manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
How big of a manga fan are you (in terms of # of series read / reading)?
Beginner (<10)
Casual reader (10-100)
Rookie (100-250)
Intermediate amateur (250-500)
Amateur (500-750)
Advanced amateur (750-1k)
Intermediate professional (1-1.5k)
Professional (1.5k-2k)
Advanced professional (2k-3k)
Sensei (3k+)
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Remembering Franky House

Back to News  See threaded view


Pages (4) [ 1 2 3 4 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
makhan
Post #537600 - Reply to (#537599) by thefolenangel
user avatar
Member

3:17 pm, Apr 20 2011
Posts: 6


no I didn't

naruto6302
Post #537601 - Reply to (#537582) by GGpX
user avatar
Member

4:12 am, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 30


did i said anything about it what group stole from what group? i merely stated that at one point, there was no group that scanlated One Piece early which is really the only series i followed so i know fairly well at the period which no other group scan it early, land did i even mentioned those groups you mentioned or put them down in any way shape or form? Someone need to take reading class

and @Ferozban
if you want quality, pay for it, leecher should just shut up and accept what's given them or simply shut up

Ferozban
Post #537602 - Reply to (#537601) by naruto6302
user avatar
Member

7:43 pm, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 155


exactly! leechers should shut up, so why don't you?
leechers like you are the reason bad groups like franky house exsist. you want the manga without paying for it and translated and edited as fast as possible.
maybe they were a few hours faster then binkopia, null, japflap and other groups. who cares? i rather wait a few hours instead of reading garbadge.
again you should take you're own advice and take some reading classes... and some brains wouldnt hurt you either.
ggpx mentioned those groups since you didnt seem to get why i mentioned groups. franky house did nothing but steal and release at a bad quaility. they dont deserve anything for it.
the groups that scantlate stuff to honor the mangakas work and not to get a few thousand hit on their website as fast as possible deserve respect.
leechers like you even get quality without paying for it, just by beeing patient.

so shut up leecher and suck up your fanboyism.

ohh and before i forget .... i translated (from german to english), edited and i provided raws for a short time...so much for that, try better next time or crawl back to the cave you came from.

thefolenangel
Post #537603 - Reply to (#537591) by Ferozban
user avatar
ExScanlator Master
 Member

9:49 pm, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 12


lol still we did stay long and we did massive amount of series kinda contradicts with your thesis right wink?
And it's kinda absurd to say stuff without proof, steal work, the lowest quality? LOL!

Ferozban
Post #537604 - Reply to (#537603) by thefolenangel
user avatar
Member

10:45 pm, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 155


lol you need documented proof that allmost all your works were allready in scanlation by another group? not that it's even necessary but the documented proof lies within the several pages of releases here on MU. with maybe a few exceptions everything was allready done by other just better and slower. and if i may remind you there is this little thing called honor code. what you did is called stealing.

you guys played a big role in making manga scanlation a competition, which it wasnt before. and it shouldnt be.
at least most groups still know that.

and your quality was among the lowest, in both translation and editing. even with saying it's a personal opinion, you can't actually believe it was good. it was far from good. some exceptions may at best have been mediocrite.
shall i show you examples now? i guess thats not worth the effort. just compare franky house work with let's say japflap or pick any other of the 'slower' groups which had the same projects.

and: yes you had many projects. i never said anything contrary. not that it matters anyways.

vojo85
Post #537605
user avatar
Member

12:03 am, Apr 22 2011
Posts: 53


I started with One piece when you can only find it at Null and then there was FH who had a weekly translate? Am i right? I mean i have been reading for this for 6-7 years now tell me what did they do wrong about making a weekly translate? And who stole what from who ? You all know this is illegal so how is one illegal stolen and other legal? You all think too much of some grups and some think too much of FH i think FH did there "illegal" job nicely and i admire how for 2 years they scanned one piece fairly fast. The fact is where they good at there work or did they do it on a wimp like for instance A-Team does with The breaker and other manga? I think they we're good and I'm sorry how things worked out

________________
User Posted Image

User Posted Image
Feed Me!
thefolenangel
Post #537606 - Reply to (#537604) by Ferozban
user avatar
ExScanlator Master
 Member

9:01 am, Apr 22 2011
Posts: 12


lol comparing a speedscaner with HQ scaner is just LOL!
But in the speedscaner section of the scanlating world our quality was just fine.
And there is no honor amoung thieves, and I don't think there were only "few exceptions" you will see that we not only did chapters from series that no one else scanlated, but we picked our own series too.

Most of our translations were from cnet and other star MH translators, so I don't know how that's mediocrite, still I don't know Japanese so you may be right.

