I've only read the first couple of chapters but this manga seems really interesting. But kind of creepy. And I have no idea what's going on... the writing seems a bit unnatural but that could be intentional for the atmostphere; it's a bit too awkward though and the story doesn't flow well at all.

... Last updated on July 13th, 2009, 4:51pm

Really really interesting! its rare for me to be so attached to a manga after one chapter at first i though it was a bit clique with the whole old friend comes back after a long time and the train thing but in the middle its gets really intriguing and in an instant i was hooked, but then the 1st chapter had to end and i was left wanting more to read >_<

... Last updated on November 14th, 2008, 9:12pm

I've personally wanted to read another one of Shimotsuki-sensei's works, Coelacanth, for quite some time now... So when the first chapter of this story was released, I immediately pounced upon it. And to tell the truth, it's *very* promising--the first chapter ends on a pretty intense cliffhanger, and there's a lot of mystery surrounding the club, and Chiharu. And the art is beautiful, with very excellent use of black and white, and screen tones. Chiyoko is adorable, and Chiharu is very cute. Plus, the interactions between characters are skillfully done, and Shimotsuki-sensei not only conveys their personality, but makes it seem very realistic, and makes you quickly become emotionally invested in the characters. I could very easily imagine (only certain xD) scenes happening in my own life, which is something that I usually can't say about most mangas.. but that doesn't mean that it's boring, just that it's that realistic and powerful, without losing the reader's interest or becoming like any typical, over-ly cliched shoujo.

I'm extremely interested to see how this story progresses, and how the relationship between Chiyoko and Chiharu deepens, and I recommend it to anyone who likes a little intrigue.

I've only read ch01 so far but I'm really intrigue by the plot, I believe that the story has a lot to offer and the style of the art is very nice ^^

I will edit this post once more chapter are release.