manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
When was the last time you read a non-manga related book outside of school purely for pleasure?
Right now!
A few days ago
A few weeks ago
A few months ago
Over a year ago
So long ago that I don't remember
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Is Fruits Basket really all THAT?

Back to Fruits Basket


Pages (11) [ First ... 7 8 9 10 11 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Mo-chan
Post #483854
user avatar
Member

10:47 pm, Jul 21 2011
Posts: 25


no i didnt like it
its a bit cliche too and if you continue reading it gets predictable and boring
its not the greatest to read and not the worst i also think it recieved too much praise
no offense to those who liked it

neonkitty
Post #483855
user avatar
Member

10:55 pm, Jul 21 2011
Posts: 318


i don't think it's "all that" but it's a really enjoyable read. it's not like every other shojo where it's drama after drama, fruits basket actually gives u a little time to enjoy what you just read and there's actual character development and a slow romance. personally i think it was really good and it's one of my favorites, but it's not something i would read from the start again(it's way too long xD). i don't think i've ever read a manga that's "all that" but its still up there. eyes

ms_nobody
Post #483862
user avatar
Member

11:29 pm, Jul 21 2011
Posts: 114


Fruits Basket is really not all that.

For one, Tohru is a HUGE sue. I found her annoying most of the time. Secondly, it has a lot of annoying cliches. I don't mind cliches that don't drag down the story (like in Dengeki Daisy... Teru is an orphan and is positive most of the time like Tohru, but she actually knows the right times to act happy, sad, bored, ect.... Tohru doesn't, she's just an airhead.). And lastly, Kyo just annoyed me xD... I liked Yuki.
I would have liked this a bit better if the main character wasn't so annoying though.

It's alright (not my cup of tea), but it's incredibly overrated to be honest.

Pikapu
Post #483865
user avatar
 Member

11:37 pm, Jul 21 2011
Posts: 1979


I couldn't even get through the first chapter...........

________________
User Posted Image
Quote from LawX
You are like the dense main character in a shoujo manga.
Quote from Crenshinibon
And you will murder someone one day, pika. If you're my daughter.
hyunwon88
Post #554019
Member

5:16 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 12


It has a good story line but as the story progresses it became angst filled so I think it's just above average shojo manga.

sarah-eats-cupcakes
Post #554021 - Reply to (#483865) by Pikapu
user avatar
his and her sonnet
Member

5:43 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 1125


no, i thought it was bad

Quote from Pikapu
I couldn't even get through the first chapter...........


same here, but then i read up to ch5 or 6 because my friend kept insisting its the best manga ever, but i didnt like it so i just gave up smile

Pebble_
Post #554027
user avatar
Member

6:26 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 376


Hmm... It was my first manga ever and I read when I was 12. (omg so many years ago! >_< )
And I loved it.
Even now I still think there are a lot of very interesting psychological aspects in this manga.
(Also to those who only read 4 or 5 chapters. It really gets better and better throughout the series, so if you've just read that, you've only seen the very worst of it. And the ending was quite good.)

________________
User Posted Image
Kishu
Post #554030
Member

6:46 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 19


I wouldn't say that it's the best manga that i've ever read but in my opinion it is one of a kind and you most likely won't find another like it.

alex3510
Post #554034
user avatar
Member

7:05 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 132


It is all that!!! *^_^* this manga made me smile, cry and it moved me to no end. In my opinion, it is the best manga I have ever read. Kyo's story, her adorableness and their stories of lonliness made this one so worth reading. Also, the zodiac curse is so original >_<

________________
As they played the game...I waited for someone to call "onigiri." But no one called. I was very little then. I had almost forgotten about that. [...] But they knew...there would never be room for an onigiri...in a fruits basket.
-Tohru Honda, Fruits Basket
Shourii
Post #554041
user avatar
Member

8:35 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 122


Maybe it's not all that, but it's definitely one of my fav manga.
For the first time I read it like... 6 years ago? And I keep re-reading it every year or so - it's like my sentiment for this cute, heartwarming but also sad story is just too huge smile (and the supernatural elements are a big + for me ^^)
Also liked this psychological aspect of it - family problems, lack of acceptance, guilt that prevents you from moving on - it's nice to read a shoujo which isn't all about candy&flowers ("Oh, I've met him just today, he's so handsome, I love him so much, but he doesn't love me back! What should I do!" >_>). And development of relationships! It's something that annoys me in most of the shoujo mangas - they meet, they fall in love, they live happily ever after, and all that in 5 chapters. Furuba's way of dealing with romance is something I would like to see more often (when not everything is revolving around physical attraction, but THE HORROR, ther's a litte bit of reason in it) *sigh*
Anyway, I can understand why some people don't like it (it has a very specific pace and you like Thoru or you hate her), but for me is a title from top 5 smile

________________
User Posted Image
Snassidee
Post #554047
user avatar
Member

10:31 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 53


YES. It's AMAZING. i read it over again every year. It's one of my top favorite mangas.

along with:
Gakuen Alice
Kitchen Princess
and a few others.

twammy
Post #554049
user avatar
Member

10:35 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 54


It was just okay... I can still read it but to me it's not preferred.

giinko
Post #554050 - Reply to (#483865) by Pikapu
user avatar
Psycho. Cracked.
Member

10:35 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 165


Quote from Pikapu
I couldn't even get through the first chapter...........


You just spoke my mind.

Then again, due to a great amount of boredom and curiosity, I skipped the chapters till the end. The art is definitely not the alluring point. Sometimes I ask myself how can someone draw like that and become a mangaka, when you compare it to all the other mind-blowing stunning art of other people. Secondly, the story is not all that sweet or lovely or heart-warming.
I think the most understandable reason which explains why so many people like it, is that this is the manga that is picked up the most for those who start to have interest in this field. Besides, it is published broadly in many countries.

Once you read enough manga, this one will just automatically fall in the typical, boring, cliché, predictable and plain category.


________________
Man is more ape than many of the apes.
catandmouse
Post #554055
user avatar
Member

11:16 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 433


Now that I've had time away from it, I don't hate it, I own all the volumes, I've re-read it a few times, but it is not, and never was my absolute favorite.

I actually prefer her first series, Geneimuso, over Fruits Basket, and I only somewhat enjoyed the series that came after Fruits Basket (Hoshi wa Utau).

So in short, it depends on the person. I've read much worse manga, and I've read ones that I've enjoyed more, but in general I don't think it's that bad, it has it's moments, but there are also some instances where it can grate on your nerves.

So really, it depends on the person reading it.

silvertear
Post #554059
user avatar
Member

11:46 pm, Jun 1 2012
Posts: 6


Wow this brings back memories. My very first manga! Back when I read through it the first time it was awesome, but now when I read through it, it doesn't seem as amazing as I remembered. I think the only reason why I found it so good was because of the sporadic characters like Ayame and Kagura and Kyo.

And the metaphores, gotta love her metaphores.

Pages (11) [ First ... 7 8 9 10 11 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Fruits Basket  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer