manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
For background art in manga, you prefer...
Lots of detail
An average amount of detail
Very little detail
Sparkles and patterns that fit the mood is just fine
I don't really pay attention to the backgrounds
I don't care
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Naruto, Bleach, & One Piece

Back to Shounen/Seinen


Poll
the three competing manga, vote to your reasonable judgements, time to see which is the most epic !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Naruto < Bleach < One Piece
One Piece < Bleach < Naruto
Naruto < One Piece < Bleach
Bleach < Naruto < One Piece
One Piece < Naruto < Bleach
Bleach < One Piece < Naruto
You must login to vote.

Pages (10) [ First ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Lally
Post #295741
user avatar
Mahou Shoujo
Member

9:35 pm, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 62


Oh major FAIL. Just voted the exact opposite of what I was supposed to. I was always crap at Maths...

Hermit-chan
Post #295742
user avatar
Yours Truly,
Member

9:41 pm, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 2050


Does anyone ever noticed that there's more 'negative' or 'neutral' comments on the weekly chapter discussions in Bleach and Naruto MU forum threads?

something like "..pointless chapter" "waste of chapters" "going back to the XX chapters ago" "Nothing much happening" to "Finally something HAPPENS in this chapter!"

when compared to the posts in Onepiece threads which says.. either neutral posts like "Good chapter" "cant wait for next week's chapter" to positive posts like "ZOMG IT IS SO EPIC!!" "Kickass chapter!!!" "ODa is greaT!!"



________________
User Posted Image
The Hidden Agenda=Gol.D.Ace

This Week's favourite:
DoLL (Okado Tatsuya)
Xp
robbit
Post #295753 - Reply to (#295742) by Hermit-chan
user avatar
I am the Devil
 Member

10:43 pm, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 2083


Quote from Hermit-chan
Does anyone ever noticed that there's more 'negative' or 'neutral' comments on the weekly chapter discussions in Bleach and Naruto MU forum threads?

something like "..pointless chapter" "waste of chapters" "going back to the XX chapters ago" "Nothing much happening" to "Finally something HAPPENS in this chapter!"

when compared to the posts in Onepiece threads which says.. either neutral posts like "Good chapter" "cant wait for next week's chapter" to positive posts like "ZOMG IT IS SO EPIC!!" "Kickass chapter!!!" "ODa is greaT!!"


yea. funny though cuz naruto + bleach are more popular

Hermit-chan
Post #295755 - Reply to (#295753) by robbit
user avatar
Yours Truly,
Member

10:53 pm, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 2050


Quote from robbit
Quote from Hermit-chan
Does anyone ever noticed that there's more 'negative' or 'neutral' comments on the weekly chapter discussions in Bleach and Naruto MU forum threads?

something like "..pointless chapter" "waste of chapters" "going back to the XX chapters ago" "Nothing much happening" to "Finally something HAPPENS in this chapter!"

when compared to the posts in Onepiece threads which says.. either neutral posts like "Good chapter" "cant wait for next week's chapter" to positive posts like "ZOMG IT IS SO EPIC!!" "Kickass chapter!!!" "ODa is greaT!!"


yea. funny though cuz naruto + bleach are more popular


I guess there are reasons why people still following up to these mangas. I mean, I still read Naruto eventhough I skip some of the chapters or the pages for the sake of knowing what happenned to the characters rather than looking at the plot in general no

________________
User Posted Image
The Hidden Agenda=Gol.D.Ace

This Week's favourite:
DoLL (Okado Tatsuya)
Xp
kumquat
Post #295757
user avatar
 Member

11:08 pm, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 183


One Piece wins by far.
One Piece is one of my favourite manga, I look forward to reading it every week and the current arc is just so epic and it keeps getting better and better.

Next would be Naruto then Bleach. Bleach would have won over Naruto if it were at the Soul Society arc, but after that it's not the same and Naruto's been getting more interesting lately so I gave it to Naruto.

In conclusion, One Piece FTW!!!

________________
Whiskey. Tango. Foxtrot.
razornoir
Post #295761
user avatar
Member

11:16 pm, Jun 6 2009
Posts: 227


voted OP > naruto> bleach

why ? well because i'm more disapointed in these 2 série.
In Naruto and bleach i find more often useless chapter with a prize for bleach.
More useless and put your nerves on character too ( like sasuke, sakura, inoue, hitsugaya etc etc )

And the drawing in OP are far better than in bleach and Naruto.

