Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Manga Info
Heart Silent ![]()
Login to add items to your list, keep track of your progress, and rate series!
Description
Type
Manhwa
Related Series
N/A
Associated Names
Сердце молчит
심장은 조용히
심장은 조용히
Groups Scanlating
Latest Release(s)
c.43 by Masked Scans over 6 years ago
c.42 by Masked Scans over 6 years ago
c.41 by Masked Scans over 6 years ago
Search for all releases of this series
c.42 by Masked Scans over 6 years ago
c.41 by Masked Scans over 6 years ago
Search for all releases of this series
Status
in Country of Origin
43 Chapters (Complete)
Completely Scanlated?
Yes
Anime Start/End Chapter
N/A
User Reviews
N/A
Forum
0 topics, 0 posts
Click here to view the forum
Click here to view the forum
User Rating
Average: 6.4 / 10.0 (66 votes)
Bayesian Average: 6.37 / 10.0
Bayesian Average: 6.37 / 10.0
10
3%
9+
6%
8+
21%
7+
29%
6+
15%
5+
11%
4+
3%
3+
2%
2+
0%
1+
11%
Last Updated
October 15th 2023, 6:33pm
Image [Report Inappropriate Content]
Genre
Categories
Category Recommendations
Matsu no Ma
Wanshang Cai Shi Nv Haizi
To My First Love
Amai Sasayaki (NINOMIYA Hikaru)
Epidemic Melancholy
Wanshang Cai Shi Nv Haizi
To My First Love
Amai Sasayaki (NINOMIYA Hikaru)
Epidemic Melancholy
Recommendations
N/A
Author(s)
Artist(s)
Year
2016
Original Publisher
Serialized In (magazine)
N/A
Licensed (in English)
No
English Publisher
N/A
Activity Stats (vs. other series)
Weekly Pos #765 
(+25)
Monthly Pos #1739(+151)
3 Month Pos #2287(+1102)
6 Month Pos #4640(+334)
Year Pos #7913 (No change)
(+25)Monthly Pos #1739
(+151)3 Month Pos #2287
(+1102)6 Month Pos #4640
(+334)Year Pos #7913 (No change)
List Stats
Forum Posts Click to view the forum
No topics currently in the forum, view the forum or add a new topic now.
User Comments
[
Order by usefulness ]
You must login to comment for this series! Register an account.
Man the positive reviews are really making me wonder if I missed something when I read this comic. Because as far as shounen ai goes this was pretty below average, both plot and character wise. It wasn't even that I found it annoying, the execution was just kinda... nonsensical? A lot of plot points that were resolved super hastily, a lot of plot points that weren't resolved at all.
The ending makes you want to scream "THAT'S IT?!"
It has Good Wonderful Ending, just a bit rushed. Makes you questioning their future and the conditions of the protagonist of how and why that happened and things.
The Two Main Characters pretty likable. So is the Doctor.
So yeah, it was Still a Very Good Story with Interesting plot, but still left some questions unanswered.
It has Good Wonderful Ending, just a bit rushed. Makes you questioning their future and the conditions of the protagonist of how and why that happened and things.
The Two Main Characters pretty likable. So is the Doctor.
So yeah, it was Still a Very Good Story with Interesting plot, but still left some questions unanswered.
This had such a good premise... The beginning was pretty good, going at a slow pace and all. But I think the author just didn't know what to do with the plot anymore and just rushed everything so that it would finish quickly. A lot of questions got left unanswered too, like
The secondary characters had a lot of potential too, like the MC's doctor x his uncle, the male lead's best friends, the blue haired guy from MC's high school, etc. But the author didn't develop these characters at all so it was very disappointing.
Overall, this was so promising, but I think the author just didn't want to keep it going because they just didn't know what to do with the plot, a bit disappointing tbh :/
... Last updated on September 7th, 2018, 7:15pm
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
Why doesn't his heart beat? Why does it only beat when he is with the other guy? What happened to his uncle before that he is so obsessed with his nephew? What really happened to his parents?
The secondary characters had a lot of potential too, like the MC's doctor x his uncle, the male lead's best friends, the blue haired guy from MC's high school, etc. But the author didn't develop these characters at all so it was very disappointing.
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
I specifically wished they would show more about the doctor and the uncle's relationship too, like how did their relationship start and how would his uncle finally let go of his obsession with finding a cure.
Overall, this was so promising, but I think the author just didn't want to keep it going because they just didn't know what to do with the plot, a bit disappointing tbh :/
... Last updated on September 7th, 2018, 7:15pm
Whats not to love?? The story is based on a concept that is very unrealistic, but the writer does a great job with making it seem believable. I mean, how can a person be alive if their heart doesn't beat?!?!?
Heart Silent is a fluffy and heartfelt manga with just a bit of angst and confusion. The confusion is to be expected for a sci-fi-ish romance after all. The pairing isn't exactly normal, but it makes sense with the circumstances. I have a thing for straight x straight pairings, and this pairing is pretty darn cute!!
Not too much to complain about, except maybe wanting more "H" scenes, but that doesn't take away from the story. Pretty good for a digital comic in my opinion!
Heart Silent is a fluffy and heartfelt manga with just a bit of angst and confusion. The confusion is to be expected for a sci-fi-ish romance after all. The pairing isn't exactly normal, but it makes sense with the circumstances. I have a thing for straight x straight pairings, and this pairing is pretty darn cute!!
Not too much to complain about, except maybe wanting more "H" scenes, but that doesn't take away from the story. Pretty good for a digital comic in my opinion!
You must login to comment for this series! Register an account.
