|well, i second Pandora Hearts but haven't read the others so don't know (yet)
but from what i do know i recommend:
Fushigi Yuugi: Genbu Kaiden - has all your um requested conditions except horror, doesn't have that, but you should read it
Gakuen Alice - also has them all, only have to mention that from the beginning it's more of a comedy/happy-go-lucky type thou you can hint the darkness=tragedy there & as it goes on it gets more & more tragic
Hatenkou Yuugi - it's a must read
Ayashi no Ceres - it doesn't have here at mangaupdates a tragedy tag but i believe it is, it's worth reading anyway, if i remember correctly i cried while reading it
Bitter Virgin - more of a serious/tragic horrific story, but - it doesn't have anything supernatural sooo, i guess it doesnt fit
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
in short the girl was repeatedly raped by her step-father and got pregnant, then it tells how she deals with it/heals, sort of
Chrno Crusade - you'll cry, believe me, it's a must read
Crimson-Shell - it's short, good & after reading it you'll want more
Ghost Hunt - everything but romance, at least not really, more of a horror/investigation manga but it's better than good, great
Hana to Akuma - tragedy is at the end & you'll love it, a perfect ending (fro my perspective)
Hotarubi no Mori e - the 2nd story is the one i remember the best from this one; it's good
Immortal Rain - it's good, real good
Rec - Kimi ga Naita Hi - no supernatural, comedy or horror but you'll love it, it's short, perfect & one of a kind!!!!!!!! a definite must read, cant not cry at the very end
Usotsuki Mi-kun to Kowareta Ma-chan: Totteoki no Uso - doesnt have supernatural or comedy, but it was good and short if a bit sick from my perspective but still good, nah it was good & done in a clever/interesting way if i remember correctly
The Record of a Fallen Vampire - there's no comedy (thou i think there was even if a bit now & then) or horror, but it's perfect.Perfect. This one's also a must read, a genius work which will bring out your tears
hmmm i think that's all i recall from my favorite tragic manga which makes one cry & think 'bout it long after it's finished
Last edited by Rouzmary at 12:57 pm, Nov 13
...Nothing is Eternal but Eternity...
...Enjoy Life as Much as You Can...
...And do Whatever You Want...
...Because it May be Only One...