The humour in bleach and naruto suck wich a big prize for bleach.

But well OP can be sometime repetitive ( i have a hard time starting this série honestly ) but it's still less than bleach.

ha but just for the last 10 chapter or so my vote wloud be bleach> naruto. I think recently the autor do a far better work ( short figth, better humour, better use of the 16 page he have to do each week ).


Last edited by razornoir at 11:23 pm, Jun 6

XxKumagoroXx
Post #313639
user avatar
Fujoshi ♥
Member

3:49 am, Aug 15 2009
Posts: 807


I choose Naruto because of the three I only read Naruto and Bleach. OP never really caught my attention. I hear it's a great series but I'm lazy to read 400-500 chapters of manga from the very begining. Also there's no hot guys except that blond guy. Yes, I admit it! I only watch animes with hot guys or pretty guys in it laugh I'll probably end up reading OP like in a year or two because that happened to me with Naruto.

ranigurung
Post #313678
user avatar
Member

8:30 am, Aug 15 2009
Posts: 66


one piece is best there is no chapter u can call is bore....is always exacting
there will be marine
there will be pirate
there will be manpower
there will be action that man have different kinda power differet way to fight
there will be time u will cry for whole hour
there will be time u laughing untill our stomach hurt
there will be war with power u never will be see again
there is father who wanted man
but son look idiot but he have good heart that he love family and friend
there will be cook who can cook welll fight well
there will be swordman he will fight untill he or him die
there is simple woman with wired power but she has good knowledge
there liar guy who never tired lying but when is abt friend he will never turn back
there girl who will do anything for money but she will make sure u will be save untill u get to other island
there is cute pet but he is doctor he will try best cure u even if ur his enemy
there musican he has nothing in body only bone but he will make sure
wheen wanna listen or hear song he be there for u
..........I DONT THINK BLEACH and NARUTO HAVE THOSE

NARUTO was good early before sasuke left
is has funny good thing to watch after he left is same rab over he went there save some one .......he go crazy after lookingfor sasuke ......so i get bore no more naruto forme

BLEACH.....was really cool to high school student death god power
wat will happen u can wait see ......but after 200 episode i get bore
same power they used more useless action with less thing do read ....
but art is hot
bleach after 200 episode i never watch it
naruto after suseke left is go done and stop reading
BUT ONE PIECE NEVER MAKE me BOORE
ITS GET MOORE STORY ACTION FUN .....ONE PIECE IS BEST


pokeslob
Post #315655
user avatar
Theologian
Member

2:30 am, Aug 24 2009
Posts: 104


Bleach is the best of the three!
then One Piece and then Naruto.
mainly because the art in Bleach is good, the story is cool, and its not totally overrated like Naruto.
One Piece is second just because I like it better than Naruto and not as much as bleach.
Naruto is last because it is very generic and overrated, n stuff

________________
My Top manga:
1. Yu-Gi-Oh!
2. Death Note
3. Fullmetal Alchemist
4. Bakuman.
5. Love Hina
XxKumagoroXx
Post #315657 - Reply to (#315655) by pokeslob
user avatar
Fujoshi ♥
Member

2:41 am, Aug 24 2009
Posts: 807


Quote from pokeslob
Bleach is the best of the three!
then One Piece and then Naruto.
mainly because the art in Bleach is good, the story is cool, and its not totally overrated like Naruto.
One Piece is second just because I like it better than Naruto and not as much as bleach.
Naruto is last because it is very generic and overrated, n stuff

No way...
how can tite kubo compare to either Kishimoto or One piece's mangaka? eek Have you been living under a rock? Tite Kubo is the king of trolls! Bleach manga went downhill... none

Sijy
Post #315783 - Reply to (#315657) by XxKumagoroXx
user avatar
Wakasensei
 Member

6:22 pm, Aug 24 2009
Posts: 332


Quote from XxKumagoroXx
No way...
how can tite kubo compare to either Kishimoto or One piece's mangaka? eek Have you been living under a rock? Tite Kubo is the king of trolls! Bleach manga went downhill... none


The art of Bleach is really good at times. And the powers are neat, even if the formula of them just standing around fighting over and over and over is boring. some people like it.

I still prefer one piece and naruto. But since I can't wait for either of them and spoil it before the chapter comes out, so bleach is usually a surprise to me.


________________
"because ninja who commit crimes can only be stopped by ninja who are even better" -Itachi
netj999
Post #315793
user avatar
Member

7:29 pm, Aug 24 2009
Posts: 117


One Piece > Naruto > Bleach

Well all three of these animes have been enjoyable for me, and I have been watching them since they first started airing except for One Piece.

1. One Piece is my favorite cause it's always enjoyable and very fun to watch and read. It always grabs my attention and keeps me interested. There really is never a boring chapter/episode. Also the OP fillers are a lot better than the Naruto and Bleach ones.

2. Naruto has always been pretty good. Though I have to agree that the eye power thing is getting old and lame. You can't win against someone with an eye power or new evolutions "rainbow sharingan" wth lame. Also Pain's eye for all the hype it didn't seem too special, like I know he pwned everyone except Naruto, but what did we expect. My main problem which probably a lot of people found is the 2.5 year gap. Naruto came back and he really didn't learn anything new and wasn't even that much stronger. He came back then after his first mission he went back to training, um then what was the point of leaving Konoha. Also all the filler's they have are really bad and scream Naruto is gay literally. The recent filler with Yukimaru and the crystal user, oh wow that was special. Painful to watch. Anyways the manga is getting more interesting and anime is picking up.

3. Bleach is good. Though after SS it went downhill. Cause as we all know the Hueco Mundo arc is a copy of the SS arc just with Orihime as the maiden in distress. Ichigo always gets his butt handed to him, and then when his hollow beats up his enemy for him cause he's too weak, he says "well this ain't fair cut off my arm and a leg as well". Um, hello you ain't like him he does that you are gonna die there wouldn't even be a fight, stupidest line I have ever read in a manga/anime. There fillers are just as bad as Naruto and for some odd reason Naruto did it as well they include flashbacks and/or characters from fillers into the main storyline. Also everyone says this, but the manga chapter each week is usually not very exciting and not much happens.

Overall OP is just better and more epic than Naruto and Bleach. It may sound like I was being harsh or more hypocritical about Naruto and Bleach and didn't state much about OP. Anyways that's how I rate the three in greatness and epicness. In my honest opinion is that Naruto and Bleach will never reach One Piece and never surpass it and in fact no anime probably ever will. We will have to see about it when Fairy Tail's anime starts. Most likely won't be better than OP, but I can see it taking over Bleach or Naruto's place. Also manga's very good and interesting.

AnimeMusicLuv
Post #318347
user avatar
Orange
 Member

5:16 pm, Sep 4 2009
Posts: 405


Naruto is the only manga I'm following, back then i used to follow Bleach, but i lost it..to much fights damn it!
and One Piece is the ultimate adventure, funny etc, but i'm too lazy to start it=D

________________
shuuu~
User Posted Image
ArtieBoy
Post #337350 - Reply to (#98737) by gjoerulv
Member

10:18 am, Nov 24 2009
Posts: 20


Quote from gjoerulv
I never got the big deal with OP. I'm not saying it's bad, it's just way too shounen for me. It's like Oda has a "how-to-make-a-stereotypical-shounen" look up book. The 1st arc with Zorro was great, then it went downhill in a decent pace, and now it's a flatliner imo. I haven't liked it much since the crew got to grand line. It's overkill emotional as well. The arts are very original though.

Bleach was kinda slow in the beginning, but got better pretty quick. The ss arc was overall great, but had it's dull moments too. It should have enden then, 'cause now it's going nowhere really fast. Recently though it's been somewhat intresting, though it's pretty much ss all over again. The art is very standard mangaish too.

Naruto is the most original considering they all are shounen. Kishimoto actually dares to make antiheroes, useless characters and kill 'em. It had a good start with lots of swings. The story may seem deeper than what it actually is, and is interpreted this way too. The thing is that mabye too much is left to the readers imagenation, and that isn't common in main stream shounens. biggrin cool


Alot of naruto concepts came from hunter x hunter and Dragon Ball. I don't see the originality in copying.

I'm gonna go with One Piece. Because the story isnt about some KID trying to SAVE the WORLD. and there powers are the most original



averyk
Post #337351
user avatar
Member

10:24 am, Nov 24 2009
Posts: 215


truthfully i have trouble answering this since it is always a changing answer.

Pages (10) [ First ... 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Shounen/Seinen  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer