Baka-Updates Manga - Viewing Topic - Is it really tragedy?

App

Try out our new iPhone application!

Manga Poll

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed

Forums

Main Index | New Posts ( all ) | Search Forums

You are now viewing a topic.

Is it really tragedy?

Back to Basara

You must be registered to post!

From User	Message Body
ajmanga	Post #199465
Shadow Member 10:13 pm, Sep 6 2008 Posts: 90	I've read the ending and it's a good one. Is it still tragedy because of their suffering and heartbreak or something? Because all those people died? Even so, they still end up together and the people stop fighting.
meroko123	Post #199469
unknown species Member 10:17 pm, Sep 6 2008 Posts: 904	i think the beginning might be the tragedy cause her freind and her brother got killed. also the suffering aswell....
ajmanga	Post #199500
Shadow Member 11:52 pm, Sep 6 2008 Posts: 90	I've read other series with death, suffering, and so on at the beginning that aren't listed as tragedy. I thought tragedies were mainly when the series focuses around great loss and misfortune and things never seem to get better. This is more an action adventure series anyways, right?
tsuto	Post #199507
Catnapper Member 12:08 am, Sep 7 2008 Posts: 3425	Well, I'm not sure, someone that has read until the ending would be able to tell. Tragedy for me means that it won't have a happy ending, which is, it will be tragic. So the beggining isn't really relevant I think. ________________ This week's favorites: - Udon no Hito ççççççç[Ô .Ô] tsutopodus© will eat your manga and steal your cats!
ajmanga	Post #199673 - Reply to (#199507) by tsuto
Shadow Member 3:05 pm, Sep 7 2008 Posts: 90	Quote from tsuto Well, I'm not sure, someone that has read until the ending would be able to tell. Tragedy for me means that it won't have a happy ending, which is, it will be tragic. So the beggining isn't really relevant I think. Yeah U have the same train of thought that I do. Should it be changed?
tsuto	Post #199741 - Reply to (#199673) by ajmanga
Catnapper Member 6:10 pm, Sep 7 2008 Posts: 3425	Quote from ajmanga Quote from tsuto Well, I'm not sure, someone that has read until the ending would be able to tell. Tragedy for me means that it won't have a happy ending, which is, it will be tragic. So the beggining isn't really relevant I think. Yeah U have the same train of thought that I do. Should it be changed? I just checked, it seem to have way too many genres. It's Action / adventure / drama / fantasy / gender bender / romance / sci-fi / shoujo / supernatural / tragedy. ________________ This week's favorites: - Udon no Hito ççççççç[Ô .Ô] tsutopodus© will eat your manga and steal your cats!
Cerulean	Post #200018
Inquisitor 12:10 pm, Sep 8 2008 Posts: 612	will someone freaking revive this project? i've never begged for scan before, but every since i lost that website to view the RAWs, i really want to see a happy ending for this series T_T ________________ The Deviant
ajmanga	Post #200513 - Reply to (#199741) by tsuto
Shadow Member 2:17 pm, Sep 9 2008 Posts: 90	Quote from tsuto Quote from ajmanga Quote from tsuto Well, I'm not sure, someone that has read until the ending would be able to tell. Tragedy for me means that it won't have a happy ending, which is, it will be tragic. So the beggining isn't really relevant I think. Yeah U have the same train of thought that I do. Should it be changed? I just checked, it seem to have way too many genres. It's Action / adventure / drama / fantasy / gender bender / romance / sci-fi / shoujo / supernatural / tragedy. OK, done. Now it's no longer sci-fi or tragedy. I'm not so sure about the supernatural tag either. I know there was a discussion like this with Claymore whether it was horror or not and the admin locked the genres. Can I ask for any administrators out there to help correct the genres then lock it? Thnx. Last edited by ajmanga at 2:22 pm, Sep 9
ahoaho	Post #200543
Smooth Operator Super Mod 3:49 pm, Sep 9 2008 Posts: 5328	If this [ a serious drama typically describing a conflict between the protagonist and a superior force (as destiny) and having a sorrowful or disastrous conclusion that elicits pity or terror] describes the ending, then it's a tragedy. ________________ Listen here Livin just to keep from dyin
Identity Crisis	Post #200552
Super Mod 4:02 pm, Sep 9 2008 Posts: 4872	Locked, as requested.

You must be registered to post!

Back to Basara Back to Top

Search This Topic:

Manga Search

MANGA Fu