manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
For a really long, ongoing series, you prefer to
Keep reading since you're already so invested
Keep reading as long it's good
After a certain point, just stop and wait for it to finish then read the entire thing at once
Just give up reading after a certain point
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

New Poll - Effect of Bad Ending

Back to News  See threaded view


Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
maine12329
Post #539229 - Reply to (#539227) by PunnyName
user avatar
Member

12:46 am, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 25


I read all of those too! I enjoyed the ending of Kobato though... Not so much for Tsubasa and xxxHolic. Tsubasa's final battle was awkward to me and xxxHolic didn't spread the ending into enough chapters to explain things like who Himawari married etc.

xxxHolic's one should have truly been the worse one since it was rushed. As far as manga endings go, xxxHolic was the only one I felt disappointed about.

RiK.dfs
Post #539230 - Reply to (#539222) by kevmasterzoc
Member

1:06 am, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 61


It's not retarded when the mangaka has more than one series with bad endings. And a "bad ending" can really differ from what most would consider an "ending they just didn't like".

naikan
Post #539231 - Reply to (#539228) by deadphoenix
Member

1:12 am, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 83


Well, to be fair to the author, bad endings are subjective. To me, I disliked the ending of Samurai Deeper Kyo because it felt like the author took a couple bad liberties with the plot in order to force a certain type of ending (trying not to spoil it...).

But then again, I was fine with the endings of xxxHolic and Mirai Nikki that others have hated on in this thread and I will continue to collect CLAMP's stories, so one person's bad ending is not another ones. I would strongly encourage you to read to the end of Samurai Deeper Kyo for free at a library and then decide if you want to invest in it.

For me, though, Rurouni Kenshin and Full Metal Alchemist are two series I'm happy to pay for in any language! Especially the beautifully re-issued Japanese collectors edition with bonus coloured pages (!!).

deadphoenix
Post #539232 - Reply to (#539231) by naikan
An innocent
Member

2:41 am, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 204


It would be nice if I could lent them in a library, but I don't live in the USA, and in my country their isn't much manga. And the ten manga that they have in the library's over here, did I already finish a long time ago. As a matter of fact, I don't think it's still a option to buy Kyo, most of the series was done by Tokyopop. And you know what happened to them...... Well, that they went bankrupt is some sort of good thing, you've got the series complete, So in the end, when you sell it in the future, to a certain Billionaire for $10000 then you've been lucky and you can enjoy your new car. At least if you want to sell it for that kind of money.

________________
When their is hope, their is live.
auriga
Post #539233
Member

2:53 am, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 275


Indeed, what counts as a "bad ending" is subjective. Case in point, Alex623 finds Adachi's endings to be dissatisfactory while I think they're sufficient especially if you consider the events which directly and indirect led to that point. But again, these are just our opinions which are subject to our individual tastes. (peace, Alex! biggrin)

I give more weight to the development rather than the actual end. If the author keeps me reading until the very end then I'm more or less bound to check out his/her other stuff ("good" art - again, subjective - is also a plus). A "bad ending" is moot if the author can't sustain my interest.

Sagaris
Post #539234
user avatar
Member

8:19 am, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 3117


Do we not get threads to discuss the polls anymore?

Joseinen
Post #539235 - Reply to (#539215) by deadphoenix
Member

9:30 pm, Feb 5 2012
Posts: 22


it's kinda the opposite for me. I didn't like mirai nikki's ending, but i'm reading big order. it's alright so far.

Turbophoenix
Post #539236
user avatar
Certified addict
 Member

2:48 pm, Feb 6 2012
Posts: 301


It really depends on what genre the next one is. If they did a romance first then an action series, then no.

But let's say that it's the same genre and the story seems worth a look, then I would still read it.

________________
User Posted Image
ShadowSakura
Post #539237
user avatar
insomniac Kagehime
Member

3:16 pm, Feb 6 2012
Posts: 2705


i read every okamoto lynn manga, even though i hate most endings
so, yes

________________
User Posted Image
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
brigee88
Post #539238
Member

3:57 pm, Feb 6 2012
Posts: 69


I would but if they did it over and over again I'm not sure I would. :/ I enjoy HMR's historical/pseduo historical stories but the endings are always so lackluster. :/ (Actually, her non historical ones are lackluster too but i won't read those anymore so...)

shinshuu
Post #539239
user avatar
Member

8:34 pm, Feb 6 2012
Posts: 27


Even if one of the author story ending suck, or good; it stil depend largely on the overall plot of the author other stories. For example, with HMR, I can only to so much until I get sick of the plot line (almost all the stories have the same plot concept). Just because I love the author doesn't mean I read their other work if the plot doesn't hook me in like CLAMP (some good, some bad; would only read those I like). I tend to cherry pick those that I like base on plot, rather than by author. If their story good, I encounter it sooner of later without even having to go the their name.

________________
Aethereal, my world.
alidan
Post #539240 - Reply to (#539221) by uzumakiwalid
Member

2:00 am, Feb 7 2012
Posts: 169


i cant go into it without spoilers... but i read such a shit ton of manga, that if i get a bad end, not just an ending i dont agree with, but an end that makes me wtf, or even rage at how stupid it is out just how crappy it makes me feel... i dont read the next thing they write till its over and i know the ending.

im more of a journey over the destination person, but what the journey is tainted because of how bad the place you end up is...

and i also take axed endings into consideration too... because just because i like the mangaka doesnt mean i want to read and get into another one of their mangas only to be ruined by another axed end... they tend to happen to the same people more often than you think...

yuno19
Post #539241 - Reply to (#539233) by auriga
user avatar
still lurqing
Member

3:39 am, Feb 7 2012
Posts: 328


hugely in agreement with you. you know, i read each comment here to seek this tone; so that i can reply, "i agree with you."

________________
grammar mistake is intentional, grammar nazis need their entertainment.
yuno19
Post #539242
user avatar
still lurqing
Member

3:44 am, Feb 7 2012
Posts: 328


As the times goes by, I perceive the ending of any art piece get greater and greater weight toward that piece overall goodness. If the ending suck, so will be the all things. If the ending is awesome, so will be the rest. But, so far, I've come across pieces that even have such unsatisfactory ending, still hook me onto the ride. Even at the re-consumption! And I conclude, no matter how big the ending may impact, it won't weight over 50% of overall. And comes the side conclusion, If the other 50% are holycow awesome, I won't mind get disappointed by sucky ending again.

________________
grammar mistake is intentional, grammar nazis need their entertainment.
Seijurou
Post #539243 - Reply to (#539234) by Sagaris
user avatar
✯ Sarcastic
 Member

2:10 am, Feb 8 2012
Posts: 597


I've never looked at those before. They've always felt redundant when the comments are already there, though I have no idea why some polls get threads and some don't.

________________
User Posted Image
Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to News  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer