It's great coming back to this topic after so long! I was vastly amused by Saint Guardian's comment about everyone being related to everyone in SG's town. Laclongquan's point about defining what counts as incest is also very valid. It got me thinking that -- well, we're
all related as long as we're human beings!
...
That's freaky. I mean, I might enjoy playing "Who's your Daddy?" with my girlfriend, but still...
Uh. Anyhow. Incest in manga is what we're talking about! I can't remember if anyone mentioned
For the Rose, but I re-read it again recently and found the multiple strands of incest in it quite interesting. Brother/sister
and brother/brother -- that's a rare combination in any manga, let alone a shoujo one!
However, I'm still looking for stories that seriously deal with incest -- preferably a consensual incestuous romance, and the problems that these lovers face both within themselves and within society. Has anyone got any recent titles to offer up? The only seinen title I've read about this theme is
Koi Kaze -- again, an old classic re-visited. There are heaps of yaoi titles about consensual incest, but I have (alas!) not found much yuri. OMG SISTERS PLZ. *cough* And there's the somewhat pallid shoujo take on stepcest in
The Devil Does Exist, but otherwise, consensual incest is difficult to come across in the shoujo genre. (Or am I wrong? If I am, please tell me! I'm always looking for recommendations!)
By far the best manga I've read about incest recently is
A Cruel God Reigns, which is mind-bendingly awesome and just -- just -- wow. It deals with the complex psychology of a sexually abused youth, who then murders his abusive stepfather and finds (what might be) love with his stepbrother. I know it sounds crazy, but there's this sense of stark reality to the whole thing that really hits me hard. The mangaka is Hagio Moto, by the way, whom some of you might know from
They Were Eleven! fame. (That series was made into an anime, remember? Way back... Okay, so maybe it's not famous anymore, and I've just outed myself as an old hag.
)
Anyway, the art of
A Cruel God Reigns might be dated, but as the manga grows on you, it becomes obvious that the art is in fact very avant garde -- which is to say, there is a surrealism to some of the darker images that is truly thrilling. Concrete situations suddenly take flight into violent, serrated images... It's brilliant. I really loved the darkness of it all -- as well as the slender ray of hope that leads our traumatized hero to a tentative recovery. (After 17 volumes of non-stop angst. Well, it's about time...)
I read (er, browsed?) the raws for this one, because only the first chapter is scanslated. More will be scanslated soon, but to tell you the truth, this story is such a pictorial feast that even the raws are powerful enough. And I'm saying this as someone who doesn't read Japanese. Heh. How does that work? I'm not sure. I only know that the way this mangaka draws her characters' expressions is unparalleled. I
know what the characters are saying! It's like magic. Or telepathy, or something.
Right, now that I've wasted your time... Please recommend more incest manga to me! Particularly anything that's been released in the past two months, since I've been away on holiday and have returned with a manga withdrawal so painful that I can barely
breathe. All I've got is old incest stories that I'm re-reading (as you've noticed), but I'm sadly lacking in new material.
Of particular interest:
a) Consensual incest.
b) Socially conscious incest. (Like, not just smut, but stories that confront realistic hurdles to an incestuous relationship.)
c) Character development.
d) Straight, bent, vertical, horizontal -- whatever. As long as it's incest, I don't care about pithy details like sexuality! Er...
Thanks in advance!
Last edited by pearlesque at 4:46 am, Jan 19 2008________________
"They sicken of the calm, who knew the storm." - Dorothy Parker.