I think I'm fairly picky. I almost never pick up a shoujo cause the artwork turns me off and characters tend to annoy me. Ecchi turns me away cause it detracts from the story for me. And I usually go for romance. Once I do pick it up I will not stop until I finish it even if it begins to worsen.

________________
If it makes sense, your probably wrong.

I'm picky, in terms of what I like. I generally give a lot of things a try, usually reading the first chapter and discarding it if I don't like it at all. Nowadays, I'm getting very picky about the artwork. I used to just read anything as long as the story was good; now, I'm sick of trying to "decode" the images.
I can easily find faults in a manga and am apt to criticize most of the ones I read, but this doesn't mean I wholly dislike them.

________________
Check out my deviantart at jennerality!

I'm picky sometimes, especially when it comes to shounen manga *shrugs* Don't really know why.
For me, the art AND plot has to be up to my standards, and if I read the first chapter, and it's boring, i drop it.

________________
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ

nope. not picky in the least.

________________
We are all more afraid than we are willing to believe but we are also more braver than we could have ever dreamed.

Extremely picky.

If the art isn't something I can really appreciate after the first two pages... its out. And I usually give it a bad rating.

________________

I usally read manga from the same mangkas or read senien I barley read any shounen and never read shoujo unless if it is CLAMP.

________________
Protect Independent Film
All that we see or seem Is but a dream within a dream. - Edgar Allen Poe

Imagination rules the world. - Napoleon Bonaparte

All men are born with a nose and ten fingers, but no one was born with a knowledge of God. - Voltaire

Picky on two points.

PLOT/STORY -nevermind the artwork

No Shoujo - maybe bcoz im a guy? Or i actually tried to read some recommended shoujo titles, and by the 1st few chapters of the 1st volume, i end up dropping it.

Lol.. i'm REALLY picky >< no matter how bored i am or have 0 mangas/manhwa/manhuas to read.. if it doesnt meet my expectations i won't read it >.>

1) good plot
2) decent drawing
3) girl characters aren't all annoying >.> (ex: bleach's orihime.. i hate her!! >=[)
4) cannot be one shot! i HATE those >.>.. i mean i do read them like once.. in awhile x) but that's it =DD

________________
One day... cake, candy, chocolate, and ice cream will rule the world! MUHAHAHAHHAHAHA >=D

I know I am XD !

MUST

#1: Good art.
#2: Good plot.
#3: Year 2000+ (...iunno, i just get this bleh feeling that the art would be crappy if it's in the 1990's or below. which, most of the time, is true. >__<)

^ #1 is a VERY big must.. since I judge most mangas by their covers. horrible, I know. : D

EDIT: Forgot a very important #4: Can't be yaoi, yuri, hentai, shounen/shoujo ai, or ecchi. You know, all those genres that fall into the "adult" category.
I'd prefer to stay away from smut and gender benders, too. ;-;

What else, what else..
And mecha and horror and all those scary stuff isn't really me, either. ._.

Last edited by fishiiie at 12:23 am, Aug 29 2008

Yes, but not extremely picky
Good art & plot

________________

Is it just me or is it only those that focus on shoujo that are picky when it comes to art.

I read everything but my main focus isn't shoujo.
To me I'm never turned off by art. Good art can make me like the series more when I start reading it though.

I wouldn't say I'm too picky when chosing what to read but I what do know is that I've become alot more picky on chosing since I started reading manga.

I'm not all that picky in terms of what I read. If the series is short, I might even trudge through an entire series even if it's not my thing. My biggest restriction is my wallet because I tend to buy what I read online; otherwise I would read a lot more.

Art for me is not such a big deal. Out of curiosity, I was wondering what do some people who think that high quality art is important think about series where the art is deliberately bad to give it a specific feel (for example, certain types of comedy manga)?

If it makes me laugh, I tend to like the series (I'm a fan of romantic comedies, even if corny). I also like series which use a lot of factual information (e.g., some historical, medical). I don't like adult types all that much, but if I think the series is well thought out, I'll probably finish it.

I'll write some related points on the elitist thread:
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?page=2&tid= 5809&hl=elitist

As long as I can follow what's going on...but I need a decent enough quality of art and story

________________
Lalala~