| From User |
Message Body |
|
shoujo22
|
Post #326364 |
Member
2:31 pm, Oct 8 2009
Posts: 51
|
About 95% of the smut I've read has been completely and totally stupid, and I ended up laughing at stuff that probably wasn't even supposed to be funny  . I did like Midnight Secretary though. Oh, and Chou yo Hana yo. It was pure crack. Completely ridiculous, but I laughed my @$$ off reading it though. That series is SO not to be taken seriously.
Other than those two series, I've found that smut mangas aren't really to my liking 
|
|
base_coat
|
Post #326438 - Reply to ( #326364) by shoujo22 |
Fruit Salad
Member
9:50 pm, Oct 8 2009
Posts: 1294
|
Quote from shoujo22 About 95% of the smut I've read has been completely and totally stupid, and I ended up laughing at stuff that probably wasn't even supposed to be funny . I did like Midnight Secretary though. Oh, and Chou yo Hana yo. It was pure crack. Completely ridiculous, but I laughed my @$$ off reading it though. That series is SO not to be taken seriously. Other than those two series, I've found that smut mangas aren't really to my liking
Try other Yoshihara Yuki's works, for example: Mermaid Prince, Aisuru Hito, and Itadakimasu. The one you mentioned is not my thing though.
|
|
Mizi
|
Post #326480 - Reply to ( #326249) by StarlightDreams |
Calc. BC-er!
Member
2:07 am, Oct 9 2009
Posts: 104
|
Quote from StarlightDreams Lies.
You are a hardcore smut fan! ;< I know it!
PSH! You're just kidding 'cause you know it XD I, unlike Mai, do not enjoy much of it  Though some smut is alright XD
*plans on hunting mai down*
*takes K-dramas from Mai*
________________
NOIR is recruting~*click image*
 |
|
StarlightDreams
|
Post #326481 - Reply to ( #326480) by Mizi |
Nerdlight
Moderator
2:10 am, Oct 9 2009
Posts: 2471
|
Quote from Mizi Quote from StarlightDreams Lies.
You are a hardcore smut fan! ;< I know it! PSH! You're just kidding 'cause you know it XD I, unlike Mai, do not enjoy much of it Though some smut is alright XD *plans on hunting mai down* *takes K-dramas from Mai*
D:
I don't even like smut that much. I dropped most of them! ;~;
I only enjoy Yoshihara Yuki's because it's so darn funny. I recommend them. 
And I know you loveeeeeeee them, especially them outflines. ;D
And nooo, don't take them away! They're my life!
________________
BROWNIES!
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ
Next to Read...Full Metal Alchemist |
|
shoujo22
|
Post #327415 - Reply to ( #326438) by base_coat |
Member
6:21 pm, Oct 13 2009
Posts: 51
|
Quote from base_coat Quote from shoujo22 About 95% of the smut I've read has been completely and totally stupid, and I ended up laughing at stuff that probably wasn't even supposed to be funny . I did like Midnight Secretary though. Oh, and Chou yo Hana yo. It was pure crack. Completely ridiculous, but I laughed my @$$ off reading it though. That series is SO not to be taken seriously. Other than those two series, I've found that smut mangas aren't really to my liking Try other Yoshihara Yuki's works, for example: Mermaid Prince, Aisuru Hito, and Itadakimasu. The one you mentioned is not my thing though.
I've read them all. I liked all of them except for Aisuru Hito-- which I stopped reading after only a few chapters because I couldn't get with the bouncing from brother to brother thing  .
|
|
Drab
|
Post #327420 |
Member
7:02 pm, Oct 13 2009
Posts: 9
|
I say no for me.
Probably because of the ones I've read that contain smut, it seems to serve no other purpose besides just being there. Also, it usually tends to take away from the story and characters to the point where I just avoid it.
________________
Visit my Blog!
 |
|
base_coat
|
Post #327421 - Reply to ( #327415) by shoujo22 |
Fruit Salad
Member
7:08 pm, Oct 13 2009
Posts: 1294
|
Quote from shoujo22 I've read them all. I liked all of them except for Aisuru Hito-- which I stopped reading after only a few chapters because I couldn't get with the bouncing from brother to brother thing .
That's one of the reasons that make it funny. Some people just like bouncing and Yoshihara actually handled it in a humorous way. I am surprised that so many people can't see past that small thing. Not many female-oriented manga are brave enough to be like that.
Last edited by base_coat at 7:13 pm, Oct 13
|
|
IMustBeInsane
|
Post #327489 |
Oxymoronic
Member
1:00 am, Oct 14 2009
Posts: 635
|
I usually don't care one way or another. I'll read with or without. Sometimes, I'm in a "pure" romance mood and don't want any and sometimes I really, really want some good smut (like, right now!).
________________
GREEN BAY 5-4
*Packers and Titans won; Bears, Steelers and Patriots lost. In fact, the only bad thing that happend Sunday was the Lions loss at the hands of the Vikings...*
I am a breath of insanity in a world of chaos.
"Gravity is a habit that is hard to shake off." - Terry Pratchett |
|
ichigo_daisuki
|
Post #327494 |
-_- ~nuu~
Member
1:26 am, Oct 14 2009
Posts: 60
|
No thanks; I don't care for smut 
________________
"to the world you may be one person,
but to one person you may be the world."
-unknown |
|
VanGirl
|
Post #327496 |
Member
1:45 am, Oct 14 2009
Posts: 35
|
I like smut!
The more the merrier! jk
It all depends on what mood I am in.. There are times when i just want to read some.. Its defineatley not all I read tho..
|
|
base_coat
|
Post #327556 - Reply to ( #327489) by IMustBeInsane |
Fruit Salad
Member
12:21 pm, Oct 14 2009
Posts: 1294
|
Quote from IMustBeInsane I usually don't care one way or another. I'll read with or without. Sometimes, I'm in a "pure" romance mood and don't want any and sometimes I really, really want some good smut (like, right now!).
If it's not "pure" romance, it isn't necessarily smut. It can be "mature" without smut.
|
|
shoujo22
|
Post #331042 - Reply to ( #327421) by base_coat |
Member
4:29 pm, Oct 28 2009
Posts: 51
|
Quote from base_coat Quote from shoujo22 I've read them all. I liked all of them except for Aisuru Hito-- which I stopped reading after only a few chapters because I couldn't get with the bouncing from brother to brother thing . That's one of the reasons that make it funny. Some people just like bouncing and Yoshihara actually handled it in a humorous way. I am surprised that so many people can't see past that small thing. Not many female-oriented manga are brave enough to be like that.
I'm just not one for love triangles. Never have been-- especially ones involving siblings (comedy or not). Going between brothers or sisters is kinda not a simple thing for me, actually. Humorous or not, they just irk me. Can't help it *shrug* I'm not knocking whether or not other people like the bouncing back and forth thing. That's just not my thing-- whether the leading character is male or female
I like all of Yoshihara's work except for that one though.
|
|
Kitanne
|
Post #331635 |
Member
1:14 am, Oct 31 2009
Posts: 4
|
I'm all for smut, especially in things that are more josei than shojo. For me, most modern young adult/adult relationships are going to realistic include some sexy times. (Granted shojo/josei isn't always that realistic but still). Smut doesn't have to mean a lack of romance and I think sometimes it's pretty damn romantic!
I only find it annoying when it's overly flowery or there is tons of crying (!!!) for no reason or just plain badly drawn. I'm a fan of Enjouji Maki (Private Prince, yay faaace) and I was quite sad when Midnight Secretary was over. Thankfully, Ohmu Tomu has some other great (some of them smutty) series!
________________
I conquer for kicks. |
