manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
For background art in manga, you prefer...
Lots of detail
An average amount of detail
Very little detail
Sparkles and patterns that fit the mood is just fine
I don't really pay attention to the backgrounds
I don't care
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Manga vs. Manwha/Manhua

Back to Manga General


Poll
What are your reading preferences?
I am a purist: I only read Manga
I prefer Manga, but I'll also read Manwha/Manhua
I have no preference! Anything is good, gimme gimme!
Hah! I actually prefer Manwha/Manhua you loser!
You must login to vote.

Pages (4) [ 1 2 3 4 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
PoshSam
Post #367443
Member

3:50 am, Mar 30 2010
Posts: 165


I used to be quite gung-ho about korean manwha a few years back, I used to read as many as I could get my hands on, but then I came to a conclusion, korean manwha's certainly have much stronger heroines(they are always delinquents, beat guys up all the time, scary..), and do have a sense of humour that rivals with manga, but they are terrible at realism and endings.
Seriously, most of them I read have stupid endings that make you feel you've wasted your time, and I like a little fantasy in my stories, but I also want to be able to relate to the characters aswell on SOME level, sometimes I want the characters to have realistic thoughts and not be jumpy all the time...and the art may be pretty but let's be honest, everyone is a flipping model in manwhas, even manga has normal average looking people, manwha's wouldn't dream of showing someone non-gorgeous.
I'm always disappointed when I read an interesting summary and then find it's a manwha, because I know it'll get sucky somewhere.
I'll try thinking of one manwha that hasn't been a let-down...

blakraven66
Post #367461
user avatar
Omnipresent
 Super Mod

5:12 am, Mar 30 2010
Posts: 6118


Why did you lump manhwa and manhua together?

________________
User Posted Image
haru-sama
Post #370298
user avatar
narcissist
Member

6:50 am, Apr 11 2010
Posts: 49


Well, I read mostly manga just because I prefer manga's art style most of the time. I feel so short when I read manhwa.... and they all have these crazy faces that I just can't stick on Koreans.. I MEAN DON'T THEY USUALLY HAVE SINGLE EYELIDS? But they still dress as good as ever.

________________
avatar's from kaiyorihito kaiyorishiki
KittyTeea
Post #370303
user avatar
Member

7:09 am, Apr 11 2010
Posts: 254


Personaly I read anything or at least try it if the sinopsis is good enough, but I prefer manga because I love comedies and korean works tend to be dramatic.

Also what's the difference between manhwa and manhua? I still can't figure it out. Plz tell.

________________
User Posted Image

I love vampires.
Yenoh
Post #370329
user avatar
Taro
 Member

8:11 am, Apr 11 2010
Posts: 1966


I tend to read manga more often than manhwa because there are waaay more. But it doesn't really matter whether it's manhua/manhwa/or manga as long as the story's good, it's fine.

Aikanaro
Post #370335
Member

8:23 am, Apr 11 2010
Posts: 543


I just like comics - I don't care in the slightest where they came from so long as they're good.

Toto
Post #370341
user avatar
Site Admin

8:34 am, Apr 11 2010
Posts: 2276


@KittyTeea: You need to learn how to google if you don't know something. If you still can't find an answer, then you should ask.

http://www.google.com/search?q=manhwa+vs+manhua




As for me, I'll go with manga mostly, as I'm more exposed to Japan's regional comics; however, even within a given regional work, there are different styles that can be attributed to another's... or something completely different.

I'm also a sucker for Rain's watercolors.

Last edited by Toto at 10:37 am, Mar 31

________________
"Officially, this machine doesn't exist, you didn't get it from me,
and I don't know you. Make sure it doesn't leave the building."
Ryou91_Sh1k1
Post #457801
Member

8:54 am, Mar 31 2011
Posts: 1


manga no contest.
there are some that are good like shin angyo onshi, but nothing like masterpiece.
and most of manhwa is similiar to each other, tell me if there is manhwa about american football.
hell, how about unique storytelling like oyasumi pun pun?
if there are any manhwa out there that as great as monster, berserk, vagabond, bokurano, ykk, aria then we talk.
but that kinda overkill, i guess.


Binturong
Post #458011
user avatar
Member

6:18 am, Apr 1 2011
Posts: 703


Manga is clearly superior in all categories.

________________
User Posted Image
ForteAtrox
Post #458013
user avatar
Pew pew
Member

6:21 am, Apr 1 2011
Posts: 828


It doesn't matter.
The only thing that's really different is the direction that you read it from...

Does webtoons count as manhwa or is it their own category? Because it's clearly far different from the typical Korean manhwa you would see nowadays.

________________
User Posted Image
Vallan.Mandrake
Post #465642
Member

12:18 am, May 2 2011
Posts: 4


well I do not care where they are from ...
but most manhwa have that boring-all the same romance drama plot without deep characters... and webtoons are compleatly different.

Grumpy
Post #465744
user avatar
rawr
Member

6:45 am, May 2 2011
Posts: 161


manhwa really just means comics from korea. webtoons that are from korea are comics from korea. Therefore, would classify under manhwa. Webtoons are not exclusive to korea btw.

also @haru-sama, No, not all Koreans have single eyelids. The fold that makes "double eyelid" is rather common in korea and is not a result of plastic surgery... I have double eyelids.
-------------
on topic, I read everything. Manga, manhwa, manhua, american, german, etc... The entire topic seems rather trying to make stereotypes though. Reality is, people are different, and comic authors and artists are different people. You need to evaluate the authors, not the origin -- and perhaps their budgets.

________________
The Company
[b]Batoto
shiro_13
Post #465750
user avatar
Member

7:32 am, May 2 2011
Posts: 35


i'll go with manga..smile

________________
everybody lies.
book_lover
Post #465751
user avatar
Member

7:37 am, May 2 2011
Posts: 337


To say that manga is superior to manwha/manhua is a huge generalization. There are bad and good series in all these genres. It depends on the author/artist and not the country they are from.

I will say that there are probably certain conventions and clichés in each country, but a good author would twist them/avoid them/use them well so that they don't drag down the story, maybe even enhancing it.

Some examples of excellent manwha and manhua include Savage Garden, Absolute Witch, Noblesse (webcomics count), Saver, 1/2 Prince and Youth Gone Wild. Of course, there are also many excellent manga biggrin

Last edited by book_lover at 7:50 am, May 2

scav
Post #465755
Member

8:24 am, May 2 2011
Posts: 1


even thought im a huge fan of One piece, i voted for manhwas cuz actually i don't see any good mangas, except those that i've been reading since years like (one piece, berserk, gantz, gto, hajime no ippo, gunnm last order etc...). the only recent mangas that i liked is Bakuman.

also i think people shouldn't judge manhwa if they don't know thoses:

the breaker
Ares
yureka
Noblesse (web comic)
veritas
ID
P.K
the ruler of the land
zippy ziggy
legend of maian


Pages (4) [ 1 2 3 4 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Manga General  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer