The art doesn't have anything special on it. The story starts normal, even cliche, but with time you start to notice special things, like how the world is worked on it, he always talk about the abandoned country (city?) and how things are hard there, you notice he had the power to see the future but Wonwoo just ignores it. It was really poetic, how the characters think specially, it isn't for anyone to read,

To end this, if you don't like to cry or to read tragic stories don't even try to read this one, you'll be disappointed. (It's a beautiful one if you do appreciate it)

This one manhwa sure is something different from the bunch. The definition of a "happy ending" is the central spirit leading the whole series on and off, thus making quite an impact when it truly and finally hit the readers at the end. I have to admit I did feel it strongly knock me over despite still having both feet on the ground. That really isn't an easy feeling to describe accurately. The firm yet calm aftershock in everyone's mind after reading is exactly what the author wanted to achieve and I dare say she had overwhelmingly succeeded, in striking me at least. The characters surprisingly have much stronger personalities than the usual paper thin one dimensional as well, and that doesn't only apply to main characters. I seriously think this is one piece of work worth being looked into and explored deeper, I'm sure as we peel off each layer while doing so there'd still be more to come, unexpectedly even.

... Aside from the desparate longing of the characters for something, that is hardly for them to reach or likely to happen, the two volumes seemed lost at some points. I especially liked, how the artist was able to express the emotions of the characters, while the gender didn't really matter. That's a rare thing for the genre and worth of praise, IMO. And, the ending wasn't that tragic in my eyes. It was more like the longing finally was ending and this in a way, that leaves space for the readers own thoughts. I liked it actually.

The artwork was clean and matching the whole atmosphere well, so in the end there is nothing to regret about picking this read up. ^^

I have read this series in one go, but when I was thinking about how to rate it, I had to stop for a moment and give it some consideradion, which is rather unusual for me.

It's not that the plot was particulary to my liking or that I instantly fell in love with any particular element of the manhwa - frankly speaking after finishing the whole thing I had no idea what to make of it. The art is quite good and it was definitely one of the reasons why I've decided to read it, but is still wasn't to the point that one would continue reading even if the story was absolutely horrid.

I think that the real strenght of this manhwa lies in the way that it grabs the reader's attention, without them being aware of it. I believe that the confusion I've felt after finishing and the sole fact that I've bothered to write this review are good indicators of its quality.

... Last updated on July 2nd, 2013, 5:14am

I definitely like this one. It is - as you may suspect from the tags - a tragedy. And yes it is sad.
However it is also, at least to some extent, a happy ending for the protagonists.

If you like fluff and happy-go-lucky characters, this one's not for you. If you like something deeper and mature, then I think this is a great read.

It says happy ending as the title so I expected a happy ending and I found myself crying at the end instead.
If only I knew I wouldn't have completed this.I would have left it to my imagination.
Why it didn't have to be a tragedy.if you are someone like me that likes comedy and happy stories I don't recommend this for you but if you can handle bittersweet tradegies you have to read this

This manhwa made an impression on me. I think. I am still wondering.
At least I know, that I don't really know whether I like it or not. I'm left with this feeling of wanting to cry because of the ending and yet I just feel empty - which I don't know whether is good or bad either. Don't really know if I make sense or not XD
Throughout the story, there was a constant gentle and calm atmosphere which I honestly didn't like at the beginning since I just felt that the story was monotone and boring. Yet after having read the whole thing I woudn't want to change anything. The characters seem pretty expressionless at first glance, but if you pay attention to them, you will definitely notice their complexed personalities.

Actually, I think I like this manhwa XD It's very beautiful, but it will definitely not suit everyone's taste. Thought I don't think I can rate this series.

I expecte somethings more in this story, but it was really weird.
even the end, i did'nt understand what happen.

the story itself was good, but i would'nt recommande it....

The ending is especially unique. I didn't even get the chance to feel sad or angry. Everything ended so quickly, in the blink of an eye, but I'm sure the author wanted to give us that effect. You'll obviously know what I mean once you finish reading it and actually stop to think. And regarding the title...


If you cannot stand tragic stories, don't force yourself to read this one. But you're missing out on something special. It's not everyday I happen on a story such as this and I actually enjoyed it.
Also, if you don't want to stay for the art, why not give the plot a chance? I'm not overpraising this manhwa; simply saying.
I won't rate because I know I would gain someone's resentment for 'misleading' them. But all-in-all I thought this was a lovely manhwa even if it wasn't exceptional.

Maybe something was lost in translation, but this story felt rather bland, confusing and weird-paced to me. I never really got into the story. The conversations seemed awkward. I really don't know why there are so many people fussing about this manhwa. The only special thing about this piece is that it's in full color, but the art isn't even that good.

I'm a bit disappointed, I must say.