manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
Your favorite series has been going for a while now. You...
Want it to continue forever
Want it to end before it turns worse
Want the author to stop to start a completely new series
Want a spin-off story of it
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Discussion (SPOILERS)

Back to Kimi no Iru Machi


Pages (44) [ First ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Kaishe
Post #341169
user avatar
Someone
Member

12:24 am, Dec 11 2009
Posts: 58


This chapter still hasn't given me much of a motivation to change my standpoint. Very pointless chapter, it divides the reader into those for Haruto x Kanzaki and those who aren't. Where are my answers? What happened with Yuzuki? Where is my Shiho?

Side note, I know Akari's role was pretty much the same but does anyone think she'll get any action aside from being a side character?

Just read chapter 73, allow me to rant just a bit.

If what is said in chapter 73 is true, I will bluntly say that Yuzuki has become a total tramp, and needs to die. My opinion of Nanami has gotten better, but still the fact that she told Haruto that Yuzuki possibly has a new boyfriend is cruel, although I respect that she really did tell him. Although her reason for telling him was through jealousy and she asks him to go out with her again? Tsk Tsk.

Alright so my questions are answered I'm satisfied but not happy, I'll be waiting for the next chapter in anticipation.


Last edited by blakraven66 at 5:09 pm, Dec 22

tactics
Post #343849
user avatar
 Member

1:35 pm, Dec 22 2009
Posts: 3369


No. I'm not accepting that as the reason why she cut off so suddenly. The infomation came from Rin. I'm taking it with a tablespoon of salt. That girl likes stirring things up. I can't believe it just yet XD

When I see it from a reliable source, then I'll believe it and wonder what on earth Eba is thinking. As of now however, I'm weary.

So, Nanami makes her move! Who's pissed off? XD

________________
User Posted Image
The Guy
Post #343850
user avatar
It's him!!
Member

1:37 pm, Dec 22 2009
Posts: 612


Quote from Kaishe
If what is said in chapter 73 is true, I will bluntly say that Yuzuki has become a total tramp, and needs to die. My opinion of Nanami has gotten better, but still the fact that she told Haruto that Yuzuki possibly has a new boyfriend is cruel, although I respect that she really did tell him. Although her reason for telling him was through jealousy and she asks him to go out with her again? Tsk Tsk.

*Agrees with extreme prejudice.*

Now, I can understand if feelings for a person change, especially in a long distance relationship.
But just stringing someone along while you start a new relationship is just low.
If she wanted a new boyfriend the least she could have done was end it in his face, not this kind of shit.

On the other hand, this whole thing just doesn't really seem like her. And you have to consider the person we heard it from was Rin.
Let's just hope it was Rin being a bitch.


________________
Do but despise reason and science,
The highest of all human gifts -
Then you have surrendered to the Devil
And must surely perish. - J.W. von Goethe
Criminal Intent
Post #343891
user avatar
Masanobu Hojo
Member

5:26 pm, Dec 22 2009
Posts: 365


Okay first off, I'm going to assume it was just Rin being annoying.

Also, while Kanzaki did kind of irk me before (You play hard to get and the get mad when someone else takes the initiative, WTF?), but I like that she's willing to throw caution to the wind in order to get together w/ him, even Yuzuki wasn't willing to do that.

All om all, this was a good chap, and I can't wait til the next one. eyes

________________
LOOK AT MY WITTY SIG!!11!!!!11
Calibine
Post #343899
user avatar
Blah
Member

5:51 pm, Dec 22 2009
Posts: 910


Whaaa?? I hope Rin is just lying but I think she wouldn't do that. But I could be wrong...

________________
Lalala~
ikuyoK
Post #343903
user avatar
Member

6:07 pm, Dec 22 2009
Posts: 335


First off, she said, "it looks like," because she was talking about him so happily. Not very definative.. Secondly, I doubt the Mangaka would make a(or the) main heroine out to be, without a doubt, so very much hated by everyone. It just wouldn't make much sense.. I bet it's Rin stirring things up a bit. Either blatantly lying or just over exaggerating a bit.

________________
~The best lives are those that are lived while getting a little dirty~ (Gintama)
~If all you think about is money, your heart will become poor~ (Forgot where)
Lnc411
Post #343912
user avatar
Member

6:52 pm, Dec 22 2009
Posts: 339


Ah Rin... the troublemaker... Damn! The suspense is killing me! lol.

cungthedinh
Post #344111
Member

5:44 pm, Dec 23 2009
Posts: 3


first post ever made in this site biggrin

Ch73, cannot believe, it not like Eba at all, 1 more week to go roll eyes , really love the way the story progress, much better than Suzuka, but personally we all know how Haruto will answer Nanami, plot twist anybody.

BTW I followed this story from the very start, and when I go back to check my file, wow 73 chapter, I felt like i have just read chapter 40 yesterday, and re-read make me missed the day Eba stayed with Haruto, ahh the good old day, anybody wanna bet if Haruto will go to Tokyo or Eba will go back to him roll eyes

Last edited by cungthedinh at 6:29 pm, Dec 23

rifhan
Post #344724
Member

7:40 pm, Dec 27 2009
Posts: 1


Well, I'm pretty sure that Eba having a new boyfriend is just a lie, moreover it being told by Rin. Come to think about it, in a manga where the hero is the center of attention, the girls won't just break up with him easily. And say if that is really the case (Eba having a new boyfriend), this story will end pretty soon. My prediction is that our hero will next go out with Nanami for several chapters, when suddenly Eba returns and sees them together and gets really shocked and upset to find that his man's heart can easily change during her absence. And then Haruto will rush to get Eba to explain everything and as usual, things will get complicated and this manga will become a little longer. Well, in a way or another it's also Eba's fault though, for cutting communication with Haruto for a long time (I wonder what's the reason).
Nevertheless, ehem, I have a soft spot for Nanami and would rather like to see Haruto ends up with her. I know most of you don't agree with this, but I'll be cheering Nanami along the way. bigrazz

dark mage
Post #344748 - Reply to (#344724) by rifhan
Member

10:33 pm, Dec 27 2009
Posts: 504


Quote from rifhan
Nevertheless, ehem, I have a soft spot for Nanami and would rather like to see Haruto ends up with her. I know most of you don't agree with this, but I'll be cheering Nanami along the way. bigrazz


I am an Eba fan, but I have a soft-spot for Nanami too, so you arent the only one. I will have no problem if Haruto does go out with her (allthough its highly unlikely) as Nanami deserves it.


Kaishe
Post #345139 - Reply to (#344748) by dark mage
user avatar
Someone
Member

12:34 am, Dec 30 2009
Posts: 58


Quote from dark mage
Quote from rifhan
Nevertheless, ehem, I have a soft spot for Nanami and would rather like to see Haruto ends up with her. I know most of you don't agree with this, but I'll be cheering Nanami along the way. bigrazz


I am an Eba fan, but I have a soft-spot for Nanami too, so you arent the only one. I will have no problem if Haruto does go out with her (allthough its highly unlikely) as Nanami deserves it.


Sorry I don't mean to be a jerk when I say this, but WHAT? Nanami deserves it? How so, I mean the only good this she has done so far is get Haruto out of depression and all of a sudden she has earned the privilege to date Haruto. Okay when I put it like that it makes it seem as if Haruto is some awesome cool superhero which he isn't but he is still the protagonist of the story, Anyways I do not agree one bit, as Nanami had her chance to go out with Haruto before.

dark mage
Post #345149 - Reply to (#345139) by Kaishe
Member

2:38 am, Dec 30 2009
Posts: 504


Quote from Kaishe
Quote from dark mage
Quote from rifhan
Nevertheless, ehem, I have a soft spot for Nanami and would rather like to see Haruto ends up with her. I know most of you don't agree with this, but I'll be cheering Nanami along the way. bigrazz


I am an Eba fan, but I have a soft-spot for Nanami too, so you arent the only one. I will have no problem if Haruto does go out with her (allthough its highly unlikely) as Nanami deserves it.


Sorry I don't mean to be a jerk when I say this, but WHAT? Nanami deserves it? How so, I mean the only good this she has done so far is get Haruto out of depression and all of a sudden she has earned the privilege to date Haruto. Okay when I put it like that it makes it seem as if Haruto is some awesome cool superhero which he isn't but he is still the protagonist of the story, Anyways I do not agree one bit, as Nanami had her chance to go out with Haruto before.


That is a big thing to get someone out of depression. She had her chance, yes, but it was Haruto's fault, words and actions that forced Nanami to reject him. Nanami never once stopped loving him, but Haruto's actions made her believe he treasured Eba more than her even if he confessed to her, so isnt it absolutel pointless and painful to go out with a guy who will prioritize another girl over his Girlfriend? Nanami refused to go through all that pain as Eba was still around and Haruto was likely to repeat his actions and keep neglecting Nanami for Eba even if Nanami became his girlfriend. But now that Eba seems to be out of the picture for good, Nanami is trying her best for Haruto and giving it her all to cheer him up. Nanami has always been like this, she tried her best even when Haruto first confessed to her, this has always been her personality and only once during the slap did we see her acting out of character.


