banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

manga vs. anime

Poll
Do you prefer manga or anime and why?
manga
anime
both are stupid and geeky (if you chose this one, get the f**k off this site)
You must login to vote.

Pages (5) [ 1 2 3 4 5 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #117913
user avatar
Member

11:14 pm, Feb 2 2008
Posts: 187


Manga. There are less filler arcs, and those you can skip. I can get more involved when I read and go at my own pace, study the pictures if I want or skim something I find boring. Takes up less room on my computer and was usually written first.

________________
"Tu es responsable pour toujours de ce que tu as approvoise." Le Renard en "The Little Prince" Antoine de St. Exupery.
user avatar
Member

7:23 pm, Feb 3 2008
Posts: 110


b/c it's true to the writers initial and original story telling unlike in anime the story sometimes changes and sometimes the writers point doesnt get across as well as i would like b/c the anime has to cut some parts out. or re-adjust it to work

________________
http://i193.photobucket.com/albums/z204/kmacfarland/PonandZi .gif
Post #118362
user avatar
Member

7:33 pm, Feb 3 2008
Posts: 439


i prefer the first telling of the story because thats the actual story. Others that follow can be plagued with fillers or other team's sense of style/humor or what not

________________
"Let's put a smile on that face."
user avatar
Member

7:37 pm, Feb 3 2008
Posts: 588


I think that both have their own good points but I can't complain about Eureka Seven being an anime, the manga just isn't that good.

user avatar
uhh...
Member

4:33 am, Aug 2 2008
Posts: 1034


i know this is a manga site......but i went with anime, i'd just really rather watch something then read it...thats why i pray every great manga gets turned into an anime, so i'll never have to read again....

________________
User Posted Image
Post #186604
user avatar
Member

11:27 am, Aug 3 2008
Posts: 10


generally mangas are better. you get more background/depth. there are exeptions though.. but often the animes have way more fillers or leave important things out that and anime tend to overall make a darker manga "lighter" just so that more people watch it mad

there are animes that are awesome though... but generally those haven't a manga counterpart^^

Member

11:47 am, Aug 3 2008
Posts: 13


I also agree that general manga are better, but there're some anime, like Mai-hime and sequel, you can't go wrong with the anime. In fact, the anime is far superior compare to manga.

user avatar
Inactive Phantom
Member

12:54 pm, Aug 3 2008
Posts: 1078


Although I have a deep appreciation of anime and animation as a whole, there isn't that much anime that interests me. I also find it harder to simply dip into, as opposed to just picking up a manga and reading it.

Post #186768
user avatar
Member

7:00 pm, Aug 3 2008
Posts: 2342


Many anime are adaptions of manga, they never quite stay the same. Things are either added or taken away, why mess with a good formula?

I tend to also get urned off by bad animation, a lot more than art. If I see to many still frames, bad colouring/shading and the like. The soundtrack can also make or brake an anime for me too.

Manga isn't as visually appeasing to me, but I usually o for them instead. The stories are deeper, or at least hat what I expect.

user avatar
Godslayer
Member

6:10 pm, May 6 2011
Posts: 213


it depends. sometimes a manga is better than its anime counterpart and vice verse. sometimes theres a good anime or manga that don't have counterparts. my preference changes with my mood.

user avatar
 Member

8:02 pm, May 6 2011
Posts: 974


why not both? there are anime series which better than its manga counterparts, even though its seldom.

I prefer anime because there are voice and motion biggrin, sometimes manga feel kinda dull, I'm very picky when it comes to manga, but anime I just watch anything which has good animation or my fav seiyuus has roles on it.

________________
"we are people because of other people"
"I am who I am because of who we all are"
user avatar
Pew pew
Member

8:35 pm, May 6 2011
Posts: 883


Manga!
Though I do like some anime's for the voice acting.

user avatar
Member

7:59 am, May 7 2011
Posts: 245


Although missing out on Animes means missing out on many brilliant seiyuus (Oh God, I want to hear Fukuyama Jun's voice at the moment), I just can't be bothered to pick up animes nowadays. It just drags on too much, especially when it comes to those evil filler episodes.

Manga also brings out the art more, though some anime's graphic is much better than the manga (ex: Gakuen Alice).

Some people are too lazy to watch animes like me, but there are actually people out there who are too lazy to read mangas. And it all depends on the manga and anime, but I definitely lean more on Manga.

user avatar
Member

7:06 pm, May 10 2011
Posts: 33


Manga of course!

1) usually longer than the anime
2) easier to find chappies than episodes
3) I like to hear their thoughts

Anime:
1) usually funnier than the manga 'cause it can portray humor better
Fourty-Six laws of Anime:

Originally compiled and edited by Darrin Bright and Ryan Shellito

1. Law of Metaphysical Irregularity
The normal laws of physics do not apply.

2. Law of Differentiated Gravitation
Whenever someone or something jumps, is thrown, or otherwise is rendered airborn, gravity is reduced by a factor of 4.

3. Law of Sonic Amplification, First Law of Anime Acoustics
In space, loud sounds, like explosions, are even louder because there is no air to get in the way.

4. Law of Constant Thrust, First Law of Anime Motion
In space, constant thrust equals constant velocity.

5. Law of Mechanical Mobility, Second Law of Anime Motion
The larger a mechanical device is, the faster it moves. Armored Mecha are the fastest objects known to human science.

6. Law of Temporal Variability
Time is not a constant. Time stops for the hero whenever he does something 'cool' or 'impressive'. Time slows down when friends and lovers are being killed and speeds up whenever there is a fight.

7. First Law of Temporal Mortality
'Good Guys' and 'Bad Guys' both die in one of two ways. Either so quick they don't even see it coming, OR it's a long drawn out affair where the character gains much insight to the workings of society, human existence or why the toast always lands butter side down.

8. Second Law of Temporal Mortality
It takes some time for bad guys to die... regardless of physical damage. Even when the 'Bad Guys' are killed so quickly they didn't even see it coming, it takes them a while to realize they are dead. This is attributed to the belief that being evil damages the Reality Lobe of the brain.

9. Law of Dramatic Emphasis
Scenes involving extreme amounts of action are depicted with either still-frames or black screens with a slash of bright color (usually red or white).

10, Law of Dramatic Multiplicity
Scenes that only happen once, for instance, a 'Good Guy' kicks the 'Bad Guy' in the face, are seen at least 3 times from 3 different angles.

11. Law of Inherent Combustability
Everything explodes. Everything.
First Corollary - Anything that explodes bulges first.
Second Corollary - Large cities are the most explosive substances known to human science. Tokyo in particular seems to be the most unstable of these cities, sometimes referred to as "The Matchstick City".

12. Law of Phlogistatic Emission
Nearly all things emit light from fatal wounds.

13. Law of Energetic Emission
There is alway an energy build up (commonly referred to as an energy 'bulge') before Mecha or space craft weapons fire. Because of the explosive qualities of weapons, it is believed that this is related to the Law of Inherent Combustability.

14. Law of Inverse Lethal Magnitude
The destructive potential of a weapon is inversly proportional to its size.
First Corollary - Small and cute will always overcome big and ugly. Also know as the A-Ko phenomenon.

15. Law of Inexhaustability
No one EVER runs out of ammunition. That is of course unless they are cornered, out-numbered, out-classed, and unconscious.

16. Law of Inverse Accuracy
The accuracy of a 'Good Guy' when operating any form of fire-arm increases as the difficulty of the shot increases. The accuracy of the 'Bad Guys' when operating fire-arms decreases when the difficulty of the shot decreases. (Also known as the Stormtrooper Effect)
Example: A 'Good Guy' in a drunken stupor being held upside down from a moving vehicle will always hit, and several battalions of 'Bad Guys' firing on a 'Good Guy' standing alone in the middle of an open field will always miss.
First Corollary - The more 'Bad Guys' there are, the less likely they will hit anyone or do any real damage.
Second Corollary - Whenever a 'Good Guy' is faced with insurmountable odds, the 'Bad Guys' line up in neat rows, allowing the hero to take them all out with a single burst of automatic fire and then escape.
Third Corollary - Whenever a 'Good Guy' is actually hit by enemy fire, it is in a designated 'Good Guy Area', usually a flesh wound in the shoulder or arm, which restricts the 'Good Guy' from doing anything more strenuous than driving, firing weaponry, using melee weapons, operating heavy machinery, or doing complex martial arts maneuvres.

17. Law of Transient Romantic Unreliability
Minmei is a bimbo.

18. Law of Hemoglobin Capacity
The human body contains over 12 gallons of blood, sometimes more, under high pressure.

19. Law of Demonic Consistency
Demons and other supernatural creatures have at least three eyes, loads of fangs, tend to be yellow-green or brown (but black is not unknown), and can only be hurt by bladed weapons.

20. Law of Militaristic Unreliability
Huge galaxy-wide armadas, entire armies, and large war-machines full of cruel, heartless, bloodthirsty warriors can be stopped and defeated with a single insignificant example of a caring/loving emotion or a song.

21. Law of Tactical Unreliability
Tactical geniuses aren't...

22. Law of Inconsequential Undetectability
People never notice the little things... Like missing body parts, or wounds the size of Seattle.

23. Law of Juvenile Intellectuality
Children are smarter than adults. And almost always twice as annoying.

24. Law of Americanthropomorphism
Americans in Anime appear in one of two roles, either as a really nasty skinny 'Bad Guy' or a big stupid 'Good Guy'.
First Corollary - The only people who are more stupid than the big dumb Americans are the American translators. (Sometimes referred to as the Green Line Effect.)
Second Corollary - The only people who are more stupid than the American translators are the American editors and censors.

25. Law of Mandibular Proportionality
The size of a person's mouth is directly proportional to the volume at which they are speaking or eating.

26. Law of Feline Mutation
Any half-cat/half-human mutation will invariably:
a) be female
b) will possess ears and sometimes a tail as a genetic mutation
c)and wear as little clothing as possible, if any.

27. Law of Conservation of Firepower
Any powerful weapon capable of destroying/defeating an opponent in a single shot will invariably be reserved and used only as a last resort.

28. Law of Technological User-Benevolence
The formal training required to operate a spaceship or mecha is inversely proportional to its complexity.

29. Law of Melee Luminescence
Any being displaying extremely high levels of martial arts prowess and/or violent emotions emits light in the form of a glowing aura. This aura is usually blue for 'good guys' and red for 'bad guys'. This is attributed to Good being higher in the electromagnetic spectrum than Evil.

30. Law of Non-anthropomorphic Antagonism
All ugly, non-humanoid alien races are hostile, and usually hell-bent on destroying humanity for some obscure reason.

31. Law of Follicular Chroma Variability
Any color in the visible spectrum is considered a natural hair color. This color can change without warning or explanation.

32. Law of Follicular Permanence
Hair in anime is pretty much indestructable, and can resist any amount of meteorological conditions, energy emissions, physical abuse, or explosive effects and still look perfect. The only way to hurt someone's hair is the same way you deal with demons...with bladed weapons!

33. Law of Topological Aerodynamics, First Law of Anime Aero-Dynamics
ANY shape, no matter how convoluted or odd-looking, is automatically aerodynamic.

34. Law of Probable Attire
Clothing in anime follows certain predictable guidelines.
--Female characters wear as little clothing as possible, regardless of whether it is socially or meteorologically appropriate. Any female with an excessive amount of clothing will invariably have her clothes ripped to shreds or torn off somehow. If there is no opportunity to tear off the afore-mentioned female's clothes, then she will inexplicably take a shower for no apparent reason (also known as the Gratuitous Shower Scene).
--Whenever there is a headwind, a Male characters will invariably wear a long cloak which doesn't hamper movement and billows out dramatically behind him.
First Corollary (Cryo-Adaptability) - All anime characters are resistant to extremely cold temperatures, and do not need to wear heavy or warm clothing in snow.
Second Corollary (Indecent Invulnerability) - Bikinis render the wearer invulnerable to any form of damage.

35. Law of Musical Omnipotence
Any character capable of musical talent (singing, playing an instrument, etc.) is automatically capable of doing much more "simple" things like piloting mecha, fighting crime, stopping an intergalactic war, and so on... especially if they have never attempted these things before.

36. Law of Quitupular Aggultination
Also called "The Five-man Rule," when "Good Guys" group together, it tends to be in groups of five. There are five basic positions, which are:
a) The Hero/Leader
b) His girlfriend
c) His Best Friend/Rival
d) A Hulking Brute
e) A Dwarf/Kid
Between these basic positions are distributed several attributes, which include:
--Extreme Coolness
--Amazing intelligence
--Incredible Irritation

37. Law of Extradimensional Capacitance
All anime females have an extradimensional storage space of variable volume somewhere on their person from which they can instantly retrieve any object at a moment's notice.
First Corollary (The Hammer Rule) - The most common item stored is a heavy mallet, which can be used with unerring accuracy on any male who deserves it. Other common items include costumes/uniforms, power suits/armor, and large bazookas.

38. Law of Hydrostatic Emission
Eyes tend to be rather large in Anime. This is because they contain several gallons of water, which may be instantaneously released at high pressure through large tear ducts. The actual volume of water contained in the eyes is unknown, as there is no evidence to suggest that these reservoirs are actually capable of running out. The reason water tends to collect in the eyes is because Anime characters only have one large sweat gland, which is located at the back of the head. When extremely stressed, embarrassed, or worried, this sweat gland exudes a single but very large drop of sebaceous fluid.

39. Law of Inverse Attraction
Success at finding suitable mates is inversely proportionate to how desperately you want to be successful. The more you want, the less you get.
First Corollary Unfortunately, this law seems to apply to Otaku in the real world...

40. Law of Nasal Sanguination
When sexually aroused, males in Anime don't get erections, they get nosebleeds. No one's sure why this is, though... the current theory suggests that larger eyes means smaller sinuses and thinner sinus tissue (see Law #38 above). Females don't get nosebleeds, but invariably get one heck of a blush along the cheeks and across the nose, suggesting a lot of bloodflow to that region.

41. Law of Xylolaceration
Wooden or bamboo swords are just as sharp as metal swords, if not sharper.

42. Law of Juvenile Omnipotence
Always send a boy to do a man's job. He'll get it done in half the time and twice the angst.

43. Law of Quadrotriscadecophobia
There is no Law #43.

44. Law of Nominative Clamovocation
The likelihood of success and damage done by a martial arts attack is directly proportional to the volume at which the full name of the attack is announced.

45. Law of Uninteruptable Metamorphosis
Regardless of how long or involved the transformation sequence or how many times they've seen it before, any 'Bad Guys' witnessing a mecha/hero/heroine transforming are too stunned to do anything to interrupt it.

46. Law of Flimsy Incognition
Simply changing into a costume or wearing a teensy mask can make you utterly unrecognizable to even your closest friends and relatives.

Member

5:10 am, Jun 1 2011
Posts: 20


it depends i guess.
to me, manga is more convenient 'cause it's more accessible to me and is less time consuming than anime. it's also harder for me to sit down and watch episodes nowadays, because i am extremely restless for some reason and i find it harder to be engaged.
if i had all the time in the world, i might like anime better. music really helps and anime has the advantage of having more platforms on which it can convey stuff and pull us along with.

but i like manga because even though it is a more simple medium, it can affect me just as much as any film or animation can.


Pages (5) [ 1 2 3 4 5 ] Next
You must be registered to post!