On the stealing mather check vojo85's opinion he is on the scene for a long time (as I see) and his point is very interesting wink

Ferozban
Post #537607 - Reply to (#537606) by thefolenangel
user avatar
Member

10:10 am, Apr 22 2011
Posts: 155


lol, So you don't want to be compared to a high quality scanner so you can downgrade the definition of good? ok lets compare you to the speedscanners. let's see what binktopia and co. were doing back then.
right, even among speedscanner you're work was not good.
but i guess it became useless to talk about it. when we talk about 'good' scanlations a speedscanner should just shut up but you will never acknowledge that the only 'quality' of franky house was speed and nothing but speed.
saying you dont want to be compared to the other groups is just escaping the issue.


well and on the stealing (and quality) matter check out ggpx opinion just 3 comments under this, he is in this scene for a much much longer time wink
i still heard no excuse of you for what we both now said about groups like franky house: (let me qoute). "she was the one who created the model to make scanlations as quick as possible so they could force people to download from sites like MegaUpload & DepositFile and make money from those scanlations.

Now you have a bunch of groups who scanlate as fast as they can with ZERO attention to detail - not to mention accepting dictionary-translators"

so i hope you won't mind that i did not shed a single tear for you're group. wink

Jackall
Post #537608 - Reply to (#537602) by Ferozban
Member

6:37 am, Apr 23 2011
Posts: 4


aww mann.. you're too much he might be just a little boy who lost here (just look at his nickname) and don't wanna buy any manga and just want to read them freely cause he don't have any idea that it's SO DAMN HARD TO MAKE A SINGLE PAGE OF MANGA!

oh.. why do you think I know it? coz im an artist either.
so, naruto6302 just sit down please and enjoy the respectable scanlation group to take care of your fav manga.
YEAH HAPPY ENDING

max mahito
Post #537609
Member

1:25 pm, Oct 10 2011
Posts: 2


Seems like Drama likes FHS a lot.It never just leaves the gorup.Anyways, all the commotion can be quelled.The above blog post was by a staff member who was suspended.As the member didn't have any info on internal discussions, it was just presumed FHS died since we had no release for quite some time.

All that aside, Franky House was/is not dead.And no other external sources shall be believed.If we ever die, that will be clearly highlighted and indicated at our site.
That is at: http://franky-house.com/forums/index.php

Thank you,
Be Well
~M.M

MrAZ
Post #537610 - Reply to (#537609) by max mahito
Member

10:20 am, Oct 14 2011
Posts: 1


Hey MMMMMM!!! biggrin So glad to see you here! How are you?
I've been worried where I will contact you since I don't get your email. I got on at FH just a few hours ago... Why did it get suspended again? and why on copyright violation? what did they do? I thought that site has been inactive for a long time now with only SB sub-forum on...
By the way M, PM me when you have time. I have news for you if you get the drift hehe. ^_^ Oh, make sure to include your email alright? I got worried on how to contact you since that forum got suspended. I got no emails from our friends there... T_T

This is my first time on B.U. Hi to all of you! ^^ Only, I don't know if what most of you guys say about FH being this and that is really true or not. Yes, I've read folenangel's blog a few months ago, and that's where I found out about the forum's history. I was just happy to read their Skip Beat scans during that era it was mentioned. I never knew that it would come to this state this year. What I can say is that even if I'm only active on their sub-forum there, members there are friendly and not "plastic" if you get what I mean. I'm just glad I made a lot of friends. You can argue but since the issue about FH has been there, let's just move on guys... Be happy that at least even some of us don't get a chance to grab our favorite manga on the stores (which sadly even Bleach isn't here on my home country, not even Skip Beat), groups out there are posting the manga already translated. never mind the quality, I'm just glad I was able to at least read the manga. Instead of complaining, be glad you are able to read a manga because of their efforts. So let's stop arguing guys... it's already in war in middle east biggrin peace and love

max mahito
Post #537611 - Reply to (#537610) by MrAZ
Member

2:42 pm, Oct 23 2011
Posts: 2


^_^

I'm fine, AZ, thank you.I hope you're fine and doing well to.
As you can see, the site is suspended due to take down request for copyright violation of Digital Millenium Act.We were reported to be violators by somy group/induvidual.
So, yeah.Let me clarify again.We're not dead.We even hired a lawyer and we'll fight for it.

Thank you,
Be Well
~M.M

makhan
Post #562037 - Reply to (#537607) by Ferozban
user avatar
Member

2:25 pm, Jul 20 2012
Posts: 6


Quote from Ferozban
lol, So you don't want to be compared to a high quality scanner so you can downgrade the definition of good? ok lets compare you to the speedscanners. let's see what binktopia and co. were doing back then.
right, even among speedscanner you're work was not good.
but i guess it became useless to tal ...


Omg, wow, you're such an idiot and a jerk.
I just dropped by to see if there was any discussion going on only to find this shit. I'm not trying to revive the argument but I feel obligated to speak up for my many friends at Franky House.

If you've started reading manga 3 years ago, then you probably don't know that Franky House did do it's share of HQ scanlations in early 2007. I don't remember how they compared to the Japflap of that time but I do remember they were solid quality, better than many HQ groups at that time. Around that time FH didn't deal with speedscans at all.
You say FH started the speedscan race? Bullshit. Before FH even started dealing with speedscans, each week we had at least 4 or 5 releases of WSJ series. How do I remember? Because I was a one man team at that time, doing speedscans myself. And believe me when I tell you, that what you call LQ now is light years ahead of what we've been calling MQ 6 years ago. And though many say LQ is worthless, nobody can take from me the 10000 downloads (from a single server) I got in one day for a few hours of work. It made me feel really happy and appreciated.

What FH did was try to end that stupid speedscan battle. Venicia (our leader) reached out to all those individual scanlators and invited them to create one big group that could split work to produce better results faster. And it worked. It worked only for a year but it did. We did produce more releases more steadily and our quality was improving with each release. We had some great people back then, I made friendships that still last. Of course HQ groups were releasing better scanlations but they were taking weeks to do so, while we were releasing in hours. The only group that competed with us in terms of quality at that time was Binktopia and while I admit they were often coming at the top, they were only releasing the most popular WSJ titles, while we were often releasing as many as 10 chapters per week. And no, there were no better alternatives for Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle, xxxHolic and others (until binktopia picked up xxxHolic 6 months later only to release few chapters and drop it, then pick it again few months afterwards).

Now, that was a great time for FH (late 2007, early 2008) and anyone who says we were releasing crap at that moment clearly doesn't know what he's talking about. And now that's where a problem occured. In 2008 we were at our game, releasing solid MQ at crazy speed. We started getting more trainees, some of them great, some of them not so much. What we lacked was a good release flow. The only person with real power in the group was Venicia. Which means that everyone else was basically equal. We didn't have a clear quality control process, so many trainees went on to release LQ scans without consulting anyone. And while we produced many good scanlations, we started mixing some crap in. We were a big group, it was impossible for one person to have everything in their grasp at all times (even if only for the time difference reasons) but the leader didn't fancy the idea of creating a chain of power. And eventually she ended up in a hospital and left the group without a leader to manage itself. We held onto it for 2 years afterwards, I believe. Longer than I thought will be possible but it wasn't done without some sacrifices. By then most of the original staff was gone, so the group was riding on the backs of enthusiastic newbies. Some of them did a great job, some of them released crappy scans, some of them started forwarding everything to money earning sites (thefolenangel). As far as I remember, work stealing occurred twice. Once sometime early, maybe in 2007, before FH turned speedscans, I wasn't there at the moment and I don't remember what it was about. Second time much later, I believe the perpetrator was again thefolenangel.

It became too long already, so I'll just sum it up. FH is NOT a villain in the scanlating world, who released only crappy scans, stole translations and rushed speedscans battle. FH did it's share of solid scanlating work. Everyone who says different without ever scanlating anything should go and scanlate one chapter from magazine RAW. Now imagine we scanlated 1500 of them. And while there are many groups releasing much higher quality scans, a great majority of them uses volume scans that can't even be compared to magazine scans. The only group I'm aware of who did a similar share of mag scans as FH is Binktopia. They did a great job and they deserve their credit.

GGpX, I respect you as a scanlator but why are you generalizing like that? FH had many great scanlators and few shitty ones. All the stealing that occured (I remember only two cases but if you insist there were more I won't argue) can also be associated with one or two people. I know thefolenangle made a huge mess, I was the first one who tried banning her back in 2008 but I didn't have the power to do so and our leader was not listening.

Please think before you call FH putrid. We did a lot of good work and had a lot of great people. You may throw your harsh words easily but it does hurt to read all these comments after sacrificing literally weeks scanlating for no reward but kind words of people who did enjoy our scans (and believe it or not, there were many of them).


SOSAnimeBoy
Post #570159 - Reply to (#537611) by max mahito
user avatar
Member

4:52 am, Sep 16 2012
Posts: 20


Max, whatever happened to the site? I've been waiting for news. I miss the forum badly, especially Matty's ava/sig request threads sad

Unknown
Post #570282
Member

12:32 am, Sep 17 2012
Posts:


Post Deleted

Pages (4) [ 1 2 3 4 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to News  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer