at least, scanlators will be able to pick up some of TP unfinished business if no other company takes it.
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Tokyopop Ends Manga Publishing After Fourteen Years
From User
Message Body
Member
6:08 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 486
6:08 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 486
Post #461733
Member
6:15 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 1439
I don't really have enough money to collect manga... the only volume I bought from them was Shiawase Kissa Sanchoume Vol. 4 because Borders was closing near-by...
Most of the other series I'm collecting come from Viz and Yen Press, so yeah...
But it is pretty sad. They did publish Fruits Basket which I'm planning on collecting later on... but other than that... I'm pretty neutral with this news... I do hope those who get laid-off can find work in this economy...
Most of the other series I'm collecting come from Viz and Yen Press, so yeah...
But it is pretty sad. They did publish Fruits Basket which I'm planning on collecting later on... but other than that... I'm pretty neutral with this news... I do hope those who get laid-off can find work in this economy...
Member
6:26 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 69
6:26 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 69
Quote from hobbitelf518
I don't really have enough money to collect manga... the only volume I bought from them was Shiawase Kissa Sanchoume Vol. 4 because Borders was closing near-by...
Most of the other series I'm collecting come from Viz and Yen Press, so yeah...
But it is pretty sad. They did publish Fruits Basket which I'm planning on collecting later on... but other than that... I'm pretty neutral with this news... I do hope those who get laid-off can find work in this economy...
Most of the other series I'm collecting come from Viz and Yen Press, so yeah...
But it is pretty sad. They did publish Fruits Basket which I'm planning on collecting later on... but other than that... I'm pretty neutral with this news... I do hope those who get laid-off can find work in this economy...
i totally forgot about fruits basket! omg i have to buy the rest now. and i'll probably never get x-day again since it's out of print. i pray the prices don't spike, crap i need to buy stuff now. invu, honey mustard etc. so glad i own mars
i read more stuff from VIZ but i really am going to miss them not that i realize it ;(
Post #461739
RIP
Member
6:51 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 4917
There is not a single thing I buy from them anyway. I do own Love Hina, but since then, not a single thing worth buying. Everything comes from Del Ray, Viz, Yen Press, and Dark Horse now.
Member
6:51 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 774
Post #461744
Crap... That's a shame. I only have 5 Tokyopop series though, all of which are completed, so it's no big deal for me, but still, it's bad news. I hope somebody else picks up their releases.
________________
________________
Member
7:08 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 8
They're really stopping manga production? What about their light novel translations? Argh, Swell... Just when I took the chance at buying a ongoing series, they decide to stop publishing. I have a few light novels from them that are still in progress too. *sigh*
Well, I can't say they were a very good manga publisher cause the manga that I was getting from them always had switched and missing dialogue and lazy translating but I still liked what I read online enough to still buy the official translation of it.
I know it's not logical but I wish that they'd finish the series they've got before ending production.
Well, I can't say they were a very good manga publisher cause the manga that I was getting from them always had switched and missing dialogue and lazy translating but I still liked what I read online enough to still buy the official translation of it.
I know it's not logical but I wish that they'd finish the series they've got before ending production.
Member
7:23 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 641
Quote from ForteAtrox
o_o Not defending them or anything, but can anyone tell me specifically the reason why they were bad?
1) The flipped the manga.
2) They edited the content of the series, taking out entire chunks of story at times and changing the dialogues to make new stories.
3) They bought up a ton of licenses and forced scanlators to cease translations when they haven't released any volumes of their own.
4) They've canceled series suddenly with no reason given nor releasing the said licenses so other companies can pick up the localization.
5) Their release schedule doesn't benefit the series, taking over a year or two to release something that has several volumes in the native language already just makes people lose interest in it even more.
6) The amount of crap "manga" (badly drawn western comic in manga format) they flooded the market with was and still is an insult the the term "manga" in my opinion. If they had sold it as "comic" then no probs, but just the fact they tried to use "manga" to sell their own crap was absurd.
There are more things that they did that pissed people off, I'm just stopping here because I don't want to remember all the terrible crap they shoved down people's throats.
________________
Member
9:12 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 121
9:12 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 121
Quote from greydrak
1) The flipped the manga.
You do realize that Tokyopop was the first company to actually use the unflipped, original Japanese way of reading manga, right? Before that every company that released manga had it in standard American comic book format.
Site Admin
9:21 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 2275
Quote from ForteAtrox
o_o Not defending them or anything, but can anyone tell me specifically the reason why they were bad?
For me... Initial D
________________
"Officially, this machine doesn't exist, you didn't get it from me,
and I don't know you. Make sure it doesn't leave the building."
Pew pew
Member
9:47 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 883
Quote from greydrak
Quote from ForteAtrox
o_o Not defending them or anything, but can anyone tell me specifically the reason why they were bad?
1) The flipped the manga.
2) They edited the content of the series, taking out entire chunks of story at times and changing the dialogues to make new stories.
3) They bought up a ton of licenses and forced scanlators to cease translations when they haven't released any volumes of their own.
4) They've canceled series suddenly with no reason given nor releasing the said licenses so other companies can pick up the localization.
5) Their release schedule doesn't benefit the series, taking over a year or two to release something that has several volumes in the native language already just makes people lose interest in it even more.
6) The amount of crap "manga" (badly drawn western comic in manga format) they flooded the market with was and still is an insult the the term "manga" in my opinion. If they had sold it as "comic" then no probs, but just the fact they tried to use "manga" to sell their own crap was absurd.
There are more things that they did that pissed people off, I'm just stopping here because I don't
want to remember all the terrible crap they shoved down people's throats.
.... Wow. ._.
Post #461777
Member
10:11 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 128
They printed it on recycled paper and charged so much more.
Well, not like I really hate them or anything. On one hand, I don't really care about TP since I buy mostly the Japanese version. On the other hand, I bought Kindaichi from them, so they really shouldn't go down before they finish publishing it.
Well, not like I really hate them or anything. On one hand, I don't really care about TP since I buy mostly the Japanese version. On the other hand, I bought Kindaichi from them, so they really shouldn't go down before they finish publishing it.
Post #461778
AKA Roseille
Member
10:19 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 326
I respect Tokyopop. They licensed some of the most amazing and underrated series I've ever read (namely, The Embalmer and Immortal Rain, as well as a recent interest, Demon Sacred) and seemed reliable and interesting.
I really will miss them, but I'll survive—I just ordered a ton of RAW manga, so there's not too much that can make me tragically unhappy right now.
RIP, Tokyopop. I loved you while you lived. Thank you for bringing things like The Embalmer to the English-speaking world.
________________
≡ Youtube ≡ DeviantART ≡ Roseille Scans
I really will miss them, but I'll survive—I just ordered a ton of RAW manga, so there's not too much that can make me tragically unhappy right now.
RIP, Tokyopop. I loved you while you lived. Thank you for bringing things like The Embalmer to the English-speaking world.
________________
≡ Youtube ≡ DeviantART ≡ Roseille Scans
Post #461780
Member
11:09 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 40
It's too bad Tokyopop turned into this, and drove themselves into the ground. I really liked them when they first started, they really catered to the manga community unlike the POS Viz publishing. I don't know how Viz is now since I swore off of them a really long time ago, but anyone remembering Viz's really really early days they were doing exactly what Tokyopop is doing now, except they wouldn't even keep the manga in it's original reading order and cut out huge swaths of chapters.
Anyways, there really needs to be a new business model for the US version of manga. Spending a $1000 on manga that gave you enough to only casually read through in two weeks is not sustainable for any kind of manga fan no matter how devoted.
Anyways, there really needs to be a new business model for the US version of manga. Spending a $1000 on manga that gave you enough to only casually read through in two weeks is not sustainable for any kind of manga fan no matter how devoted.
Member
11:36 pm, Apr 15 2011
Posts: 95
this is so upsetting.
Search
- MANGA Fu
- News
- What's New!
- Series Stats
- Forums
- Releases
- Scanlators
- Series Info
- Mangaka
- Publishers
- Reviews
- Genres
- Categories
- FAQ
- Members
- API
- MEMBERS
- Sign Up
- TEAM-BU
- Admin CP
- About Us