One of the most frustrating hentai I read had a man considering asking an old friend out, only to discover that she literally sleeps with everyone but him. It's not that he's that lame or anything, she just likes him so much that she thinks it would be cruel to do it with him. And that's how the story ENDS.

Are there any stories that start out like that, with a man who loves a girl who will do anyone but won't do him? Okay if he finds a better girl, but hoping for something where she winds up switching from anyone but him to no one but him. I'm pretty sure I've seen a couple things like this some time ago, but I don't remember what it was and anyway I want more.

I don't really get why you guys make a big fuss over hentai. It's just sex. I read it for the sex and don't even care who does it with who. I don't get how it can be frustrating unless it's rape.

By the way, is there any hentai which is the other way around, where a guy sleeps with anyone but the main girl who likes him/whom he likes? I would like to read that.

Last edited by base_coat at 11:33 pm, Jun 28 2010

Not everyone is fine with just sex regardless of how it's presented. Many people tend to identify unconsciously with the main/narrating character, and if a story ends with his girl-next-door friend trying to hide from him the fact that she's slept with everyone he knows and a lot of people he doesn't is a little messed up. Even more so if this results in him being the only one who doesn't get any, and hiding the fact that he knows everything she's hiding.
A lot of hentai out there has some form of plot at least for the sake of explaining how things wound up a certain way. Many of them just use it to present the immediate sex scenes and dump it though, even when there's plenty they can do with it, and with further story development they can get a lot more out of what they set up. With a guy hiding the fact that he knows something his childhood friend is desperately trying to hide from him, there's plenty of stuff you could do.

Anyway, that was just an example to help describe what I'm looking for. I like there to be plot in it. Please don't post simply to say how silly you think the request is.

Also, there's tons of hentai where the guy sleeps with everyone. That's part of why I'm interested in seeing a reversal, with the girl being the one to go from anyone to just one. I don't know any off the top of my head where he excludes the main girl, but I know they're there, especially when they're childhood friends, cousins, or stepsiblings, since these relationships mean taboo for some people. One that I don't think is hentai that's a little like that is Bitter Virgin. The girl has some past trauma that makes her very uncomfortable with guys, but she's able to get close to the main guy specifically because he singles her out as one he wouldn't go for.

I agree with you, and its not all about sex for everyone and that's why you see so many readers who dont like NTR and get turned off by it,and that's because we feel for the good guys. Let me tell you there are a lot of readers like this, including me, and I think its not all about sex, atleast the hentai's with a story that is.

About, a suggestion for the types of manga you are looking for, I cant remember Hentai but these are Joseis ---

Kimi Wa Pet
Kiss and Never Cry *(It wasnt all scanlated into english but the shit only hits the fan in the unscanlated chapters, but the story does revolve arfound a girl who considers herself "unclean")

I remember maybe I'm a beast starting that way.

Hentai is not to be taken seriously. If you want serious stuff, watch movies, don't read hentai. I don't get how you can identify with anyone. That's not even remotely related to your life. Why don't you identify with those who sleep with the girl then?

Actually to me those girls who exclude the main guy have very similar mentality as that of those guys who think childhood friends, etc are a taboo. Hentai authors usually give their characters very simple (to the point of being unrealistic and even stupid) logic because sex is the main point, not characters. It's not that difficult to understand and get over.

Usually when there's a video involved, it's always a guy who's watching the girl on the video. Is there any one where the girl watches the main guy on the video?

Last edited by base_coat at 4:04 am, Jul 5 2010

i think shuusaku is thinking of Adult genre, rather than hentai, since Adult is like... slightly less than hentai with a plot...

Just check out this link -- Wednesday After School and see the reviews and see how many readers by it. Also most of the hentai by Sanbun has good stories, its not all about sex. And your example of girls never watching boys, do happen in some mangas, I have sen it happen and the other reason is, its assumed mostly males read Hentai

I have no problem at all with hentai that is nothing but straight sex. In hentai, like in eroge, there are two major classes: those that have a real story and have a main character working toward a goal that involves various amounts of sex, and those that have little or no story and are set up purely to have a character screw every vagina he sees, with the possible exception of farm animals and senior citizens. Both are good in their own way, and I'll take either (so long as the animals and elderly are excluded). But if there's a plot, I want it to be done well, and I don't want to get to know a male character only to see him end up with nothing left but his right hand and some memories in which he was always the spectator.

If the plot is present, then I prefer it be taken to a point where I can be satisfied. It's generally easier on the author to simply have a guy doing the girls he wants to do, without having him sitting there staring as his girl gets turned into a sex slave. But if they make that effort, I like them to make enough effort to have him either get her back, join the ranks of slave-masters, or find someone else. IMHO, every series that has NTR or similar should start with the line "Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'intrate".

Again, please don't come here just to say how stupid you think the requests and questions are, or to ask if there's anything that's completely the opposite. I'm not just posting this because crap like I'd mentioned annoys and frustrates me, but also because I'm interested to see something like this.

BTW, I don't mind why she won't do him. She might think he's pathetic, or like him too much to hook him up with a sl*t like her, or want to preserve their friendship, or just not think of him that way. Another possibility that could be interesting is that she would sleep with him but he doesn't want a sl*t, and what she does to get him.

Seijun comes to mind.