I only rate manga if I feel pretty strongly about it; I read too much & have too much other stuff to do to rate everything I read (especially since I'd been reading manga for a while before I started using the listy-thingy here) - I don't even keep up with adding stuff to my "finished" list.

If I love a manga, hate it, or notice that my feeling about the manga is substantially different than the majority (lots of people rating it a 10, when I feel it's a 5, for example) then that's when I actually take the time to rate it.

________________
"[English] not only borrows words from other languages; it has on occasion chased other languages down dark alley-ways, clubbed them unconscious and rifled their pockets for new vocabulary."
-James Nicoll, can.general, March 21, 1992

if i love it, then yea, but i don't downrate anything, since others may find it and like it and the down rating affects the ratings lol

I vote the mangas that I read. Sometimes I'm annoyed to see how loads of ppl rated 9-10 for mangas that are obviously stupid...and overrated.

It also annoys me to READ vague reviews like "I like it!! The Bishies' hot and it's CUTE" or "I rated 9 for its Art!!"


________________

The Hidden Agenda=Gol.D.Ace

This Week's favourite:
DoLL (Okado Tatsuya)
Xp

I try to rate all manga I read. Even a writeup too, though that's been happening a lot less lately.

I vote when I like the series a lot, when I complete it
or when I must tell the world that it sucks more
than a hooker vacuum in a vortex.

I only rate a series when I really like/hate it.

Like Happy World! That thing made me RRRRRRAAAAAAAGGGGGGGGEEEEEEE

Or like Vagabond, which came out of left field for me. It would be in the "God Tier Level" of awesome, trust me.



This applies to me as well. I will NEVER understand why people rate it high just because of those two reasons.



Last edited by loosecannon504 at 1:36 am, Dec 22 2008

________________

I did 'Depends, I vote if I really like/hate the manga', because (not including this site), I only do it if I really like it, whereas if its this site I always vote.

________________

I rate every manga I complete. And usually mangas I am in the middle of reading. I don't have a in depth system of how I rate things. If I really like it a 9 or 10, if it's decent a 7-8, so-so 5-6, really bad 3-4. I don't give things 1-2, because I won't bother finishing them.

Let us row our boat with flaming oars in the engulfing sea of rage
and whip a thousand jellyfish to bits with barbwire!

I don't usually rate since I don't really care enough to. The ratings for series usually aren't very accurate so I never pay attention to them anyway.

What he said.

________________

Poll over, results posted

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants