manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
Which kind of story would you find more interesting
Dystopia
Utopia
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Popular shojos you just don't like?

Back to Shoujo/Josei


Pages (35) [ First ... 31 32 33 34 35 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Aglaia
Post #637240
user avatar
Member

5:26 pm, Mar 23 2014
Posts: 6


Kimi Ni Todoke (honestly it seems to me that the bgs get more screentime and some of the scenes are just way too slow! )
Mars (I'm probably going to be hated for saying this. but for some reason I just couldn't get past the third or was it the fourth volume. I keep hearing it's awesome but I fail to see it)

I kind of don't tend to like the all too mainstream "Oh my God. He's so popular, he's so cute/cool and he'll never notice someone like me." and then the guy is all 'pretending not to like her' but then giving out pretty obvious signs otherwise. >.<

________________
Defeat your foes with randomness and lightning fast typing speed.
evilcleo
Post #640279
Member

1:31 am, Apr 25 2014
Posts: 87


I could never understand the appeal of skip beat. It became an overblown party of cliches with characters that lack appeal. I don't mind cliche stuff but if it continues like a cycle again and again for 200+ chapters, it gets really old. And I don't know if the heroine is really that strong; I'd call her opinionated with an annoyingly loud voice and attitude.

The shoujo I truly hate though is itazura na kiss. I can't stand the guy. The girl chases him but gives up 3-4 times but in his arrogance he convinces her to try again, only to go back to hating her every single time. Finally he gets with her but never bothers to explain why even though he liked her all this time, he never went for it. Even when they're married, he acts like this distant figure who is like "oh, you're still here?" or "do you want something?"

Kaichou wa maid-sama was good until chapter 50ish. After that it just got old. Same for Usotuski lily. Not usually for gender benders but the characters were fun, gags funny, and the cross dressing incidents were entertaining...until like chapter 40. Unlike the mangaka behind kaichou though, who knew when to end it before it truly got bad, she just continued with lazy, filler like material with too many chapters about the side characters and 4-koma comics.

I like special A in small doses. Their idiocy is funny and Kei is so awesome when he's jealous. It's great that although he has everything, he has eyes for this dense girl with a lot of spirit.

Black bird..no. I'll take a weak naive girl but I won't take a weak,naive girl without a personality. Stepping on roses and faster than a kiss were good for a while but the endings absolutely sucked. I wouldn't have read those two if I knew how it ended. They were so bad, they ruined the entire manga.

Last edited by evilcleo at 1:46 am, Apr 25

shoutoshiro
Post #642316
user avatar
Member

4:58 am, May 18 2014
Posts: 55


Definitely Hiyokoi. I don't need to give a reason.

________________
“If I'm going to just live taking someone else's place, then it'd be better if I could just be a pebble. That way, there'd be neither misunderstanding nor confusion, and then even you wouldn't know me.” – Eine Kleine (Kenshi Yonezu)
OrchardPetalLullaby
Post #642325
user avatar
Member

5:44 am, May 18 2014
Posts: 202


Black Bird - got boring
Kaichou wa maid-sama - got boring
Special A - It's just stupid in my opinion
Shugo Chara! - Hated the concept. Never read it.
Koi dano Ai dano - I just can't even attempt this one.... I think I'd have to be given something I want in order to ever attempt it.
You're So Cool - ridiculous
Moe Kare!! - Pretty much anything by IKEYAMADA Go irritates/bores me.
Ingènuo - Couldn't get past a chapter


Kimi Ni Todoke and Suki tte Ii na yo started getting boring chapters ago so even though I liked the beginnings I don't think I'll ever finish them.

________________
Remembrance, a forsaken thing that revokes ignorance and leaves people in doubt, is my only redemption and solace deep within the cascade of white.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
The evergreen trees speak of days long past when music mingled with the wind and sweet murmurs brushed our cheeks.
hkanz
Post #643537
user avatar
Member

12:16 am, Jun 2 2014
Posts: 300


Kaichou wa Maid-sama - I didn't find it boring, but I was irritated by how Misaki is supposed to be a strong female character yet needs rescuing by Usui at every turn - and even more irritated by how people buy into this. I was also irritated by Usui's perfection & how he has no life outside of Misaki, also by the
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
10-year separation at the end.


Lovely Complex - Bored me, couldn't get past a few chapters. I read another by the same author in full and didn't like it either, but I've forgotten the name.

Kimi Ni Todoke - Boring, couldn't get past a few chapters.

Good Morning Call - The most formulaic, vanilla shoujo I've ever encountered (though I'm not sure that it's popular/well-known).

Kyou, Koi wa Hajimewasu or anything by this author.

Teacher's Pet or anything by this author.

Anything that, like the two above, feature an aggressive guy who rapes/abuses the girl. With the possible exception of Haou Airen since I view that less as a romance than
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
'girl gets Stockholm's syndrome and is utterly destroyed by relationship, enter tragic ending'
. That being said, I'm not going to re-read Haou Airen.

In Ouran's defense, I love it. smile The mangaka does have a cluttered style but that doesn't bother me.

Last edited by hkanz at 12:26 am, Jun 2

himemai
Post #647426
user avatar
Member

11:15 am, Jul 16 2014
Posts: 12


Popular shoujo I dislike.... let see... Vampire Knight is my first answer^^"
. I don't know why, maybe it just don't suit my taste, so I drop it asap when I found out the main lead is more and more irritating for me. I wonder why people like this manga very much.... Well, but each person have a different taste, so maybe that's why^^/


Next, perhaps Uwasa no Midori-kun (this is somewhat popular in my place) ^^" But this one... I dislike the ending, because the main lead isn't end up with the one I want. I just feel so empty. Some of my friends do feel the way I feel. So, this one is totally because the main lead end up with the different person.

