| From User |
Message Body |
|
yuri999
|
Post #348817 |
Member
7:13 pm, Jan 12 2010
Posts: 129
|
So it must have been obvious to you all as to why there was such hurried development but the real reason is that due to it constantly ranking in the bottom 5 , ane doki has been cancelled and this weeks issue of WSJ will have its final chapter.
Imho, the story was okay in the beginning but slowly and slowly it started to lose focus and later on it became a complete mess. Mizuki is capable of doing better than this and I really really feel that she should team up with a good writer on her next series. Her art is good enough for a rom-manga but she needs a little help on the writing front.
Edit: Sorry, I should have written chapter 26. The series has ended as of 13/01/2010. RIP.
Last edited by yuri999 at 12:55 pm, Jan 14
|
|
tactics
|
Post #348818 |
Is a female
 Member
7:22 pm, Jan 12 2010
Posts: 3226
|
Really?
Well to be honest, the fact that she's 4 years older than him, (and he's only 13 as well) I'm a bit :/ about that. I didn't want that to put me totally off though so I gave it a chance anyway.
It's not terrible or anything, but yeah, it's not fantastic either.
As long at is has an ending, of any sort, that's ok. Please dear god have an ending.
________________
 |
|
crazyjap22
|
Post #348819 |
Member
7:22 pm, Jan 12 2010
Posts: 12
|
ya it was obvious it was going to end but I feel sad for Kawashita-sensei cuz all her series are great but all of them don't last like Ichigo 100% I think it's because it's Weekly Shounen Jump. Maybe if she went to Jump SQ then she will be successful.
Also I saw rumors on the internet that they are going to make it into an anime.
I guess that's something to look forward too if it's true
Last edited by crazyjap22 at 7:35 pm, Jan 12
|
|
chulian1819
|
Post #349015 |
chulian
Member
12:48 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 833
|
I have mixed feelings for her work....... I hoep she does at least a good ending so I can decide to read it....
thankz @crazy for the info ^^
________________
Reading Love Lucky
Recommended B Gata H Kei <3 Conveni-N XD
 |
|
mashqi
|
Post #349016 |
Streamyx SUCK ASS
Member
1:08 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 470
|
i like the art but i dun really like the story.. I hope Mizuki would make a better manga next time..
________________
Slow internet is DEADLY
 |
|
Scyfon
|
Post #349017 |
Mome Basher
Member
1:09 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 3212
|
Aaaaaw....
There goes my Kawashita-sensei fix TT_TT
I liked Ane-doki.
I felt Hatsukoi gentei was a little better ('cept the ending, pffft), but this was special in it's own way.
I quite liked the whole "she is older than him by 3 years" thing.
You don't really see that often and it's sorta every 13 year old boy's fantasy (perhaps at it's weakest ^_^; ; )
Let's hope it'll have an ending that I like! (like lilim kiss' ending)
________________
dA
FACT: Signing forum posts is as stupid as "signing off" a phone call. |
|
Darknemo2000
|
Post #349023 |
Member
2:00 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 56
|
Scyfon, I think one of teh reason it did so bad was that 'older by 4 years' thing.
You may say it is a dream, but not su good setup for an actual romance.
Ah but 4 years is no big deal, you may say and you would be right. There are manga's with 7 year gap or even more, but the key is the way characters are portrayed. And the hero looked like a kid both mantally and physically compared to the heroine, thus all the fanservice had no romance tone to it.
Heck, Negi from Negima is also much younger, but his pairings do not look as ridiculous because he is portrayed more mature than his age thus the gap isnt as strong as in Ane-Doki.
Another thing is that such series like TLR had more fanservice, but what it was also important that fanservice had a romantic tone to it as well. In Ane-Doki there isn't that much of fanservice, and because of age difference there is no romance to repay for the lack of it, and story felt dull.
The only way was if the hero went for the girls similar to his age, but it seems like people are not that interested in romances between little kids...
________________
Hobby:
Manga/Anime. Philosophy, Poetry, books, basketball, russian rock. |
|
mayid
|
Post #349098 |
Member
8:32 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 3
|
Quote Heck, Negi from Negima is also much younger, but his pairings do not look as ridiculous because he is portrayed more mature than his age thus the gap isnt as strong as in Ane-Doki.
Hahahah But if we talk about Mahou sensei negima than whe talk about a story of the great master named Ken Akamatsu and he is on a whole other level than Kawashita-sensei. Look at Love Hina he surely knows how to make interesting manga´s who are not short.
|
|
jackblack901
|
Post #349099 |
Member
8:40 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 151
|
WSJ is truly a manga crusher. I guess even the great art work of Kawashita-sensei is unable to help this manga go on without a decent plot 
________________
 |
|
The Guy
|
Post #349103 |
It's him!!
Member
8:47 pm, Jan 13 2010
Posts: 608
|
Too bad. I was starting to quite enjoy this manga.
I actually thought it would go on for a while longer.
The age difference of 3-4 years kind of stopped any real romance from developing. With the whole moving away thing I was thinking of a time skip to highschool or something. Then him returning to his old home and a chance meeting with her again. Then some serious romance development.
Oh well. Maybe something truly brilliant will take it's place. Though chances are slim, it being WSJ and all.
________________
Do but despise reason and science,
The highest of all human gifts -
Then you have surrendered to the Devil
And must surely perish. - J.W. von Goethe |
|
yuri999
|
Post #349264 |
Member
12:56 pm, Jan 14 2010
Posts: 129
|
The manga ended on 13/01/2010.
Also, it ended on chapter 26. Sorry for the wrong title.
|
|
Monzaemon
|
Post #349266 |
Ojiisan
Member
2:00 pm, Jan 14 2010
Posts: 84
|
Thats a shame to hear, I think it was a pretty ok manga.
But I really thought it was going to go on for a bit longer.
Hopefully it will give a good ending. I'd hate to see it end up like Spoiler (highlight to view) To-LOVE-Ru did. That ending really made me upset.
________________
 |
|
Makaveli
|
Post #349389 |
The Coolest
Member
6:22 pm, Jan 14 2010
Posts: 890
|
i will be happy as long as he picks someone to go out wit...not not a open-ending wit no one like tuloveru...jus wanna read and say i finished it
________________
The Don: Young Makaveli
love is evil, spell it backwards and I'll show you...
"my mind shines bright even when my thoughts seem dark"
Never Ignorant Getting Goals Accomplished
The Hate U Give Little Infates F***s Everybody
justILLMATIC |
|
awesomeguy2731
|
Post #349563 |
fun time
Member
12:54 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 38
|
wow... everyone pretty much hates to love ru's ending...
anyway, one second... NOOOO!!!!
why did anedoki have to end so soon!!
i was starting to like it!
oh well... i hope kawashita makes a new one, that is better than ever, soon.
________________
it is time for SUPER AWESOME TIMES!! WOOT! |
|
Daisukereds
|
Post #349570 |
Member
1:33 am, Jan 15 2010
Posts: 26
|
Man...crappy news. But I kind of saw it coming...I mean, it's not as detailed and "mysterious" as Ichigo 100%...still enjoyable. Anyway, as long as it has a decent ending I'm okay with it...
A better manga will follow...hopefully
|
