo-ai
We will not be doing yaoi, yuri, hentai, shounen-ai, or shoujo-ai
» PansyWansyLinsy on August 29th, 2015, 11:41am
Oh, nice. Good to see that we're lumped in with hentai. But really, why not include yaoi or yuri?
» lambchopsil on August 29th, 2015, 11:51am
Because I don't want to
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
» PansyWansyLinsy on August 29th, 2015, 4:02pm
Quote from lambchopsil
Because I don't want to
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
I see, so your reasoning could be anything from inherent bias to making this a PG-13 friendly poll? Although there are definitely seinen and josei/smut works that could be classified as 17+ with heavy sexual content? Shounen-ai/shoujo-ai as we classify it has no 18+ content at all.
Quote from Chibi-Chibi
Yeah, but not having 18+ and not allowing shounen-ai, or shoujo-ai are two completely different things -.-;;
@PansyWansyLinsy: some of the works are labeled as shoujo too (since all that is actually subganre of shoujo) so maybe some of the works you wanted to nominate are labeled as such too.
@PansyWansyLinsy: some of the works are labeled as shoujo too (since all that is actually subganre of shoujo) so maybe some of the works you wanted to nominate are labeled as such too.
Agreed, and that would be an interesting workaround. I've never participated in their best of poll so I'm not sure how the voting process works. Many BL readers are from a young female demographic so I can understand that reasoning.
Probably won't be participating anyway seeing as I don't read nearly enough from the other demographics to justify a vote.
» deadphoenix on August 30th, 2015, 4:10am
Quote from lambchopsil
Because I don't want to
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
Isn't seinen and josei also 18+? Most seinen and josei isn't suited for children. Well, it's your chose, it's probably to much work.
Anyway, it would be to difficult for me to chose five good yaoi series anyways.I at least hope that one of my chooses made it in the top 10 that I at least can vote. And please don't let Naruto or Bleach end up in the top ten, then I would flip. I also hope that short series aren't ignored, completed series always have difficulties to get in such lists, because they are mostly very deep buried in the memory of people.
» KaoriNite on August 31st, 2015, 1:31am
Quote from lambchopsil
And you may have realized this, but we purposely don't have 18+ content in site polls
We've had polls in the past that asked if we like fan service, if we read hentai, and what bust size we would like girls in manga to have.
This is not a PG13 site. People are allowed to post releases of hentai and other 18+ manga, and there is a forum section dedicated to 18+ material. And as others have mentioned, Josei and Seinen are by definition 18+. Which means people would technically be allowed to nominate Josei Smut or Boderline-H Seinen.
So simply put, the real reason is
Quote from lambchopsil
Because I don't want to
. But as someone else mentioned, I guess people could always start their own poll in the18+ or yaoi/yuri forums.
» Chibi-Chibi on August 29th, 2015, 2:12pm
Yeah, but not having 18+ and not allowing shounen-ai, or shoujo-ai are two completely different things -.-;;
@PansyWansyLinsy: some of the works are labeled as shoujo too (since all that is actually subganre of shoujo) so maybe some of the works you wanted to nominate are labeled as such too.
@PansyWansyLinsy: some of the works are labeled as shoujo too (since all that is actually subganre of shoujo) so maybe some of the works you wanted to nominate are labeled as such too.
» residentgrigo on August 30th, 2015, 4:56am
All sorts of manga with a focus on homosexual relationships were published in general audience magazines with target demographics applied as the Tezuka winning Zankoku na Kami ga Shihaisuru or Tempest to give examples of both so the notion of such isn´t technically out of the question. Traditional Yaoi/Yuri are treated as porn by the book market anyway so i also view them as hentai (naming the readers rotten girls isn´t nice but that one stuck) and none have a chance to win a MU award in the end due to the limited appeal. Seinen is also an all ages publication form (the book Fifty Shades of Grey is too btw.) and not hentai or Bill 156 wouldn´t exist. Anyone can also start a poll on such in the 2 18+ sub forums...
Do the awards have a name?
Do the awards have a name?
» MinatoAce on August 30th, 2015, 6:34am
Hell Yeah! Now you're talking.
We're having a Users'/Fans' Choice in the end.
Seriously like residentgrigo asked, Is there a name ?!
Or. Do you wanna have voters to suggest some ?! ^^
We're having a Users'/Fans' Choice in the end.
Seriously like residentgrigo asked, Is there a name ?!
Or. Do you wanna have voters to suggest some ?! ^^
» PansyWansyLinsy on August 30th, 2015, 12:59pm
This is mostly a demographic awards anyway, right? I guess the point is moot given that yaoi/yuri are more genres than demographic. Ah well, next time.
» Crenshinibon on August 30th, 2015, 11:14pm
God, has it really been six years?
Time is a son of a bitch.
Time is a son of a bitch.
» Mirurururu on September 1st, 2015, 5:11am
I curse you
And I curse this poll
And I curse the damn idea TT_____TT do you have any idea how torturous it was to pick only 5? Especially for the shounen and shoujo category TAT
And I curse this poll
And I curse the damn idea TT_____TT do you have any idea how torturous it was to pick only 5? Especially for the shounen and shoujo category TAT
» Sosseres on September 4th, 2015, 1:00pm
I was strolling along and entering series pretty easily, trying to diversify picks so I don't have an all Adachi list or similar. Then I hit Josei and realised I haven't enjoyed 5 of them. Managed to scrape together a list in the end though.
