banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Romance Like This

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member

5:42 pm, Dec 26 2012
Posts: 130


I've been digging into non-romantic plots for a while (and I've been loving it, thanks everyone smile ), but I'm kind of missing it. Romance and I don't usually click though. Don't get me wrong I like romance; it's just the blacksheep of my fantasy world lately.

Criteria:

Genre
1) No shoujo ai, yuri, or yaoi
2) No ecchi or smut
3) No harem (unless it's really a love triangle with random hotties around)
4) Romance has to be main plot
5) No hardcore tragedy

Characters
1) No overly blushy females
2) No cold or completely self-absorbed inconsiderate males
3) No playboys or playgirls
4) No easily melted facade/disguise
5) Each party possesses some degree of common sense
6) No incredibly passive male or females (slapping love interest or assaulter then withering underneath while blushing is NOT non-passive)
7) Good at everything characters? No thanks.
8) No easily manipulated MCs
9) Incredibly rare and optional---Neither character really expected love nor looked for it
10) No female tsunderes

Relationship
1) Actual arguments! Hitting and/or yelling done by both parties
2) If hatred/dislike prior, must be mutual and for a good reason that isn't one of them being a rapist or mental scarring bully
3) Not abusive or unhealthy

Nothing by Hwang-Mi Ri, Han Yu-Rang, or Shinjo Mayu

Thanks so much for reading this! This was probably a real eye full. Sorry. A million thanks for each person that answers! Here's some extra info that really isn't necessary, but might help:

Stuff that fits:
Lovely Complex
Bring It On

Works I liked that are exceptions:
Hot Blooded Woman
Please Save My Earth
Let Dai
The Tarot Cafe
Hot Road

________________
I like my men androgynous.
I like my women androgynous.
user avatar
Noblesse Forever!
Member

6:23 pm, Dec 26 2012
Posts: 1067


Billionaire Girl
Spice & Wolf (Novel) You can try the anime or manga,too. Novel is the best though (Also, its highly favoured by MU's romance god wink )
Blood Alone Romance/Supernatural (I believe romance is the main theme).
Orange Marmalade
Otoyomegatari
Emma

------------
Recommended stuffs though might not fit some of your criteria. Too good to be ignored~

Melo Holic Tragedy. Hardcore? Judge that for yourself.
Natsu no Zenjitsu Loves scenes but they are plot requirements. Dont worry its neither ecchi or smut.
Honeymoon Salad Love scenes, but good. Actual arguments!



Last edited by strixflash at 6:51 pm, Dec 26 2012

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

6:41 pm, Dec 26 2012
Posts: 511


Maybe Reimei no Arcana, as far as I can semember it ticks all your boxes plus its a fantasy, which you seem to like.

Another one could be The prince's cactus, he's a bit of an arrogant brat at first but its an interesting manga because of the female lead.

Another one where the female lead wins is Akuma to love song.....though I can't really remember the main love interest fighting with the female mc, but there is a lot of conflict in this manga from a lot of different people. Lots of arguing and nasty things done and both the main two have their times of being bratty or caught up in the turmoil.

Beauty pop-whole manga is basically the thawing process between these two male and female students that have hairdressing aspirations and conflicting backgrounds. Lots of arguments...

I suppose you could say Skip beat! fits you're description....cause there is/has been arguments and conflict...

Haou gakuen misoragumi has arguments and there is a good reason for it all, so thats another that fits, although the pairing isn't cemented yet...its just so funny, I advise~


Post #581981
user avatar
Member

7:13 am, Dec 28 2012
Posts: 1792


Pretty much what strix said. You should look into the seinen department.
Bonnouji
Chokotto Sister
Densha Otoko
Hachimitsu to Clover

Second Melo Holic

________________
in need of romance?
uncommon, sad, sweet
Member

7:39 am, Dec 28 2012
Posts: 106


Molester Man
By Chance, We... and...

Last edited by kaidiego at 8:03 am, Dec 28 2012

________________
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844 - 1900) - "Man is more ape than many of the apes."

Jean-Paul Sartre - "You are--your life, and nothing else."

Henrik Ibsen - "The majority is always wrong; the minority is rarely right."
Post #582010
user avatar
Member

10:11 am, Dec 28 2012
Posts: 250


Solanin
Nodame Cantabile

possible exception: Heart of Thomas - shounen ai and somewhat tragic, but it's one of the best manga I've read

oh and I'm glad to see another Hot Road fan

Last edited by Roughan at 10:16 am, Dec 28 2012

________________
User Posted Image
Post #582011
user avatar
Member

10:23 am, Dec 28 2012
Posts: 38


Can I just say that I love how you described your request? It's pretty much what I look for in romance manga! haha Forced and shallow romances, and characters with no personalities can get pretty annoying at times! bigrazz

Anyway, here are my suggestions:
Ao Haru Ride
Cat Street
Dengeki Daisy
Hibi Chouchou
Akagami no Shirayukihime
Akatsuki no Yona
Oboreru Knife
Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun

Hope this helps! smile

________________
(c) credits go to shizuu for the avatar! smile
You must be registered to post!