manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
For background art in manga, you prefer...
Lots of detail
An average amount of detail
Very little detail
Sparkles and patterns that fit the mood is just fine
I don't really pay attention to the backgrounds
I don't care
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Best harem manga (please choose one)

Back to Manga General


Pages (14) [ First ... 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
loosecannon504
Post #279415 - Reply to (#279412) by x0mbiec0rp
user avatar
The Gorilla Killa™
Member

1:03 am, Apr 23 2009
Posts: 3228


Quote from x0mbiec0rp
Quote from trunks84
Ichigo 100%. Reason: read the manga, it speaks for itself. And if you disagree cause of the ending then just mature a little since life doesn't always play out the way you want.

What if I disagree because I disliked the main character? Is that not allowed?

I second x0mbiec0rp. You come off as a fanboy who thinks that anyone who doesn't like the ending is immature, instead of the fact that they just have a different opinion than you. none

________________
Quote from Klapzi
The cool part is that I never get tired of being deceived

Quote from tactics
Just because someone's head was chopped off doesn't mean they're dead. That's just silly.

User Posted Image
trunks84
Post #279443 - Reply to (#279412) by x0mbiec0rp
user avatar
Member

2:22 am, Apr 23 2009
Posts: 34


Quote from x0mbiec0rp
Quote from trunks84
Ichigo 100%. Reason: read the manga, it speaks for itself. And if you disagree cause of the ending then just mature a little since life doesn't always play out the way you want.

What if I disagree because I disliked the main character? Is that not allowed?


I have no beaf with people who dislike the manga for well sounded reasons like that the main character wasn't their cup of tea cause he was to undecisive or cause he was to timid.

Quote from loosecannon504
I second x0mbiec0rp. You come off as a fanboy who thinks that anyone who doesn't like the ending is immature, instead of the fact that they just have a different opinion than you. none


Well i prefer it over sounding like a fanboy of the others cause someone disagrees with their preference. I don't see how you came to that conclusion since I never said anything about personal preference of which one he should've ended with. Seems you're just attacking me cause you were an Aya fan so who's the real fanboy? And yeah I do find people that hate the manga cause he just didn't end up with their personal preference immature.



Last edited by trunks84 at 2:46 am, Apr 23

________________
User Posted Image
loosecannon504
Post #279499 - Reply to (#279443) by trunks84
user avatar
The Gorilla Killa™
Member

5:26 am, Apr 23 2009
Posts: 3228


Quote from trunks84
Quote from loosecannon504
I second x0mbiec0rp. You come off as a fanboy who thinks that anyone who doesn't like the ending is immature, instead of the fact that they just have a different opinion than you. none


Well i prefer it over sounding like a fanboy of the others cause someone disagrees with their preference. I don't see how you came to that conclusion since I never said anything about personal preference of which one he should've ended with. Seems you're just attacking me cause you were an Aya fan so who's the real fanboy? And yeah I do find people that hate the manga cause he just didn't end up with their personal preference immature.


First of all, I don't even like Ichigo 100%. I've typed it on here time and time again how I thought it was a poorly written manga and how Kawashita can't write.

Second, I came to the conclusion of you sounding like a fanboy because of your post in this thread.

Quote from trunks84
But this is speaking mostly as a fan that was completely satisfied cause I was a Nishino fan from the start and I did always expect her to win though not that I would've been pissed off like a lot of fans if she didn't get chosen cause I did love them all almost equally. If I'm dissapointed about one thing on this site it's Ichigo 100% score and the retards that rated it 0 cause their girl didn't get chosen.
.

Right here you not only admitted to liking Nishino the most out of all of them, but even acted like a close-minded fanboy when you called the people who rated it a 1 even though only 67 people rated Ichigo 100% a 1 (It's impossible to rate manga a 0 with that rating system), and 231 voted it a perfect 10, which is almost 3 1/2 times the amount of people that voted it a 1.

Quote from trunks84
And the anime producers of this series should be shot, hell they should be raped as hard bye a bunch of well endowed gays as they raped this series.


And in the same post, you thought that the anime producers should be raped of all things just because they messed up the anime adaptation of your favorite romance manga (Something you even admitted to earlier in the same post as shown below).

Quote from trunks84
Especially since this is one of the first romance mangas that I've ever read and it immediately became my favorite. Hell the only romances that come close to it imo is I's, Maison Ikkoku & Love Hina.


YOUR WHOLE POST IS WHAT A TYPICAL FANBOY WOULD TYPE.

Third, I'm not an Aya fanboy. I never even typed which girl I was a fan of (Hint: It's none of them). I only typed who I thought Manaka should get with in the end and which girl I wanted to get with had I been in the manga, as you can see in my comment below from this thread. Being a fan of a character and choosing which character you would get with had you been in the manga are two entirely different things.

Quote from loosecannon504
I actually liked and hated the ending.

The reason why I hated it was because I did want Manaka to get with Aya. They seemed right for each other, and the relationship he had with Nishino was hollow no matter what. The only reason why Nishino was even in the story was because of Manaka being pressured into asking her out. If he would've done the smart thing by not falling into peer pressure, he and Aya would've been together (Or at least at some point. Manaka and Aya were too dumb and shy in not telling each other their feelings for most of the story.).

The reason why I liked the ending was because it broke the rules of any romance story. Usually, the protagonist ends up with the 1st person they meet, the last person they meet, or just end up alone. Manaka ends up with the 3rd girl that he meets (Yui was 1st, and Aya was 2nd). But I think that's one of the reason why most people (myself included) didn't like the ending. We're all so used to the rules of romance I mentioned above, so when something like this happens, we would get mad about it.

If I was in the story, I would've picked Aya or Satsuki. They're hotness personified biggrin


And as you can see, I not only stated why I hated the ending, but I also explained why I LIKED the ending.

Look, I can understand someone liking a certain manga a whole lot, but if someone likes it to the point that they bash other people for not liking the ending (Especially if it has an ending where their favorite character comes out on top, like you and Nishino), or for people rating it low because they don't have the same opinion about it, then that's being a fan that's also close-minded and an asshole, plain and simple.

And that's exactly what you are.

________________
Quote from Klapzi
The cool part is that I never get tired of being deceived

Quote from tactics
Just because someone's head was chopped off doesn't mean they're dead. That's just silly.

User Posted Image
trunks84
Post #279738
user avatar
Member

7:24 pm, Apr 23 2009
Posts: 34


Quote from "loosecannon504"
Right here you not only admitted to liking Nishino the most out of all of them, but even acted like a close-minded fanboy when you called the people who rated it a 1 even though only 67 people rated Ichigo 100% a 1 (It's impossible to rate manga a 0 with that rating system), and 231 voted it a perfect 10, which is almost 3 1/2 times the amount of people that voted it a 1.


I admit that Nishino was my favorite the whole time through the manga. But I also said
Quote from "trunks84"
But this is speaking mostly as a fan that was completely satisfied cause I was a Nishino fan from the start and I did always expect her to win though not that I would've been pissed off like a lot of fans if she didn't get chosen cause I did love them all almost equally.


Now grow some brain and get some comprehensive reading skills cause you bolded the wrong part which obviously shows that I wasn't a Nishino fanboy. Nishino had only a small advantage and I could've cared less about the outcome...

Quote from "loosecannon504"
And in the same post, you thought that the anime producers should be raped of all things just because they messed up the anime adaptation of your favorite romance manga (Something you even admitted to earlier in the same post as shown below).


Obviously I'm joking and I don't wish them to be raped irl. If you've seen the ovas maybe you should understand why I was so pissed off / dissapointed in the ovas.

Quote from "loosecannon504"
YOUR WHOLE POST IS WHAT A TYPICAL FANBOY WOULD TYPE.

Third, I'm not an Aya fanboy. I never even typed which girl I was a fan of (Hint: It's none of them). I only typed who I thought Manaka should get with in the end and which girl I wanted to get with had I been in the manga, as you can see in my comment below from this thread. Being a fan of a character and choosing which character you would get with had you been in the manga are two entirely different things.


So stating that Ichigo 100% is my favorite manga and that the only ones that I find that compare are Maisson Ikkoku & Love Hina is fanboyish? I'd rather call it a mather of taste / opinion then call someone a word that's rather insulting then praising.

And you sound more of an Aya fanboy then I'm a Nishino fanboy. You had the chance to ignore my post which was hardly that fanboyish, but to me it just seems that you attacked me cause you're an Aya fanboy who think I'm a Nishino fanboy that finds people immature who aren't a Nishino fanboy and as an Aya fanboy who dislikes the end. Which isn't, since I only hate people that say Ichigo 100% is the worst shit there is cause their girl didn't get chosen.

Quote from "loosecannon504"
And as you can see, I not only stated why I hated the ending, but I also explained why I LIKED the ending.

Look, I can understand someone liking a certain manga a whole lot, but if someone likes it to the point that they bash other people for not liking the ending (Especially if it has an ending where their favorite character comes out on top, like you and Nishino), or for people rating it low because they don't have the same opinion about it, then that's being a fan that's also close-minded and an asshole, plain and simple.

And that's exactly what you are.


I think those words apply more on you then they do on me. You're starting an argument with me cause I stated my opinion which you disagree with. So I should adjust my opinion for you? Don't make me laugh you retard with no comprehensive reading skills. I don't hate people that dislike the outcome, I hate people that hate it cause it didn't turn out the way they wanted. That's all, don't try to put words in my or other peoples mouth that they didn't say. Like Xombiec0rp who hardly called me a fanboy. Seems you got more issues with Ichigo 100% outcome then me. And yeah thanks for lowering me to your lvl, really pleasant...

Last edited by trunks84 at 7:31 pm, Apr 23

________________
User Posted Image
MangaAddiction
Post #279740
user avatar
Member

7:26 pm, Apr 23 2009
Posts: 81


I LIKE Ichigo 100% it my favorvite Harem manga (and i read alot of them) it also ended the way i wanted it too

Also for the ppl who rated it 1 just because it didn't turn out the way you wanted it too . . . . Well i have nothing to say to them really it doesn't bother me because lets face it. If you ask someone for a Harem Manga to read Ichigo 100% name will eventually come up

________________
You are now inside my Tsukuyomi. For the next 72 hours... I will slap you with this trout...

Resistance is amusing...
Toldeg
Post #279743
user avatar
Latish
Member

7:35 pm, Apr 23 2009
Posts: 145


i dont really remember the name of the manga.. but for me that was like *the* embodiment what a harem really means... cause there the main character woke up in a reeeeaaally big room amidst lots and lots and lots of girls lying on pillows all sleeping happily.. and i think its not necessary to mention what happened before that day..
and thats like a true harem for me, cuz its not really a harem if nothing ever happens.. imho... biggrin

________________
All is Hitsuzen...
db84x
Post #279903
user avatar
 Member

3:18 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 79


Quote from trunks84
Quote from "loosecannon504"
Right here you not only admitted to liking Nishino the most out of all of them, but even acted like a close-minded fanboy when you called the people who rated it a 1 even though only 67 people rated Ichigo 100% a 1 (It's impossible to rate manga a 0 with that rating system), and 231 voted it a perfect 10, which is almost 3 1/2 times the amount of people that voted it a 1.


I admit that Nishino was my favorite the whole time through the manga. But I also said
Quote from "trunks84"
But this is speaking mostly as a fan that was completely satisfied cause I was a Nishino fan from the start and I did always expect her to win though not that I would've been pissed off like a lot of fans if she didn't get chosen cause I did love them all almost equally.


Now grow some brain and get some comprehensive reading skills cause you bolded the wrong part which obviously shows that I wasn't a Nishino fanboy. Nishino had only a small advantage and I could've cared less about the outcome...

Quote from "loosecannon504"
And in the same post, you thought that the anime producers should be raped of all things just because they messed up the anime adaptation of your favorite romance manga (Something you even admitted to earlier in the same post as shown below).


Obviously I'm joking and I don't wish them to be raped irl. If you've seen the ovas maybe you should understand why I was so pissed off / dissapointed in the ovas.

Quote from "loosecannon504"
YOUR WHOLE POST IS WHAT A TYPICAL FANBOY WOULD TYPE.

Third, I'm not an Aya fanboy. I never even typed which girl I was a fan of (Hint: It's none of them). I only typed who I thought Manaka should get with in the end and which girl I wanted to get with had I been in the manga, as you can see in my comment below from this thread. Being a fan of a character and choosing which character you would get with had you been in the manga are two entirely different things.


So stating that Ichigo 100% is my favorite manga and that the only ones that I find that compare are Maisson Ikkoku & Love Hina is fanboyish? I'd rather call it a mather of taste / opinion then call someone a word that's rather insulting then praising.

And you sound more of an Aya fanboy then I'm a Nishino fanboy. You had the chance to ignore my post which was hardly that fanboyish, but to me it just seems that you attacked me cause you're an Aya fanboy who think I'm a Nishino fanboy that finds people immature who aren't a Nishino fanboy and as an Aya fanboy who dislikes the end. Which isn't, since I only hate people that say Ichigo 100% is the worst shit there is cause their girl didn't get chosen.

Quote from "loosecannon504"
And as you can see, I not only stated why I hated the ending, but I also explained why I LIKED the ending.

Look, I can understand someone liking a certain manga a whole lot, but if someone likes it to the point that they bash other people for not liking the ending (Especially if it has an ending where their favorite character comes out on top, like you and Nishino), or for people rating it low because they don't have the same opinion about it, then that's being a fan that's also close-minded and an asshole, plain and simple.

And that's exactly what you are.


I think those words apply more on you then they do on me. You're starting an argument with me cause I stated my opinion which you disagree with. So I should adjust my opinion for you? Don't make me laugh you retard with no comprehensive reading skills. I don't hate people that dislike the outcome, I hate people that hate it cause it didn't turn out the way they wanted. That's all, don't try to put words in my or other peoples mouth that they didn't say. Like Xombiec0rp who hardly called me a fanboy. Seems you got more issues with Ichigo 100% outcome then me. And yeah thanks for lowering me to your lvl, really pleasant...


Ichigo 100% is definitely the best harem manga, btw if you want to fight about ending come to this topic and feel free fighting around.

loosecannon504
Post #279948 - Reply to (#279738) by trunks84
user avatar
The Gorilla Killa™
Member

6:37 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 3228


Quote from trunks84
I admit that Nishino was my favorite the whole time through the manga. But I also said
Quote from "trunks84"
But this is speaking mostly as a fan that was completely satisfied cause I was a Nishino fan from the start and I did always expect her to win though not that I would've been pissed off like a lot of fans if she didn't get chosen cause I did love them all almost equally.


Now grow some brain and get some comprehensive reading skills cause you bolded the wrong part which obviously shows that I wasn't a Nishino fanboy. Nishino had only a small advantage and I could've cared less about the outcome...


The reason why I made that part bold was because of one thing: You talking about how anyone who hated the ending was immature. You even typed that you liked them all almost equally, meaning that you didn't care who he ended up with because you'd be happy about it . So you were basically in a safe zone because if any girl had been chosen, then you'd like it either way and would be satisfied with the ending. And with that, you could freely bash anyone that didn't like it because you had more of a chance for your girl to get picked (Since you liked all of them), while some person would like between one girl and every girl but Nishino. And then you didn't even consider the fact that people might've hated it for different reasons other than their girl wasn't chosen (Certain possibilities could be if someone thought that Manaka should end up alone in the end, or if they thought the ending was too predictable). You just ignored that possibility and typed that if anyone didn't like the ending of it, then it was because their girl wasn't chosen and that they're immature. That's not how it goes. People will always have different opinions about EVERYTHING. And if you can't get past something as simple as that, then it seems like you're the one that's immature.


Quote from "loosecannon504"
Quote from trunks84
And in the same post, you thought that the anime producers should be raped of all things just because they messed up the anime adaptation of your favorite romance manga (Something you even admitted to earlier in the same post as shown below).

Obviously I'm joking and I don't wish them to be raped irl. If you've seen the ovas maybe you should understand why I was so pissed off / dissapointed in the ovas.


I understand how you didn't like it, because even I thought that it wasn't that well done. But the thing is how would I know you're joking? It's not like I can hear someone's tone of voice though the text and it's like not you had "/sarcasm" at the end (Which would make it worse, since you have to type to people that you were being sarcastic). If you had a laugh emoticon ( laugh ) somewhere around that statement, then it would've given me at least a HINT that you really didn't mean it. Besides, the way you were defending the manga and the fact that you typed that people who voted it low are retards is typical fanboy behavior and led me to believe that you were serious about it. Only people like that will bash anyone who hates any part of their favorite thing, unlike regular fans who'll just go, "So you think that part of it sucks? That's cool." and then would go back to indulging in their favorite thing because they know that people have different opinions about it and it wouldn't bother them as much as it bothers you. That, or they'd have a civil discussion about it, something you seem to be incapable of doing seeing how you like to throw around the words "retard" and "immature" at anyone who had a different opinion than you about the manga or the ending.

Quote from "loosecannon504"
Quote from trunks84
Third, I'm not an Aya fanboy. I never even typed which girl I was a fan of (Hint: It's none of them). I only typed who I thought Manaka should get with in the end and which girl I wanted to get with had I been in the manga, as you can see in my comment below from this thread. Being a fan of a character and choosing which character you would get with had you been in the manga are two entirely different things.


So stating that Ichigo 100% is my favorite manga and that the only ones that I find that compare are Maisson Ikkoku & Love Hina is fanboyish? I'd rather call it a mather of taste / opinion then call someone a word that's rather insulting then praising.


This is already answered with what I just typed above. You defending it to the living end and calling people who don't like it retards is being a fanboy about it.

Quote from trunks84
And you sound more of an Aya fanboy then I'm a Nishino fanboy. You had the chance to ignore my post which was hardly that fanboyish, but to me it just seems that you attacked me cause you're an Aya fanboy who think I'm a Nishino fanboy that finds people immature who aren't a Nishino fanboy and as an Aya fanboy who dislikes the end. Which isn't, since I only hate people that say Ichigo 100% is the worst shit there is cause their girl didn't get chosen.


Now this is you simply ignoring things I've typed. I not only stated that I wasn't a fanboy of any of the girls, but the fact that I thought that Ichigo 100% was poorly written, and how Kawashita can't write. It seems like you're the one with no comprehensive reading skills, seeing how Ichigo 100% was poorly written, and how Kawashita can't write WAS ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS I TYPED in my post before this one.

Quote from "loosecannon504"
Quote from trunks84
And as you can see, I not only stated why I hated the ending, but I also explained why I LIKED the ending.

Look, I can understand someone liking a certain manga a whole lot, but if someone likes it to the point that they bash other people for not liking the ending (Especially if it has an ending where their favorite character comes out on top, like you and Nishino), or for people rating it low because they don't have the same opinion about it, then that's being a fan that's also close-minded and an asshole, plain and simple.

And that's exactly what you are.


I think those words apply more on you then they do on me. You're starting an argument with me cause I stated my opinion which you disagree with. So I should adjust my opinion for you? Don't make me laugh you retard with no comprehensive reading skills. I don't hate people that dislike the outcome, I hate people that hate it cause it didn't turn out the way they wanted. That's all, don't try to put words in my or other peoples mouth that they didn't say. Like Xombiec0rp who hardly called me a fanboy. Seems you got more issues with Ichigo 100% outcome then me. And yeah thanks for lowering me to your lvl, really pleasant...


Of course people wouldn't like the ending if it didn't turn out the way they wanted it to. THAT'S CALLED HAVING AN DIFFERENT OPINION FROM THE PEOPLE WHO LIKED IT. And I didn't even start this argument. I simply agreed with what x0mbiec0rp typed and I added that you COME OFF as a fanboy, I never stated that you were a fanboy. When you started this argument by claiming that I was attacking you (When again, I stated that you COME OFF as a fanboy), and when you in turn called me an Aya fanboy with absolutely no proof whatsoever to back it up is when I decided to retaliate. And I don't have any issues with it at all. I read the story once, didn't like it, and never read it again. You simply think I have issues with it because I don't agree with your biased opinion. And you calling me a retard with no reading skills, as well as the fact that you think that I brought you down to my level, when in fact YOU started this whole argument just proves the fact that you're a close-minded asshole that'll attack anyone who doesn't agree with you 100%, unlike myself, who is simply trying to get it through your fucking head that you shouldn't bash people just because they didn't like that their girl didn't get picked in the end.

Last edited by loosecannon504 at 7:00 am, Apr 24

________________
Quote from Klapzi
The cool part is that I never get tired of being deceived

Quote from tactics
Just because someone's head was chopped off doesn't mean they're dead. That's just silly.

User Posted Image
blakraven66
Post #279956
user avatar
Omnipresent
 Super Mod

6:55 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 6118


As much as I enjoy an arguement, we're getting off topic and this has turned to a bashfest. So 2 letters...PM

________________
User Posted Image
silencer
Post #279983
user avatar
The last Blood Elf
Member

8:13 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 200


Hmm, i don't read many harem manga , just found 5 of them in my memory : Omamori Himari, Ai Kora, Love Hina, Change 123 and Ichigo100%.Well, the best harem for me is Ai kora, Omamori Himari or Change 123 is good, Love Hina and Ichigo100% is...,hmm so so.

I just dislike manga where the main character is exactly below average in many aspects, but the girls can't fall in love with any other guys than him, like an obsession,(probably due to abnormal sex hormone ), more over, the main character in this type of manga, often barely change in his stupidity through out the manga until the last chapter...As for Ichigo 100%, the ending is the only thing that make up for other flaws...it's good to see something makes sense in a manga like that.

________________
User Posted Image
qwert123
Post #279991
user avatar
Member

8:33 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 157


it's a manhwa but I'll choose Unbalance×2

________________
User Posted Image
carlqt
Post #279994
user avatar
THE
Member

8:47 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 234


i like TWGOK, is this considered a harem? Although there are many girls involved, only 1 girl is focus per arc... And after the arc, the girl forgets him although the crush remains.

Quote from blakraven66
As much as I enjoy an arguement, we're getting off topic and this has turned to a bashfest. So 2 letters...PM


tsk... want to read more bashing and fighting smile wink grin

________________
User Posted Image

Kizaru, the only person who can say Ben Beckman without his lips touching

~just CARL is fine~
omimon
Post #279996
Member

8:50 am, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 11


It's all about Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei.

strayed
Post #280052 - Reply to (#279404) by trunks84
user avatar
The Beast
 Member

2:51 pm, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 134


Quote from trunks84
Ichigo 100%. Reason: read the manga, it speaks for itself. And if you disagree cause of the ending then just mature a little since life doesn't always play out the way you want.


i'm sorry, trunks84 smile
i'm not trying to interfere or anything smile
but i think the cause of the argument was this:
Quote from trunks84
And if you disagree cause of the ending then just mature a little

well, i believe we all are already matured enough to not to judge other people as 'not matured enough' just because they don't have the same opinion, right? smile

i really recommend Ichigo 100%. because, even though i don't like the ending (i just don't like it but i don't hate it smile ), but i don't think other people would have the same opinion as me. we all have a different point of view, right?. so you would possibly end up like it or maybe not like it. it depends on your own point of view. just give it a try~!

and i hope you won't say i'm immature because we don't have the same opinion smile




Last edited by strayed at 3:00 pm, Apr 24

________________
User Posted Image
Lnc411
Post #280058 - Reply to (#279991) by qwert123
user avatar
Member

3:17 pm, Apr 24 2009
Posts: 339


Quote from qwert123
it's a manhwa but I'll choose Unbalance×2


I agree with Ubalance x Unbalance. It has a good story, and the art is great.

Pages (14) [ First ... 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Manga General  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer