I assume this was suppose to be more of a supplement to the novel as it really cannot stand up by itself. Don't waste your time unless you're an emotional sap that cries over dead bugs and broken pencils since I can't imagine anyone else being moved by this version.

The "art" is god awful and the romance paper thin. You'd think with so many romance+deadly disease stories out there they could copy tropes better than this. Manga has never been strict on human proportions but the terribly square figures of the characters makes me wonder how this ever got published.

Both the movies My Girl and I (Korean) and Sekai no Chuushin de, Ai o Sakebu (Japanese, same title) had much more impact than this manga did.

I felt that the mangaka artist tried too hard to make the emotion clear when, if they just could have kept it simple, would have made it a lot better. It seemed there was no emotion from the main protagonists - they just accepted the fate and moved on until the end.

At least in the movies, they were more distraught about this kind of thing, I suppose. Either way, it was an all right read, but it didn't make me sob or anything.

Though i didn't really read the romancy parts, it seemed to drag on, i really love this manga. it was so bittersweet! it is a really sweet romance with an amazingly tragic ending.

It's actually really good; one of the more sad manga I've read and I'm impressed. Most Shoujo can get really annoying, and usually I tend to prefer a fast-paced shounen manga, but this was great! It was touching, and one of the few manga that made me cry. The art wasn't the best, but I was sucked into the cute romance and cried as Aki had her final moments, even though the pictures were really... bleh...



One of the best manga I've read, and I strongly recomend it.

hey guys I'm new here...and I really want to read this manga...I already watch the drama version of it...and *sigh*...it makes me depressed for a months because its really awesome...its so sad and touching...pls...i dont know where or how to open to read this manga....pls help me^^

... Last updated on August 20th, 2008, 7:19am

Its absolutely brilliant the looking back thing at first i thought i'll be bored with it coz i already know the end result but the emotions and the way the guy just knows and remembers his first love is enough to make you cry.. writing was also top notch.. i'd love to watch an ova of this please someone make one!

It wasn't that sad or even touching at all. I felt they tried very hard to make it a story with meaning but ultimately, there just weren't enough moments and events to really convey their feelings for one another. Instead, what we got was a chunk of narration from his perspective and some tidbits of her feelings for him.

And to me, the worst parts of the story were these:

the "darkness" is really depressing and everytime he main guy sees it, I start to get all sappy & teary.
It was really sad seeing all that after seeing how uch in love & how close they got... =(

one of the first manga i ever read. i loved it. i cried a bit, but that only makes it ten kagillion times better in my opinion. i really want to re-read it quite a few times more. it is definitely worth your time. =)