Baka-Updates Manga - Viewing Topic - is yuta's sister dead?

App

Try out our new iPhone application!

Manga Poll

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed

Forums

Main Index | New Posts ( all ) | Search Forums

You are now viewing a topic.

is yuta's sister dead?

Back to Papa no Iukoto o Kikinasai!

You must be registered to post!

From User	Message Body
icethegreat	Post #518485
Member 4:19 pm, Jan 21 2012 Posts: 127	Is Yuta's sister dead or just gone missing? Even though they say she and her husband are just missing it seems that theyre dead to me.
firestalker	Post #518487
Forum Firestarter Member 4:31 pm, Jan 21 2012 Posts: 285	Missing isn't dead, but they treat them as dead until proven otherwise. I'll be really sad if they find their bodies and prove their dead. I actually hold out hope that their still alive just stranded. Even the manga doesn't really elaborate on their condition... ________________ This is my Sig ..............................................................
RS456	Post #518504
Member 6:50 pm, Jan 21 2012 Posts: 177	Papa no Iukoto o Kikinasai original manga and anime they are basically dead as in both versions they had a funeral service for them. It is highly unlikely there will be any survivors in a plane crash. Missing can also mean there were bodies but beyond recognition and I am assuming this might be the case since they already had a funeral service for both of them. I am not sure about the novel but in the anime they are definately gone otherwise they wouldn't of gone as far as who is going to adopt who. But you never know the writer might pull a 180 and come up a somewhat ridulous way on how they survived which is also likely since this is also a light hearted manga. Last edited by RS456 at 7:24 pm, Jan 21
Crenshinibon	Post #518518
Local Prig Member 7:58 pm, Jan 21 2012 Posts: 1891	Iirc he has a dream in the novel about them surviving the crash and living in an African village somewhere, though admittedly it's been a couple months and I might just be fabricating the memory. Obviously that doesn't present anything concrete, but I'm sure the author's toying with the idea of them coming back towards the end of the story. Otherwise they'd have died more discerningly. This is fiction, after all. ________________ Reviews of my Work: *You are kind of boring* - Blackorion *Congratulations! Ur an asshole!* - tokyo_homi *Your awesome!!!* - Cherelle_Ashley NightSwan also said that she wanted to peg me, once, but I'm not sure whether to take that as a compliment or a threat...
RS456	Post #518522
Member 8:09 pm, Jan 21 2012 Posts: 177	I think the moral is pointing towards Yuuta selflessly doing the same for the girls as his sister did for him when their parents died for them to stay together and go through the same hardships his sister went through for him. So I think it really wouldn't mattered if they lived or died but would be nice if they do live as long as it isn't something ridiculous.
manga-fan1	Post #521815
Member 12:57 am, Feb 8 2012 Posts: 3	You realize that this is a comedy and not a drama manga/anime/novel so theres like a 10% chance, being generous, that they are actually dead, because most comedies wouldnt pull that kind of stuff unless labelled drama and/or tragedy on the genres as well.
Sakuya	Post #521817
Member 1:14 am, Feb 8 2012 Posts: 458	Its only been confirmed they are missing not dead, but not much else is revealed, I suspect the author intentionally did this to pave way for when he/she finally decides to either kill them off or reveal they are alive. Of course I would much rather they were found alive, though that probably won't happen until the series is more near the end. ________________ \| Aiki \| Medaka Box \| Tasogare Otome x Amnesia \| Witchcraft Works \|
manga-fan1	Post #521821
Member 1:36 am, Feb 8 2012 Posts: 3	You realize that this is a comedy and not a drama manga/anime/novel so theres like a 10% chance, being generous, that they are actually dead, because most comedies wouldnt pull that kind of stuff unless labelled drama and/or tragedy on the genres as well.
drunkguy	Post #523852
Unemployed Member 5:42 pm, Feb 17 2012 Posts: 722	This series does like to push people's buttons but it also swings towards saccharine sweetness at times so I would give it a 50/50 chance at this point. Though I doubt it would happen, it would be interesting to see an instance where only one of the parents managed to survived. ________________ It is better to be violent, if there is violence in our hearts, than to put on the cloak of nonviolence to cover impotence. --Mahatma Gandhi
Kaitentsuki	Post #523856 - Reply to (#518504) by RS456
Member 6:07 pm, Feb 17 2012 Posts: 718	Quote from RS456 Papa no Iukoto o Kikinasai original manga and anime they are basically dead as in both versions they had a funeral service for them. It is highly unlikely there will be any survivors in a plane crash. Missing can also mean there were bodies but beyond recognition and I am assuming this might be the case since they already had a funeral service for both of them. I am not sure about the novel but in the anime they are definately gone otherwise they wouldn't of gone as far as who is going to adopt who. But you never know the writer might pull a 180 and come up a somewhat ridulous way on how they survived which is also likely since this is also a light hearted manga. They arent dead in the manga or anime, the funeral service is done because they believe them to be dead since its not likely to survive something like that and felt it as something that was needed to be done, if someone is missing in something like that u dont wait for years to hold off a funeral.