| From User |
Message Body |
|
amaranthine
|
Post #98918 - Reply to ( #98752) by greydrak |
Member
2:03 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 3948
|
Quote from greydrak characters just started popping up with super powers and dominate everyone simply because they can.
Maybe it's just me, but aren't most shounen manga like that though? Dun dun duuun, a new super duper strong character that can kick everyone's collective asses comes along~
|
|
Scyfon
|
Post #98933 |
Mome Basher
Member
2:15 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 3212
|
They all bring the same amount of excitement to me. Each has had their own epic moments. I can't really say one is better than the other.
________________
dA
FACT: Signing forum posts is as stupid as "signing off" a phone call. |
|
Calíbre
|
Post #98941 |
Madman
 Member
2:30 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 3341
|
Bleach is my favorite by far... Naruto and One Piece are about even for me, I like One Piece better cause the story moves along faster. I like Naruto cause of the depth and emphasis they put on every detail. I like Naruto better than One Piece... solely because of Rock Lee, One of my favorite characters of all time...
________________
"“That's the difference between me and the rest of the world!
Happiness isn't good enough for me! I demand euphoria!” " |
|
bluegreenangel
|
Post #98943 |
Member
2:35 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 362
|
i like well made characters like rock lee
but one piece is the best out of all three
considering character design by crafty and creative sense alone
come on chopper the blue nosed reindeer,
zoro the 3 swords user
MAAAAD G
|
|
Calíbre
|
Post #98951 |
Madman
Member
3:05 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 3341
|
Sanji is by far my fav in One Piece, probably cause he's the only character in the manga to fight without any weapons or devil fruits... And he doesn't use his hands? He limits himself and he is still a phenomenal fighter... (on the other hand... what would he do with his hands anyways? not much...)
________________
"“That's the difference between me and the rest of the world!
Happiness isn't good enough for me! I demand euphoria!” " |
|
true_grave_unit
|
Post #98955 |
sleepy ghost
Member
3:12 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 1141
|
IMO all three are relatively close. One Piece is the top one followed by Bleach and lastly Naruto. But One Piece, for me, was a series that I feel is better if you read all at once to get the best effect. Or at least one arc at a time. If you read it a chapter a week (as it's released) it loses the effect since Oda doesn't greatly change what the main characters are capable of. Spoiler (highlight to view) Although Luffy's second and third gears did kind of come out of nowhere.
In Bleach and Naruto, everything can change in one chapter, for better or worse. Naruto was placed last because Kishimoto ticked off a lot of Naruto fans (or at least I'm sure he did based on the forums I've been on), including me, by developing characters pre-timeskip through back story and such yet post timeskip almost completely neglected in revealing their growth outside of Team 7 and Shikamaru.
________________
"When we remember we are all mad, the mysteries disappear and life stands explained."
- Samuel Clemens/Mark Twain |
|
bluegreenangel
|
Post #98958 |
Member
3:30 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 362
|
Spoiler (highlight to view) 1st and 2nd gear + Nightmare Luffy < Demon Fox Mode < BANKAI !!!!!!!!!!!!!! VAIZARD !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Last edited by lambchopsil at 4:29 am, Nov 30
|
|
daed
|
Post #98964 - Reply to ( #98958) by bluegreenangel |
Member
3:52 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 1574
|
Quote from bluegreenangel Spoiler (highlight to view) 1st and 2nd gear + Nightmare Luffy < Demon Fox Mode < BANKAI !!!!!!!!!!!!!! VAIZARD !!!!!!!!!!!!!
be sure to put a spoiler tag on the end too
lamb edit: Got it~
@tru_grave- yea the same thing annoyed me with the characters being basically forgotten. I kinda thought something good would happen for temari beyond her three page's in shippuuden, but so far i've been mistaken
Last edited by lambchopsil at 4:30 am, Nov 30
|
|
manhunter098
|
Post #98973 |
Member
4:22 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 345
|
I think Bleach is the best, then Naruto, and One Piece last.
Also I hope nobody other than me is confused by the use of the less than signs, used for the order in the poll, I cant tell if it was intended for the best to be on the left and worst on the left, and less than was accidentally used, or if its from right to left and less than is correct. So as not to make a mistake in that Ill not actually vote until Im sure.
|
|
twxm
|
Post #98993 - Reply to ( #98973) by manhunter098 |
Member
4:59 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 30
|
Quote from manhunter098 Also I hope nobody other than me is confused by the use of the less than signs, used for the order in the poll, I cant tell if it was intended for the best to be on the left and worst on the left, and less than was accidentally used, or if its from right to left and less than is correct.
I made that same kind of mistake on the SAT, however I think it works like Third Choice<Second Choice<Favorite
Anyway, to simplify this I gave each series two points if somebody voted it the best and one point if they put it in the middle. Unless there have been more votes since I made this, they currently rank as follows:
Bleach: 66
One Piece: 52
Naruto: 50
________________
You're unique, just like everyone else. |
|
ZeroX1999
|
Post #98997 |
Member
5:02 am, Nov 30 2007
Posts: 8
|
Whoops... I put One Piece Last... Well for me I think One Piece is much better than Bleach and Bleach is better than Naruto. One Piece gets me into how each character kinda develops and the fights are done nicely. Bleach is.... slow.... the battles are ridiculously long and drawn out. Naruto's battles are kinda short but keeps the interest there. But Naruto really lacks character development, they have WAY TOO many characters at once. Does the author have to put so many useless characters into it? Tenten? Wtf... she is like gone after the chunnin exams. Spoiler (highlight to view) (she kinda comes back after the Naruto timeskip, where she kinda fights Akatsuki....) And many more other characters that never got the spotlight.
ONE PIECE FOREVER!
|
|
Xeronia
|
Post #99308 |
Member
3:03 am, Dec 1 2007
Posts: 1647
|
I like Naruto, then Bleach, then One Piece. One piece is just too long and repetitive. And between Naruto and Bleach, Naruto is just a richer story with many more layers.
|
|
Rulza
|
Post #99524 |
Member
9:20 pm, Dec 1 2007
Posts: 2
|
One Piece > Bleach > Naruto
One Piece was the first manga I ever read and I'm still reading it 
|
|
zerius
|
Post #99538 |
Member
10:19 pm, Dec 1 2007
Posts: 7
|
Ah, I mess up. Accidentally vote for One Piece < Naruto < Bleach. I just notice the sign was less than.  I actually want to vote for Bleach < Naruto < One piece. I used to think that I would never watch One Piece, since the animation was so bad. After watching some of the episode when Luffy was fighting Arlong to protect Nami, I change my mind about it. I think it was then on that I start to watch anime that have bad animation. Some of them even become my favorites. The reason why I put Naruto before bleach is because the story line is much better and the fights are quite unique, but I must admit that Bleach battle scenes gives me the shiver every times, mostly when Ichigo first got his bankai. 
|
|
bluegreenangel
|
Post #104218 |
Member
12:17 am, Dec 18 2007
Posts: 362
|
one piece - best in adventure story and plots
naruto - best character design and theme
bleach - most epic
|
