manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
Demographic you read the most?
Shounen
Shoujo
Seinen
Josei
Shoujo Ai
Shounen Ai
Hentai
Lolicon
Shotacon
Yaoi
Yuri
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Again random comment removal

Back to Suggestions & Bugs


Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Myzifer
Post #421219
Member

8:40 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 17


http://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=40603
care to explain why u keep removing my comment admin?
I mean come on what's wrong with
"gd series and ch 6 is out btw"
it's the truth it's 100% about the series and it's in the comment section where it's meant to be

Pikapu
Post #421224 - Reply to (#421219) by Myzifer
user avatar
 Member

8:49 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 1954


Quote from Myzifer
http://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=40603
care to explain why u keep removing my comment admin?
I mean come on what's wrong with
"gd series and ch 6 is out btw"
it's the truth it's 100% about the series and it's in the comment section where it's meant to be

People can see where the releases are. You don't have to say that a chapter is out. And then when the release part is taken out of your comment, all it will say is "gd series," and that's not really enough. Try spelling words out and giving more of your input if you want to comment.

Btw, I'm not an admin or mod, but anyone could figure this out.

________________
User Posted Image
Quote from LawX
You are like the dense main character in a shoujo manga.
Quote from Crenshinibon
And you will murder someone one day, pika. If you're my daughter.
Myzifer
Post #421229
Member

9:00 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 17


since the site doesn't show ch 6 is released then this is new info that they can't see and why should I need to spell words out as u put it, what else could gd mean it's obvious and shouldn't have any baring on why my comment is removed.

I suggest next time u actually check a link if one is provided before making a snap judgement.

Last edited by Myzifer at 9:06 pm, Nov 4

Auzel
Post #421231
Member

9:08 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 1


This is a forum not a cell phone that your texting off of. You are, words I can not say intelligence wise, if you think that "gd series and ch 6 is out btw" is note-worthy enough to take up space on the website. It looks like spam, it sounds like spam, and I'm pretty sure it taste like spam.

LawX
Post #421235
user avatar
Masculine Devil
Member

9:12 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 1096


You could have updated that information to the database instead of leaving a comment on it. Also, maybe next time you could elaborate on how it's a good series.

________________
Quote from Scyfon
i prefer my men smooth and hairless on the body.
Quote from x0mbiec0rp
Aye, girl, lemme get a pikachu.
Myzifer
Post #421236
Member

9:15 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 17


u must love spam then, look at the link and see it's not spam and that it's the comment section, what am I meant to write a 12 page review in it?
I think not, I had made a longer post mentioning about ch6 being released but with that being removed over and over I shortened it.
facts remain the site isn't updated with correct info so I put it there in comment so should someone check the manga out and get ch5 then if they see my comment they know they can find ch6 somewhere.

oh yeh and ur personal opinion on how others write things is laughable since u obvious didn't know as times change so does the written and spoken lang which is why bit by bit the short hand version of words is slowly being more officially accepted and even considered to be added to the dictionary.

edit-last time I checked LawX normal members aren't able to change Latest Release(s)
c.5 by Animexis (9d ago)
c.4 by Animexis (26d ago)
c.3 by Animexis (152d ago)
as u can see from my copy and paste there is no option otherwise I would of updated it myself.

LawX
Post #421240
user avatar
Masculine Devil
Member

9:24 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 1096


On the right menu click on User CP then Add Release.
If you have valid information it will be approved.

________________
Quote from Scyfon
i prefer my men smooth and hairless on the body.
Quote from x0mbiec0rp
Aye, girl, lemme get a pikachu.
Myzifer
Post #421242
Member

9:30 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 17


would work if it wasn't a anonmous submission on mangatraders and I checked the other group via the only link this site has of em and they don't have it on there MF folder so either diff group or admin prob wouldn't accept it just like how they removed my countless comments.

Last edited by blakraven66 at 1:35 pm, Nov 5

greydrak
Post #421247
user avatar
Member

9:59 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 641


If you wanted to submit valid up to date information, this is not the place to put it.

User CP, either add release or request change would more than suffice to bring it to the attention of the admin/mods.

And if your submitted information is actually valid it would be approved, but "random comments" are just as useless as topics like this, which is why it gets removed since it is just "random".

________________
User Posted ImageUser Posted Image
Myzifer
Post #421249
Member

10:34 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 17


well since it isn't random and the ch is released it's valid especially since the group is unconfirmed which prevents it being submitted the normal way hence comment.

shesh the least u could do is read the topic before making a snap judgement (what is it with people tonight bothering to post but not read fully what they've posting about)

also from previous experience the admins either don't care if it's on other sites or if it doesn't fit perfectly in with what they want since this isn't the 1st time when there is evidence on releases that they weren't happy with when it was fairly clear.

hence me wanting the admin to explain why he removed my comments.

oh yeh and comments r ment to be random it's a comment(by this I mean random but in the scope of where the comment is attached which mine is clearly) not a major section or review which if it was there r other places for it.

mu2020
Post #421262 - Reply to (#421219) by Myzifer
user avatar
the mu...
Member

11:35 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 1027


Quote from Myzifer
http://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=40603
care to explain why u keep removing my comment admin?
I mean come on what's wrong with
"gd series and ch 6 is out btw"
it's the truth it's 100% about the series and it's in the comment section where it's meant to be

imho the comment section is for giving your comment about the manga. Whether it's good or not, or how u feel about the manga in general. It doesn't have to be a review, like saying its a type of manga u wanna enjoy reading at winter, or anything u thought about the manga in general.. It is not for giving a comment toward the newest scanlation or newest release. not a place to talk about a certain chapter u could just made a thread for that on the manga thread section. Also not a place to put a release warning.. there's a place for that..
Imho the reason why your comment is kept on being removed is because what u put there is not in the right place...
Either that or u stupidly rewrite your own old comment... one member can only gives one post on the comment section

in b4 lock bigrazz

________________
User Posted Image
if u wonder where the sig is from, just click the pic
Myzifer
Post #421266
Member

11:54 pm, Nov 4 2010
Posts: 17


it's a comment section for that page and guess what that page includes releases so saying yeh there is a new release out fits perfectly well on the comment section especially since it's an anon release so they aren't gona change it to indicate the 6th ch is out till some group site or irc shows it which just does more to further the reason why it's perfect for the comment section.

if this site only has places for official release info then the comment section is the best and only place to put the un-official release info.

u also say it doesn't have to be a review yet ur only example is a review "Whether it's good or not, or how u feel about the manga in general"

there is a section for user reviews and it's not the comment section.

mattai
Post #421269
user avatar
Member

12:01 am, Nov 5 2010
Posts: 609


Comments are there mainly for people to share their opinions on a given manga so people can decide if they want to read/keep reading a series.

If you look at the comment you're planning to post and say "will this comment be completely irrelevant in a year?" and the answer is "yes", it probably doesn't belong there. And if the rules somehow restrict a given release from being posted...what makes you think they'd want someone to post about that release in the comments??

________________
"It is those who know little, and not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved by science."
Myzifer
Post #421276
Member

12:23 am, Nov 5 2010
Posts: 17


so basically u thinks the comment section is a review section?
sry to point this out again but they already have a review section
Anime Start/End Chapter [Edit]
N/A

User Reviews
N/A

User Rating
Average: 8.7 / 10.0 (68 votes)
Bayesian Average: 8.31 / 10.0
10
46% (31 votes)
9+
21% (14 votes)

the comment section might be the lazy way to post a review but doesn't mean it's the correct way to do it.

u ask if it could be irrelevant in a year? answer no way to know since if no group does another release of it in a year which happens to be the same ch then bam it's still relevant and I've seen many other manga which out of no where the group working on it drops it or goes inactive so in answer then to ur final question/point of if the rules prevent a official release then why should it be in comments I'd just have to say when reading that it made me think face palm since that's the whole point of a comment section, if something which u didn't/couldn't plan for pops up then u have the option to add it in the comment section, heck even before I did software developement or system analysis I knew exactly what a comment section was meant for from filling out forms of various kinds which is basically what the manga page is.

u need to have a group signed to a release so if no group claims it then this site doesn't accept that in it's release but since this is a database for the collection of manga info and they cover all kinds of releases then this is perfect example of data out of the original scope of thought for input and fraud prevention, doesn't mean it breaks a rule just means it doesn't fit into the limited add release form.
frankly speaking the comment section is there precisely for things like this.

mu2020
Post #421280 - Reply to (#421266) by Myzifer
user avatar
the mu...
Member

12:27 am, Nov 5 2010
Posts: 1027


Quote from Myzifer
it's a comment section for that page

it is a comment section for that particular manga not for the page.
Quote
if this site only has places for official release info then the comment section is the best and only place to put the un-official release info.


official? Unofficial? Wait a minute...
U're new about this whole stuff aren't u?
Quote
u also say it doesn't have to be a review yet ur only example is a review "Whether it's good or not, or how u feel about the manga in general"

i'm sorry for not giving u more example.. U could just go and look at other people comment on other manga info page if u want... Really read em... Subjectives... Objectives... Personal insight..

I wanna say obvious troll is obvious... But... Nevermind
i wonder how long this thread will last?

________________
User Posted Image
if u wonder where the sig is from, just click the pic
Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Suggestions & Bugs  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer