banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Shonen Manga Without the "Nakama Power" Theme

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member

12:28 pm, Nov 11 2014
Posts: 8


Nakama means comrade in Japanese, and several shonen manga use this theme.
Example: One Piece, Fairy Tail.
Sure, it might sound nice, but it's not realistic.
Your "friends" don't always save you.
It's just how the world works.
no

user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
 Member

1:38 pm, Nov 11 2014
Posts: 2406


Popular and good examples:
Death Note,Akumetsu, Evangelion(was shonen once).
Kenshin/Embalming have friends but friendship=powers won´t show up.
Durarara!! is about inversions of cliche.
Claymore to a degree.

________________
I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb
User Posted Image
user avatar
 Member

8:17 am, Nov 12 2014
Posts: 1181


Double Arts? Nakama

________________
Tournament Round 1
Round 2
User Posted ImageUser Posted Image
Post #656062 - Reply to (#656006) by StarrySkies
user avatar
Mythical Creature
Member

10:43 am, Nov 12 2014
Posts: 285


Quote from StarrySkies
Nakama means comrade in Japanese, and several shonen manga use this theme.
Example: One Piece, Fairy Tail.
Sure, it might sound nice, but it's not realistic.
Your "friends" don't always save you.
It's just how the world works.
no


You need stronger friends.

Post #656084 - Reply to (#656062) by Cthylla
Member

7:41 pm, Nov 12 2014
Posts: 8


Hmm..

Post #656085 - Reply to (#656062) by Cthylla
Member

7:41 pm, Nov 12 2014
Posts: 8


Ha...that's straight to the point!
biggrin
But..it's easier said than done, in my viewpoint.
If you want to know why, I could go on for days.

Post #656090
user avatar
Member

10:09 pm, Nov 12 2014
Posts: 88


In the real life, your friends also have their own agenda. Like the well being of their own family and etc etc. So yeah, Shounen teaches a lot of naive things about life.

Maybe, that's why nowadays there are a lot of hikomori. People that used to be the naive idealist nakama power youth, then real life happened, and shatter everything.

Post #656107 - Reply to (#656090) by bnad
Member

5:46 am, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 41


Quote from bnad
In the real life, your friends also have their own agenda. Like the well being of their own family and etc etc. So yeah, Shounen teaches a lot of naive things about life.

Maybe, that's why nowadays there are a lot of hikomori. People that used to be the naive idealist nakama power youth, then real ...

OP sounds a bit cynical, but I agre with the above reason. While there are many "fake" friends, there are also friends that simply have different priorities. Not many people are capable of helping you during a sh*t storm, as they have other important priorities and helping usually has far more drawbacks than benefits. Distinguishing between fake friends, normal friends, and close friends has always been a necessary social skill.



user avatar
Seinen is RIGHT
 Member

7:25 am, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 2406


What i hate in youth manga is the theme that anything can be resolved or forgiven. Sitcoms for example live on that. A variation is called "liar revealed" but there is always happiness and forgiveness at the end of the rainbow for all. I do like positivity and friendship/devotion can move mountains but not blind or conditionless one. Especially if it writing is hamfisted. Drama writing without consequences is pointless. This blind tolerance is something the Nickelodeon(!!!) Avatar cartoon for example did NOT preach. Even JKR knew that Harry and Draco could never be friend even if an understanding was reached.

________________
I also read EU/US comics and am a librarian.
Manga-Masters, My ANN-Lists + Imdb
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

10:06 am, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 140


I'm not entirely sure if it's what you want, but these are a few of my favs.
The themes generally revolve around human flaws, so they can get rather dark.
Kuroshitsuji
Full Metal Alchemist
Donten ni Warau

Also worth a mention:
Bokura no Kiseki isn't exactly shonen (it's listed as josei for some reason), but it's a very interesting reincarnation manga (fantasy kingdom - Japanese high school) with an awesome twisting plotline.
One of the main themes of the story is trust and betrayal, as the main characters try to figure out who can be trusted and who is lying.

________________
Drop by my fanfiction page! biggrin One Piece, Hetalia, Bleach, Harry Potter and more!
http://www.fanfiction.net/~stelraetnae
Member

3:48 pm, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 190


Not sure if it counts or not but Black Cat seems to only OCCASIONALLY go it into, it really being important only near the end. With Trains whole, "because you're always alone there's no one there to prop you up when you fall bit," to Creed. And even then when he gets separated from his friends a bit earlier on, rather then then worry about he is all nonchalant because he knows they will be alright. Basically while it is an element of it, it does not feel overplayed to me.

________________
http://fightingdreamersscanlations.wordpress.com/
Member

5:12 pm, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 70


You're looking for comics aimed at little children/teens and complain about realism? Little strange but ok. You also give two examples and both are action/fighting adventure series. So you want an action/fighting adventure series that doesn't put emphasis on friendship? If you're looking for a shounen adventure/fighting series then you're choices are slim. Sorta like complaining that Pixar gives you happy endings. You know what you're gonna get walking into that sorta stuff.

Also a sorta off topic but the untranslated "nakama" thing came from Kaizoku Fansubs subbing One Piece episodes back in the day. They felt it was necessary for words that have special meanings/were difficult to translate. But that was a really silly decision. Because even in One Piece, "nakama" isn't some glowing, magical word. It's used casually for crew members and new friends alike. Even Viz's translator and some people working with jump believe that it should have been translated.

Even then I'd argue that One Piece doesn't even abuse the friendship trope like you suggest. Despite caring about friends/family in series like OP, HxH, Toriko, Magi, Kingdom (w/e) the main characters still lose.

Maybe in FT or Bleach the friendship will more easily turn one-sided fights, but even then I'd say you're just looking in the wrong place. You'd best be just looking at seinen series instead.

And even then some of them, like Berserk/Claymore/Dorehedoro, will still put strong emphasis on friends/family getting you through hardships. Maybe Vagabond or Vinland Saga? If you're really tired of the "kiddie" stuff then things like Nausicaa or Lone Wolf and Cub or Kurosawa will better suit you.

Or you could skip the fighting requirement instead. Then there are plenty of shounen for you. Most are probably gonna be comedies though, or still contain fighting in some unconventional way.

user avatar
Noblesse Forever!
Member

8:39 pm, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 1067


Noblesse It's getting repetitive & dull lately but I would recommened you to read it for the first three awesome seasons smile Starting is slow but a good read...

________________
User Posted Image
Post #656149
Member

10:55 pm, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 302


Tokyo Ghoul

Post #656151
Member

11:29 pm, Nov 13 2014
Posts: 10


I think the focus is partly cultural. I think I remember that japan used to have a different system in elementary school where kids were organized into groups and the grades given were given to the group. This was to foster more cohesion in these groups. I think there's a lot more focus on family and ancestors as well. Even in companies, workers are to prioritize the health of the company. Connections between people are a bigger factor in japan, in america it's more of a everyone for themselves kind of thing. I think this is reflected in entertainment, superman, batman etc, usually work alone or with someone of inferior standing. In japanese stuff it's often ensemble. Even in stuff like power rangers people are part of a team.

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next
You must be registered to post!