I resent the lack of Dorohedoro.

Bleh, One Punch Man it is

Wow, I didn't think I'd see someone else vote for that. But still, I'd vote for Vinland Saga anyway, being the greatest work I've read so far, miles ahead from anything else. And I did enjoy :



It's weird to see Liar Game while there isn't a single work of Fukumoto Nobuyuki being nominated. And I thought his previous One Outs was way more popular and liked.

Aw man, no REAL or Zetman. ;_;
Makes it a lot harder to choose my favorite...
I went with Punpun in the end because the art is so great and this interview made it make a lot more sense, but now I feel like I should've gone for Tokyo Ghoul. Ah well.

Ugh this list is awful. Boring, mundane, same old same old action or fantasy. I liked Punpun a lot so that's what I voted for.

One-Punch Man, Tokyo Ghoul and Hoshi no Samidare are seinen?! I've always thought they were shounen.

I have to chose between Berserk, Samidare and Monster??
Can´t I take them all?
The only good thing is GUNNM LO is not in list, other way I will really be unable to chose.

________________
The Darkness

I don't really feel qualified to vote, as I've read only one of the listed series, so I'll refrain this round. Seinen is the demo I'm most deficient in, so I guess it's to be expected. My current favorite is Boku Dake Ga Inai Machi, though, which I hope will take off in popularity once the anime airs. :3 This one really resonated with me, both as a writer and a human being, so I hope it eventually gets some recognition.

While I've read Monster and acknowledge that it's an ambitious and lovingly-crafted work, I don't think it's anywhere near "masterpiece" level. I think it really missed the mark on its theme, which, as a huge Shelley fan, I found hard to overlook. The fatal flaw of Frankenstein was that he was arrogant and overstepped his boundaries as a human by creating life. Then, when push came to shove, he completely shirked his responsibility as a creator, effectively proving that humans shouldn't have such power to begin with. With Tenma, though, the guy is a surgeon. He's supposed to save lives. He shouldn't have held himself responsible for saving the life of a child who would grow up to be a psychopath. Unlike Frankenstein, he didn't willfully create a monster, so the whole fatal flaw aspect is out the window.

And, aside from all my literary complaints, I found the story needlessly cluttered with side characters and subplots and didn't find it particularly engaging in its own right. But that's just my silly opinion~

________________


"Now, everything is... just..."

writer | librarian | critic

I'm gonna be like crazyboutcute and refrain from this vote too since Seinen is the one demo that I'm deficient in for the classics/mainstream. I've read most classics/mainstream manga in the other demos, but Seinen is just too big. I adore most of the things I've read that are Seinen, it's just most of them are less well known. I mean, of the manga I suggested for it, the only one that was close to being top 5 was Otoyomegatari.

________________
Must Read Webcomic:
Unsounded

Lists:
Reading
Complete
Western Webcomics

I'm so glad Vagabond made it to the poll! It's not getting a lot of votes though... Too bad, this manga has become really important to me and I do think it's because it truly is a masterpiece.

My second favorite, Vinland Saga, is not doing much better... Oh well, at least I'm glad it's on the poll too.

I guess Berserk is gonna be the winner... It's not that I don't like it, I do, but it just makes me feel that people enjoy gore and violence way too much. I guess that explains why Tokyo Ghoul is so high, too.

Voted for Berserk. I have read most of the titles in the polland enjoyed them except Kingdom and Liar Game.

PS: Kingdom and Liar Game have the most annoying main character. Their personality is so one dimensional that they don't feel like seinen characters at all.

________________

Eh, I can't vote.

Even if you added the next in lines (Otoyomegatari, Real, 20th Century Boys and Kiseijuu) and other stories by the same authors (Spirit Circle, Historie) on top of that, I would still not be able to make a top 10 and "drop" 6.

They are all too good for me to choose some above the others.

I guess I really love seinen. <3

Well...I voted for Berserk. And by looking at readership, it's easy to tell, that it's going to win.
Then, only 2nd to it will be One Punch Man(it's a masterpiece, believe me!).
Sad, 20th Century Boys didn't make the cut. If it was a Ongoing series the story would've been different. But, still! Wonder how did it ended up losing to Oyasumi Punpun...Weird.

Now, talking about Tokyo Ghoul:re sequel of Tokyo Ghoul. The sequel only does a timeskip.
So, yeah. Having one in the list basically means having bot. Plus, it's not very long from the time :re started. After 1 or two year, the story might be different.

This poll is balanced. Including recent ongoing ones. Quite satisfactory.

________________
[img]https://i.imgur.com/ERg8slD.gif[/img
[img]https://i.imgur.com/HphHlPh.gif[/img]
Tv Tokyo - Anime & Manga ~ MinatoAce

Lots of good series but Monster is a classic.

________________
<!--img--><img src='https://i.imgur.com/YtOi9Fg.jpg' border='0' alt='User Posted Image'><!--img_end-->

I had a giant obsession about half of these series, it just might kill me to choose one. The other half, are recommendations for me to read next.

I tried to read berserk a few times but it didn't interest me at all. I don't understand why there are so many people that likes it.