You are now viewing a topic.

(seemingly) unrequited love results in breakdown

From User	Message Body
Lorska	Post #569614
Member 4:05 pm, Sep 11 2012 Posts: 1137	Hello guys (and girls), I'm looking for some help again. This time I'm looking for some romance manga where there is some kind of shock situation for the MC because he/she sees his/her love interest with another guy/girl or a similar situation. He/she should recover from it (though it doesn't matter how long it takes) and shouldn't just give up on his/her interest, though it is not required for them to end up together (Tonari no Atashi). It is preferred that she doesn't know this beforehand. Even better If one (the reader) doesn't know this either (Namida Usagi - Seifuku no Kataomoi). Another similar example would be Hiyokoi, where she misunderstands what he says and takes it for a confession to the other girl. Another point would be that one needs to be able to empa-/sympathize with the characters, this doesn't mean that they shouldn't be cliched, but that the art and presentation of the characters are well enough and compatible. (I guess Hiyokoi readers would understand what I mean...) Edit: The seemingly means that it doesn't have to be unrequited, but at that moment the MC thinks that way! Required: relatable or likable characters romance breakdown/shock triggered by another (possible) interest of the MC's love interest (see above section) Pros: slow romance character progression drama shoujo or seinen Cons: sports music Excluded: sexual content - this includes: hentai, smut, mindless ecchi poured into the story for no reason (plot-wise) shoujo-ai, shounen-ai, yaoi, yuri extreme violence/gore one-shots Please don't link to categories. thanks in advance! ________________ in need of romance? uncommon, sad, sweet
Allez	Post #569616
Member 4:30 pm, Sep 11 2012 Posts: 420	It has been a while since I read it, but I believe Oishii Kankei fits.
holyxphoenix	Post #569652
Member 10:25 pm, Sep 11 2012 Posts: 28	Maybe Bokura wa Itsumo?
elliemoran	Post #569656
Member 10:41 pm, Sep 11 2012 Posts: 233	None have a strong breakdown, but I think these fit to some degree: Principal Surprisingly good. The summary doesn't do this one justice - and the second love interest is...unexpected Sweet Black Bitou Lollipop plot wise, definitely fits. But while I personally like the main girl, the characters overall are not always likable. Lovely Everywhere I've been wanting to mention this one to you for a while - the girl is reminiscent of Hiyokoi, but the characters split from there. Very cute and funny (I thought). That shock moment happens, but might not be drama-like enough for what you wanted.
Lorska	Post #569661
Member 11:27 pm, Sep 11 2012 Posts: 1137	@Allez: hmmm I usally keep my distance from josei, I'll see if I get back to this later, thanks anyway @holyphoenix: I've seen this one quite a lot recently, for now the Multiple protagonists and love triangle tags kept me from starting, but I guess I'll try it, thanks @elliemoran: thanks, I didn't stumble over those yet, but art and summaries seem good enough to start reading. I'll look into Lovely Everywhere, can't let your intention to mention this go to waste again thanks, and I'm still looking for more to stack up and read through Last edited by Lorska at 10:56 am, Sep 12 ________________ in need of romance? uncommon, sad, sweet
elliemoran	Post #569681 - Reply to (#569661) by Lorska
Member 3:12 am, Sep 12 2012 Posts: 233	It might have just been me, but I was pleasantly surprised by it. But I'm hoping it really is as good as I remember it being
Lorska	Post #570725
Member 10:36 am, Sep 20 2012 Posts: 1137	Bump. Any more out there? ________________ in need of romance? uncommon, sad, sweet
Niana	Post #570736
Member 12:45 pm, Sep 20 2012 Posts: 31	Katakoi no Tsuki ? but it's only one volume
Lorska	Post #570738
Member 12:59 pm, Sep 20 2012 Posts: 1137	thanks, I really don't mind length except for one-shots. ________________ in need of romance? uncommon, sad, sweet
Niana	Post #570744
Member 2:18 pm, Sep 20 2012 Posts: 31	There are some really great oneshots out there that don’t feel unfinished or rushed, (in general not for your request), what I meant was, this manga feels a bit too short for the story that was told. If I remember right, I liked the beginning but the end was rushed, for a one volume manga it would have been better to have another ending. I searched a bit for another manga to recommend you for not being out of topic Maybe you could try Kiss, Zekkou, Kiss There is not a big breakdown or shock, but the element is there. The manga is quite unique in the way the story is told from two perspectives. It is short as well but use its time better (in my opinion)
Lorska	Post #571570
Member 11:49 am, Sep 27 2012 Posts: 1137	Thanks, I'll give it a shot and BUMP. ________________ in need of romance? uncommon, sad, sweet
Yankee-chan	Post #571571
K-Indie★ Member 12:16 pm, Sep 27 2012 Posts: 427	Spontanously, how about giving H or Senpai to Kanojo a try? The first one may have a rather old-school or edgy style of art, but the storyline is by times able to convey the feelings of the characters pretty well. As for the latter one: In a way it has just the right length for me, so that it won't be depressing, but is keeping the actions of the characters somewhat realistic. ^^" ________________ "It's like love is a bonus in your life. Even without it, I'm just fine. I don't feel like pointlessly searching for it. You don't have to make yourself unhappy." (Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji) "Dreams, we say ... If you quit, then it's over. If you never give up, there will always be another chance." (Yume Miru Taiyou) "Why does it rain?" - "To create drama." (Drops (Andou Yuki))
pedrob08	Post #571631
Member 2:35 am, Sep 28 2012 Posts: 13	Suzuka or GE or Hoshi no Furu Machi ??
Lorska	Post #571709
Member 2:49 pm, Sep 28 2012 Posts: 1137	@Yankee-chan: thos eseem interesting, thanks. @pedrob08: the first two seem to heavily rely on echhi... the last one caught my eye some time ago, though, I think I'll start that one. Thanks. ________________ in need of romance? uncommon, sad, sweet