manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
Do you read the extras / omake in manga?
Always
Most of the time
Half the time
Seldom
Never
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Nurarihyon vs Kekkaishi

Back to Shounen/Seinen


You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
songofthewaves
Post #188182
Member

1:53 pm, Aug 7 2008
Posts: 3


It may or may not have already been said, but has anyone noticed the similarities between Nurarihyon and Kekkaishi?? Youkai roaming the land, a defender who transforms in the night, a school setting, childhood love interest, background society of supernaturals (the Urakai and the youkai council), crusty old grandfather figure. I mean, couldn't the mangaka think of something a tad more original. Then again, I'll be a hypocrite and say I do enjoy Nurari, but it just fits into the type of genre I like so...

Nashnir
Post #188194
user avatar
Member

3:09 pm, Aug 7 2008
Posts: 630


I go for Kekkaishi... I have Nurarihyon but I never got the interest to read it. Dunno why though.

________________
User Posted Image

And here we go.
TimeManInJail
Post #189637
user avatar
Member

9:36 pm, Aug 11 2008
Posts: 536


Nuraihyon all the way! it just the art that so seductive!

but if they were to fight kekkaishi wins!

________________
~= Stress is what we Live FOR =~

/===~CODE OF CONDUCT~===~\
|________A Life For A Life________|
Rainy Days
Post #189661
user avatar
it's a boy
Member

10:59 pm, Aug 11 2008
Posts: 2901


Nurarihyon no Mago all the way. ;P

MikeHo
Post #189665
Member

11:11 pm, Aug 11 2008
Posts: 57


Well i dont really know cause i read Nurarihyon and liked it so i would say that one wins but when i read kekkaishi i get hella bored... If anyone suggest i should read on in the kekkaishi series tell me! Dose it get any better? confused

________________
User Posted Image[br]Feed Me! Lets see what he becomes![br]Adopted from Valenth
Saexel
Post #189669
user avatar
Patent Pending
Member

11:23 pm, Aug 11 2008
Posts: 520


Definitely Nurarihyon. bigrazz

________________
User Posted Image
metamike
Post #191924
user avatar
Member

11:17 pm, Aug 16 2008
Posts: 94


If Nurarihyon incorporates romance, and Nura gets controls of his transformation, then I can definitely see it being better than Kekkaishi. However now being only 21 chapters long, there hasn't been much room for character/relationship development, so it's very inferior to Kekkaishi.

So basically right now Kekkaishi mainly because it's at 190 chapters and by now has had a large amount of character development, but depending on how complex/simple they become one could become better than the other.

Aeylis
Post #192864
user avatar
Yaaawn
Member

11:44 pm, Aug 19 2008
Posts: 746


Kekkaishi, by a large amount. Nura is definitely not bad, however it has too much drama. I like Kekkaishi with its humor and storyline more. *sorry for updating the dead-ish post*

Last edited by Aeylis at 11:57 pm, Apr 9

________________
User Posted Image
hyery
Post #193091
user avatar
rebmeM
Member

2:09 pm, Aug 20 2008
Posts: 258


I have to say for now, i think Kekkaishi is better becuz it has been around for quite sometimes which allow a better plot and characters development. It's too early to makes comparison for Nurarihyon cuz there's just 22 chap out so for now i shall reserved my judgement on that smile .

Just so you know, i get the same feeling as Kekkaishi in the manga early chpaters when i read Nurarihyon. So i'm hoping that it'll get better through times cuz i almost dropped Kekkaishi from my reading list. Thank god i didn't dropped it cuz it's getting more and more interesting cool .

________________
****You like the things that i HATE, and i HATE the things that you like****
jamie1990
Post #194321
Member

10:30 am, Aug 23 2008
Posts: 26


I haven't read nurarihyon, but I'd say it probably wins because Kekkaishi is pretty bland and unimpressive.

bajuwa
Post #197426
user avatar
Rawrs
Member

9:50 pm, Aug 31 2008
Posts: 269


I definitely prefer kekkaishi, i find it has more character development and i can't seem to get interested in nurari no matter how hard i try.
might be the style of art though, i've noticed that kind of thing has a major influence over whether i like a manga or not bigrazz

________________
User Posted Image
From the manga: Good Luck, Demon King!
Johann Krauzer II
Post #197447
user avatar
Member

10:25 pm, Aug 31 2008
Posts: 12


I agree that it's a hard competition, because Nurarihyon is pretty recent and Kekkaishi is ways ahead. So far Kekkaishi is really interesting and the characters have good developement. With nurarihyon it still has the fault of adding too many characters at first, instead of slowly introducing and devolping the old, which Kekkaishi does just fine, and in that case is way ahead in some thing like Naruto or something. Although nurarihyon hasn't been around to say something concrete, the flow in kekkaishi is topnotch.

And about similarities... well... there a gazillions of manga and shounen manga's of the japanese mytholigy genre tend to happen to look alike no matter what. I could compare something like Ushio&Tora or whatever with it, too...so let's not start a "this is kinda familiar/I've read that in xxx" discussion. With this many manga it's kinda impossible, even with the intention of NOT creating something similiar XD"

But all in all I say Kekkaishi is 'still' better, 'yet'. Let's see how Nurari turns out. Some manga's tend to get better later in art and story... and some do not. It's not like Kami no Mizo Shiru Sekai were it is awesome from the start XD"

You must be registered to post!

Back to Shounen/Seinen  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer