Kimi ni Moete Ii Desu ka? - MangaUpdates

banner

User Comments [ Order by usefulness ]

Not shabby at all, Highly recommend the third oneshot at the end

by ishitagupta
11 years ago

Rating: 8.0 / 10.0

I agree with all my fellow shoujo-holics that it's typical shoujo fare to an extent, but it's really not in so many ways! The art is reason alone for its swoon-factor. This mangaka is extremely accomplished at drawing edgy yet smexed out bishies with oodles of hair-attitude to spare! Add to the art some heroines who know not to drool at some flashy bishies just because they're supposed to for plot's sake, and it makes for cute and funny storytelling. Smut is barely there... a sprinkling at best, it's interesting executed and definitely leaves an impression making for good re-readability.

Characters, both main and secondary are very well thought out and the direction of storytelling, in the main story especially in the second chapter takes a surprisingly mature turn. We all consider that aspect in adolescent love and have probably experienced it at some point, but it's rarely been broached in lighthearted shoujo romances.

... Last updated 11 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

cliche shoujo, but not so annoying as other shoujos

by torrentchan
14 years ago

Rating: 6.0 / 10.0

Unrealistic, melodramatic, no twists. A shoujo manga. One thing that I can say good thing about this manga is that though it may consist of all that shoujo manga drama this and that, it doesn't go as far to be annoying as much.

Not much of a plot or character development. Average art. Expected ending. Simple plot-line as: "Boy and girl passionately in love, doesnt see anyone besides themselves" kind of thing.

Giving it a 6/10. Why? Like I said, typical shoujo manga that doesnt hold plot, but doesnt go so far as annoying as many other shoujo manga. Good for a short light read.

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

Cute

by angeltheya_12
14 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

As i stated in my subject, the manga is cute... And it has more stories after the ending. The mangaka should have made it longer... But if u want to read some time killer , this is a good story for you (^_^)

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

average at best

by lostinshalott
14 years ago

Rating: 2.0 / 10.0

Its an average manga, full of clichés and glittery eyes pretty looking boys etc there is a lack of humour and its altogether pretty poor, the extras were better than the actual story especially the one about her "plain" friend which wasn't exactly ended and had me going whaaaat at the end. But the main story just lacks and I disliked it. Definitely one of Hina Sakuradas earlier works because even the art wasn't all that. This manga-ka has potential as I've already said but she doesn't steer clear of the same old plot holes and clichés that other bog standard manga-kas use. She needs to go back and read some real manga works and gain some ideas from that.

Was this comment useful? Yes

No