________________
-------◦(..˘ ▿ ˘..)◦◦(..˘ ▿ ˘..)◦-------
I'm only read scan when that book isn't published in Indonesia or I just can't borrow that book.

I love reading first then buy it after I know the story ♥
MissModern
Post #649224
user avatar
Procrastinating
Member

11:32 pm, Aug 6 2014
Posts: 25


Moe Kare!!, Kyou, Koi o Hajimemasu, and Black Bird stuff like that annoys me.

________________
User Posted Image
Book_girl
Post #649229
user avatar
Member

2:00 am, Aug 7 2014
Posts: 11


So many! I stopped reading all of these:

Ao Haru Ride and Vampire Knight because of the love triangles.
Skip Beat and Kimi ni Todoke were way too slow and dragging.
Bokura ga Ita and Mars had unnecessary melodrama.
Gakuen Alice, Mairunovich, Honey Hunt, and Stepping on Roses pissed me off so much (weak females)
Say I love you was too smutty.

I did finish Fruits Basket, but I didn't like the manga at all. I wish I would have just stopped with the anime. Drama overload and the couples sucked (same with Hana Yori Dango) Oh and I loathed Hot Gimmick with a passion... that was seriously the worst ending ever.

Last edited by Book_girl at 2:05 am, Aug 7

Azure_1802
Post #649531
Member

6:39 pm, Aug 10 2014
Posts: 12


Ao Haru Ride - too complicated
Kaichou wa maid sama - annoying characters
Special A - too many unnesessary supporting details and supporting characters
Vampire Knight - I just can't swallow it
Say I love you - I dislike the art and the plot
Saiunkoku Monogatari - I don't think the artwork is good, characters' faces are the same -.-
Gakuen Alice - I hate main characters, I hate kids' romance -.-
Shugo Chara - Female lead's stupid
Hanagimi to koisuru watashi - I liked its first chapters, but after they are dating, it become boring
His and her circumstand - i felt really depressed when i read it sad
Hirunaka no ryuusei - I disappointed, the female lead's not as cool as I thought sad
Usotsuki Lily - meh
Tonari no Kaibutsu kun - I really really love the art, but I can't resist the characters
Akatsuki no Yona - useless female lead
Akagami no Shirayukihime - boring
Kiniro no corda - What's the meaning of reverse harem? =_=
Dengeki Daisy - errh...
Dear mine - cliche
Liar x Liar - It does not suit my taste
Tokyo crazy paradise - *facepalm*

oh my... i read almost all the famous shoujo manga and i disliked most of them -.-

roguewolf
Post #651178
Member

1:47 am, Sep 2 2014
Posts: 35


Hibi Chouchou. I love the art. But a piece of toast has most personality than Suiren does.

Jolty Febe
Post #652288 - Reply to (#651178) by roguewolf
user avatar
Member

11:41 pm, Sep 17 2014
Posts: 16


Absolute Boyfriend with a passion-- I read MOST of it but it never grabbed my attention and just seemed to drag on...yes the ending was unexpected but the rest of the whole thing sucked. Even the mangaka admitted she couldn't decide who the MC was going to end up with and the MC was so indecisive and annoying:/

meshy
Post #652295
user avatar
Just another lazy
Member

1:28 am, Sep 18 2014
Posts: 57


Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu. Blegh dead. Dropped it when I saw what kind of person the male MC was.

________________
"In our nature, however, there is a provision, alike marvellous and merciful, that the sufferer should never know the intensity of what he endures by its present torture, but chiefly by the pang that rankles after it." -The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne
The lord of awesome
Post #652398
Member

5:23 pm, Sep 19 2014
Posts: 4


I do not like skip beat or kitchen princess. I actually only read kitchen princess because I heard one of the main guys die.

@Aglaia
Quote from Aglaia
Kimi Ni Todoke (honestly it seems to me that the bgs get more screentime and some of the scenes are just way too slow! ) ...

Kimi Ni Todoke was so sweet though! I loved how the "villains" were not to evil and every one became friends in the end.

Last edited by lambchopsil at 11:42 pm, Sep 19

roguewolf
Post #652410 - Reply to (#652295) by meshy
Member

9:42 pm, Sep 19 2014
Posts: 35


Quote from meshy
Kyou, Koi wo Hajimemasu. Blegh dead . Dropped it when I saw what kind of person the male MC was.


Same here. I'm okay with ridiculous cliche shoujo, but that male MC was awful.

Spoiler (mouse over to view)
He relentlessly persuaded her for months and when she finally told him she liked him he dropped her completely. All because of 'mommy issues'. I am sick of that cliche. I would love for there to be a book where the guy had issues with his mother, but he still treats women with complete respect.


I also really didn't like Hajimari no Niina. I usually don't like those kind of age differences but also

Spoiler (mouse over to view)
I never really felt like he loved her for who she was. It always seemed like he loved her because she was Chitose reincarnated. And Niina herself never got a separate identity away from Chitose.

I also didn't care much for Acchan/Chitose.


Last edited by roguewolf at 9:51 pm, Sep 19

roguewolf
Post #654997
Member

9:18 pm, Oct 27 2014
Posts: 35


I tried reading Orange Marmalade, because it was popular. But, wow. I hated it. I usually like 99% of shoujo heroines, but I hated the lead in this one. So unlikable.

Pages (35) [ First ... 31 32 33 34 35 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Shoujo/Josei  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer