manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
When I read an unknown word or complicated term, I typically...
Gloss over it and don't bother looking it up
Use Google and read the first result
Go old-school and use a dictionary
Use Wikipedia (or an encyclopedia) and read everything about it as well as the related stuff
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Art vs. Plot

Back to Shoujo/Josei

Pages (17) [ First ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #246351

11:49 am, Jan 8 2009
Posts: 78

i rather have a great plot then the art but if the arts awful i just drop the series but it's a win win if there's a manga/anime with a great plot and awesome art

pieces of eternity are falling through the cracks of sweat, pain and guilt
Post #246353
user avatar
Yours Truly,

11:51 am, Jan 8 2009
Posts: 2050

if it's Josei..I'm not picky about the Art but it's the Plot that matters. But a good art is a plus for me.

As for shoujos....this is kinda hard..I rather choose the plot rather than the art...Prolly cuz I don't trust the cover as much as the cliche plots that I would be expecting once I read them.. none

User Posted Image
The Hidden Agenda=Gol.D.Ace

This Week's favourite:
DoLL (Okado Tatsuya)
Post #254026

4:53 pm, Jan 31 2009
Posts: 33

Well, I'll start reading if it has good art, but I'm not going to stay if the plot makes me want to kill the author so she cant write anymore. >.>

Post #254033 - Reply to (#254026) by 50carrots
user avatar

5:06 pm, Jan 31 2009
Posts: 60

Quote from 50carrots
Well, I'll start reading if it has good art, but I'm not going to stay if the plot makes me want to kill the author so she cant write anymore. >.>

I tend to do this too. The only time I don't look at a title is when the art style is too old. I tend to hate 'em because they hurt my eyes~, and i cannot relate to them ( I'm only 15 yrs. old). Only [m]ADACHI Mitsuru[/m] has passed through this barrier.

Post #254035
user avatar

5:10 pm, Jan 31 2009
Posts: 466

Personally I prefer a balance between art and plot.
If I have to choose between both; Plot!!!!

Looking for this!!!

A new day is beggining
Post #254037
user avatar

5:18 pm, Jan 31 2009
Posts: 104

Shoujo is the one genre that I think twice before reading a series with a good art. I'd ditch a shoujo series with laden cliches, weak characters, etc despite having amazingly beautiful art. I'd read shoujo with terrible art anytime as long as the story's good. So yeah, I pick plot over art in the case of shoujo-- or any genre for that matter.

Post #254217
user avatar
Keeper of Nothing

1:18 am, Feb 1 2009
Posts: 23

Generally in that genre i don't pick much of anything from it.
The whole anoerix look with the super long body parts and everyone tooth-pick thin just doesn't catch my eye.
I might still peek at it if i see it. But if I'm going to buy it the artworks has to good. And of course plot.
Artwork without plot. A story book.
Plot without art. A novel
i think? lol

Post #261309
user avatar

10:39 pm, Feb 25 2009
Posts: 15

For me, it's a combination of both. The first thing I look at is the plot summary, but if the art absolutely sucks, I won't go much further unless I've been given a strong recommendation.

Post #262644

5:06 am, Mar 2 2009
Posts: 71

I think both are equally important, but I tend to get put off if the manga has a nice story/premise but not nice enough (okay, bad) art to back it up. The manga muist have an interesting story and a nice/gorgeous art, otherwise you're better off reading a novel. Ironically, I prefer shounen art style, with it's realistic and clean drawings than shoujo's too flowery and sketchy art.

Post #262646

5:17 am, Mar 2 2009
Posts: 34

Art before plot in manga. mostly becuase the plot is express through the art. A picture is worth a thousand words.

Post #269233
user avatar

3:03 am, Mar 21 2009
Posts: 94

Plot summary is what I go by first, but if I open the book and go 'bleh' at the art, I put it down. Bad art is a serious turn off!

shojo reviews, news, opinions, and more. Check it out!
Post #270862
user avatar

7:51 pm, Mar 26 2009
Posts: 5

Definitely plot. Whenever I see a shoujo manga with the characters looking like many other shoujo leads, I tend to skip them, although sometimes I try to read their plot summary. If it seems interesting, I read the manga. If not, no. Although there are times that when the art is so bad that it doesn't pique my interest anymore, I don't even think of picking it up.

Post #270863
user avatar

7:58 pm, Mar 26 2009
Posts: 140

I don't care how awful the art is if the plot is good I am game.

User Posted Image
Post #270864
user avatar

8:16 pm, Mar 26 2009
Posts: 819

I like good art but if the plot is awful the best art in the world won't make me read it. I'm a lot more tolerable about art than I am for plot.

The pen is mightier than the sword...and considerably easier to write with.
Post #275213
user avatar
Sweetly Macabre

11:25 am, Apr 12 2009
Posts: 1005

My idea of good art is usually pretty different from most people, and I'm odd in my choices of plot too. I'm usually very obsessive about picking a good title in both plot and art before reading it. Still, plot comes first by far.

Pages (17) [ First ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 ... Last ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Shoujo/Josei  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search