And how exactly does Eba deserve Haruto? I like her and I dont know myself why I like her. Because to me, Eba hasnt done anything for Haruto other than making him cook for her, living in his house, riding on the back of his bike, acting like a spoilt brat, refusing to go to Tokyo without him, acting all wishy washy after her hands were held and getting closer to the sempai, kissing Haruto when Nanami was just outside his door and then saying she will support Haruto while he persued Nanami but also declaring she will make him fall in love with her, then when Haruto confesses she rejects him, after six months he confesses again and she rejects him only to accept at the last moment when the train is about to leave, Eba comes on the date and says she wants to break-up and then said just kidding but broke up with him anyway but didnt have the guts and courtesy to tell it to him to his face causing him alotof pain and anguish. The way I see it Eba has been nothing but trouble and all her actions have been self-contradictory but even so, I like Eba and am her fan for a reason that I am unable to quite put my finger on. Maybe Haruto feels the same?

Anyways, I see people are starting to catch on about Eba not being too thrilled to be near Haruto, first was when she didnt want Haruto to go to a school with Eba in Tokyo because that would be an inconvininience to her, and later when she didnt seem too partcularly thrilled to meet Haruto during his Tokyo trip and other little things like that, I dunno, it just seemed to me that Eba was always too wary of ever commiting herself fully to Haruto. Even her accepting of Haruto's confesson in the last minute, it never sat well for me, and I said so in one of the earlier threads, it just looked like she was taking pity on Haruto after seeing how desperate he looked, almost like an after-thought.



Last edited by dark mage at 7:40 pm, Dec 30

Criminal Intent
Post #345265 - Reply to (#345149) by dark mage
user avatar
Masanobu Hojo
Member

5:36 pm, Dec 30 2009
Posts: 365


Quote from dark mage
And how exactly does Eba deserve Haruto? I like her and I dont know myself why I like her. Because to me, Eba hasnt done anything for Haruto other than making him cook for her, living in his house, riding on the back of his bike, acting like a spoilt brat, refusing to go to Tokyo without him, acting all wishy washy after her hands were held and getting closer to the sempai, kissing Haruto when Nanami was just outside his door and then saying she will support Haruto while he persued Nanami but also declaring she will make him fall in love with her, then when Haruto confesses she rejects him, after six months he confesses again and she rejects him only to accept at the last moment when the train is about to leave, Eba comes on the date and says she wants to break-up and then said just kidding but broke up with him anyway but didnt have the guts and courtesy to tell it to him to his face causing him alotof pain and anguish. The way I see it Eba has been nothing but trouble and all her actions have been self-contradictory but even so, I like Eba and am her fan for a reason that I am unable to quite put my finger on. Maybe Haruto feels the same?

QFT

I like Eba, but she is quite troublesome and after this chapter I'm starting to like Nanami more and more. She's a realist but it doesn't stop her from being optimistic.

This is turning out to be one of my fav shounen/seinen romances. Haruto doesn't seem like a wishy washy loser/jerk, and the 2 main heroines aren't completely unbearable like most of Kouji's female characters.

________________
LOOK AT MY WITTY SIG!!11!!!!11
RhinoX753
Post #346577
Member

1:37 am, Jan 6 2010
Posts: 7


That might be the strange question... but did we see Harutos dad at least once in manga?

Cypher29
Post #347252
Member

3:49 pm, Jan 8 2010
Posts: 2


Okay, having the extra time to suffer the cliffhanger nature of the current arc, I went back an re-read the series from chp 1 and in the process noticed something odd. Throughout the series we get lots of insight into all the main cast members except for Yuzuki. It's like the mangaka is specifically keeping her under his own 'curfew' and tightly restricting information about her so that we're all left confused/suspicious/pissed when things happen. I know it's a writing method to keep plots moving by adding mystery, but it feels too detached and leaves the feeling that she's nothing but some sort of catalyst.

So far, the only reason I can see for Yuzuki to have feelings for Haruto is that he was nice to her when other people, mainly her family, were not. As for his side, it just seems like he feels obligated to her due to her klutz/idiot/ditzy nature. More like a sister complex between non-blood-related siblings. Only once did he ever actually comment on what her positive aspects were, and not in length. Quote from Ch.41: "I think it most likely isn't because she is here that I can't date Kanzaki, but because she was there, that I was able to get this close to Kanzaki".

There are far more chapters with Nanami as the focus, and we get to see a great deal of her actual feelings, especially in the more recent chapters. She's never actually disliked Haruto, and has been friendly and helpful to him pretty much from the beginning. That she turned him down the first time is pretty much Yuzuki's fault, as has been previously discussed. Bottom line, she seems to be more the main character than Yuzuki. At the very least she's actually putting effort into being with him, Yuzuki has just been using the situations and playing up his sympathy.



Pages (44) [ First ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Kimi no Iru Machi  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer