I'm no scanlator, but I know what you mean.
Are there any exceptions to the rules of scanlating with regards to picking titles, though? Just curious. I'm currently having difficulties in putting my thoughts into words concisely, haha.
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Forums
New Poll - Scanlation Groups and Their Projects
From User
Message Body
Member
4:32 pm, Sep 11 2011
Posts: 317
4:32 pm, Sep 11 2011
Posts: 317
Member
12:58 pm, Sep 12 2011
Posts: 73
12:58 pm, Sep 12 2011
Posts: 73
I say let them do as they please. Scanlators share their translated projects for the populace to enjoy without charging anything. Hell, by now they could start charging and make a killing lol.
I suppose it is annoying when a weekly or monthly series takes unreasonably long to churn out. I don't contribute, so I don't really have any place to complain. However, they should consider dropping the series or doing a joint with another group. There is such a thing as being unfair to the readers. Again, I'll just sit back and wait... or forget about the series all together.
I suppose it is annoying when a weekly or monthly series takes unreasonably long to churn out. I don't contribute, so I don't really have any place to complain. However, they should consider dropping the series or doing a joint with another group. There is such a thing as being unfair to the readers. Again, I'll just sit back and wait... or forget about the series all together.
Member
6:31 am, Sep 13 2011
Posts: 402
Most series will never get picked up again if they're dropped. If the readers are so anxious for faster releases, what they should do is at least apply to the group to help.
________________
Active translations list
Completed translations list
Dropped translations
________________
Active translations list
Completed translations list
Dropped translations
I'm that guy
Member
2:37 pm, Sep 13 2011
Posts: 15
That's how I feel too, except I have multiple personalities. I often try to force myself to do projects I don't want to do, just cuz I want to do them. It's really confusing. :S
Member
10:59 pm, Sep 13 2011
Posts: 9
Unfair to the readers? Hahahaha, you make it sound like there's no way to read manga if nobody translates it.
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
Because it's a total crime to learn a new language for the sake of a hobby, right?
Member
3:51 am, Sep 14 2011
Posts: 21
3:51 am, Sep 14 2011
Posts: 21
Yeah. I mean I think groups/readers should respect other groups and not steal their projects, or ignore rules regarding online readers. But it's another beast entirely if they are not releasing the project at all.
Member
1:12 pm, Sep 17 2011
Posts: 64
I second that ~
________________
egscans.org
________________
egscans.org
Site Admin
10:22 pm, Sep 17 2011
Posts: 56
I guess I'm just a different breed of scanlator, since I find the entire "claim" or "right" to scanlate a manga to be quite stupid. If you're stealing from someone else, it wasn't yours to begin with.
Just an Old Timer
Member
4:27 pm, Sep 20 2011
Posts: 78
is that a fact? or sarcasm?
Member
9:17 am, Sep 22 2011
Posts: 32
9:17 am, Sep 22 2011
Posts: 32
There is a special place in heaven for scanlation groups that specialize in wrapping up dropped series. For instance, A Willful Muse. I may not like all of the series that they choose but I still cheer everytime I see their releases.
