banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

New Genre: Topical

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #530916
user avatar


4:10 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 2658


We've added a new genre: "Topical". This is from the description:

"Primarily focuses on one major topic, such as the game Go in Hikaru no Go or bread making in Yakitate!! Japan"

Please help us update any series that seems to fit that description!

Update: It seems that people are seeing this category in a few different ways than I originally intended, so I'm going to suspend this until I figure out how to deal with that.

Post #530917
Member

6:29 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 630


"Topical"? That sounds so cheesy as a label. XD I wonder if "theme" would have been a better label. (Well, maybe I don't really...)

Personally, if I saw that label on a manga I'd go "Eh?"

I just don't see how it helps for the genre area since aren't these genre labels also used as a search method?

________________
My avatar was Yves Saint Laurent's The Black Evening Dress (with big bow) first shown in 1983, photographed from his 2002 retrospective and final show. [color=#CC0066]Check out some of his collections for free (pre-2008) HERE[/color] courtesy of FirstView.
Post #530918
Member

6:42 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 1650


A lot of mangas could fall under this category, maybe too many. Like, any manga that focuses on a single idea would take this.

user avatar
Member

6:53 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 123


i agree with Xeronia that way more then half of the manga would be in that catagory.

and yet still there's no ShowBiz entertainment world music related genre's like these manga's
Skip Beat!, Honey Hunt, KaiKan Phrase, Ingenuo, Handsome Girlfriend, and ect.
ilike to read these type of manga but its hard to tell which will be like these.

________________
User Posted Image User Posted Image

Please Click on my Eggs!
user avatar
 Member

7:10 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 406


i thought there was a plan to make less genres....
but more is good too
more > less

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

7:15 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 310


Hehe, so my suggestion still made it through, in some form bigrazz

Unknown
Post #530922 - Reply to (#530921) by barbapapa
Member

7:57 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts:


Post Deleted

Post #530923 - Reply to (#530922) by Unknown
user avatar
Member

8:14 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 310


To be honest, "topical" isn't what I suggested. Nor did I still care for my "profession" genre to be added.
I just thought it was funny, after the backlash I got, for it to be added.

Unknown
Post #530924 - Reply to (#530923) by barbapapa
Member

8:18 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts:


Post Deleted

Post #530925 - Reply to (#530918) by Xeronia
user avatar


8:28 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 2658


I only meant it for series that have a specific actual, real life thing associated with them, for instance, Baseball is topical (if the entire series deals with baseball), tennis for prince of tennis, Go for hikaru no go, etc. Someone added "Yu-gi-oh" which would not be topical in the sense that I envisioned... so I guess I'm going to have to figure out how to word this a bit differently.

user avatar
Emperor of Mankind
Member

11:37 pm, Apr 15 2008
Posts: 69


What ur aim is to have mangas focused mainly on a single real life topic right...
so maybe u should call it something else

if not....then explain it better and like have a place that when u add a genre the description shows up underneath it or something.........since topical actually does fit the name:
similarly to "topical" comedian: comedian who uses relative real life specific subjects in his/her work like baseball, cooking, Dick cheney, police

the bad thing about this is that u might have to add a sub-genre section

________________
I take interest in:
Science, biases, tactical games, girls, stories,anime/manga/novels, games, hard sciences, social sciences, myself, psuedoscience, statistics, girls, science, statistics, myself, girls, science, Warhammer 40k, boxing, biking, exercising, MYSELF, GIRLS, & SCIENCE

In Order respectively
Post #530927
user avatar
Member

3:56 am, Apr 16 2008
Posts: 20


I agree with most of the people here that say that it's too broad...

I don't know... I don't think it would help anything if it was added, and it seems really confusing tbh... The less confusion the better, isn't it?

Post #530928
user avatar
Member

9:23 am, Apr 16 2008
Posts: 2896

Warn: Banned



what is its purpose?

________________
Life, what would it be without so much wrongs and rights?


Star Trek XI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rZiR-NETDr0
Post #530929 - Reply to (#530928) by ares6
user avatar
Member

10:10 am, Apr 16 2008
Posts: 50


It's not bad. There's quite a lot of manga dealing with multiple topic as well. And BLOOODY too many cant be call one or multi topics. like vampire Juji kai, what topic do you call it ? or yu yu Hakusho.

Topical is useful for sport manga and game (mmo, mmorpg) manga.

Member

2:20 pm, Apr 16 2008
Posts: 13


I think having more specific topics as genre, like sports, would be better. And I also think we should drop tragedy as a genre, cause it's too similar to drama

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!