| From User |
Message Body |
|
purplebunny101
|
Post #507574 |
Member
11:22 pm, Nov 15 2011
Posts: 109
|
Okay, so I started reading this manhwa and it's really good so far, but there is just one concern. The MC is a really weak compared to the girls in the story, now if there is one thing I hate it's weak primary characters, especially if they are the MC. I just wanted to get your opinion on if you think he might remain weak or get stronger. Honestly the last chapter showed some promise, since some guys were introduced to the story. Before I thought he would remain weak because, (who would he fight?) it would have been weird if he just fought girls tooth and nail, even if the girl is a formidable opponent. In that case the might as well had made him a girl.
so...yeah 
Girl the Wild's
________________
She says "yada!" but we all know she doesn't mean it. |
|
chineserider
|
Post #507576 |
Persona non grata
Member
11:29 pm, Nov 15 2011
Posts: 1439
|
I also really like the story, but I don't think the MC is weak per se, just that he seems very weak when compared with all of these martial arts experts at the school. That would hold him up to a much higher level than a normal school, for example.
________________
Nulla in mundo pax sincera
"Always go too far, because that's where you'll find the truth." - Albert Camus |
|
FetchTheDog
|
Post #507578 |
 Member
11:33 pm, Nov 15 2011
Posts: 24
|
I see what you mean but I don't really want the MC to get stronger. While it is one thing to be annoyingly weak, the story would be ruined if they made him strong. (After all, the way the characters are introduced make this webcomic unable to be like Green Boy.) So far, the chapters have been built around strong girls + him - like some contrast. I'd like to see the MC be able to hold his own, but not make him some fighting legend.
________________
 |
|
TRMshadow
|
Post #507583 |
TRMshadow
Member
11:44 pm, Nov 15 2011
Posts: 145
|
I like the story because it deviates from most "beat 'em up" mainstream stories.
Girl The Wild's is more about the MC strength of character rather than his physical strength. I don't really see him taking part in any training montages any time soon, I rather see him facing adversity, both at school and at home, and persevering with the help of his harem.
________________
- Certified Grammar Nazi -
... and apparently Comedy Nazi according to my family. |
|
Contently
|
Post #507590 |
El Psy Congroo.
Member
12:19 am, Nov 16 2011
Posts: 832
|
He has a strong will. And if the MC were to get strong the only thing he could do in that school is beat up girls in the tournament and that would ruin the story for me.
|
|
Bakken
|
Post #512275 |
Member
7:39 pm, Dec 13 2011
Posts: 29
|
main guy is a fucking pussy ...... predictable.
|
|
Ascension
|
Post #523443 |
Member
7:20 pm, Feb 15 2012
Posts: 74
|
I personally like the manga... Been a while since i've been reading a manga/manwha chapter to chapster. True the MC is a pussy, but even so, his strength of character is his thing.
@FetchTheDog Thanks so much for telling me about Green Boy. It's awesome.
Last edited by Ascension at 9:57 pm, Feb 15
________________
We deliver perfection and don't brag about it. |
|
MumSaidImSpecial
|
Post #542661 |
Overfiend
Member
8:04 am, Mar 29 2012
Posts: 7
|
Awful MC. Grow some balls man. But I see what kind of audience this is made for. No offence.
I just don't like to see the Character I'm supposed to identify with getting beat up by friggin 18yo girls.
________________
[3. Localdefense] The Crossroads is under attack!
[3. Localdefense] The Crossroads is under attack!
[1. General] [Orkhuntar]: metallica rullz!
[1. General] [Darkkileer]: lol metallica sucks
[1. General] [Orkhuntar]: ur mum sucks
[3. Localdefense] The Crossroads is under attack!
[1. General] [Supermon]: wers mankriks wife?
[1. General] [Orkhuntar]: lol u fkn noob
[Kudlak] whispers: kan i have 5g plz?ßß
[3. Localdefense] The Crossroads is under attack! |
|
maayan15
|
Post #567379 |
Member
9:13 pm, Aug 24 2012
Posts: 2
|
well i usually don't like this type of manga..,but this one was very good.
i think everyone can enjoy this manga
can't wait until the next chapter released ><
|
|
juij
|
Post #570097 |
Member
6:13 pm, Sep 15 2012
Posts: 5
|
I love stories with an MC who grows stronger.
To make a story with a character growing stronger you need obviously a weak character to begin with, that way you can make the reader feel fulfilled.
A lot of martial arts manga follow that pattern, weak character becomes stronger, Hajime no Ippo, The Breaker, Holyland ,Green Boy,i like them all.
I wouldn't stand a manga with a Mc who is weak from start to end, but i've never read something like that.Maybe there is some weird manga for masochist where the MC is beaten up forever , but i haven't found it so far.
On the other hand i like some mangas where the MC is a god from the very beggining, but somehow those are harder to read for me, that pattern makes me bored.
|
|
kenjohn100
|
Post #570101 |
Member
6:54 pm, Sep 15 2012
Posts: 17
|
@juij you shoud read change 123mc weak from start to end but still good to me.and song is weak in fighting not normel live.there are diffrint typs of strangth not just fighting strangth.and the ones with stronge mc from start like until death do us part,gunxclover,and aiki are some i like.also there are more but cant remember and sorry for miss spelled words.i am not so good in spelling some words.
|
|
juij
|
Post #570125 - Reply to ( #570101) by kenjohn100 |
Member
10:53 pm, Sep 15 2012
Posts: 5
|
Yes, i've read change 123 but i didn't remember , and you're right , the mc isn't taking the easy way in life, so he is a strong person, just not a strong fighter.
The manga with the most astonishingly powerfull MC from the very beggining i remember reading is ID, well, a manwha to be precise.
Don't worry for the spelling, im not native english speaker xD
|
