im a fan of Clannad, thats why i tried this one and i gotta say for 4 chapters it took me long to finish this! because it was so boring! and i felt nothing for the characters! i'll admit that i was a bit touched on the final parts but it was just so boring! i feel like it was trying too hard to be sad.. that it just became crappy! and everyone was so righteous and mary sue- ish that it irks me!!
and wtf is with Tomoyo? she is so out of character!
anyway whatever.. this is my opinion and the comments below me are the other peoples' opinion.. and im greatly outnumbered so.. i'll end it here.
btw. the art is cute.. so that will add one to my score, okay, since im'm feeling good today, 1 and a half..

yes i have read it, unlike all other romance comic i have ever read which is have a happily ever after ending (some even have the heroine dead and still in the end she out of no where come back to life (i know you all know it ^_^)) but this, this is the best ending i have ever read since i starting reading manga. with unexpected story, unexpected leap of story, and unexpected ending, the only bad part in this comic is there are no introduction in character, but since it is just a spin off, so what?

I read this without knowing this would have a tragic ending... now I feel all depressed and crappy... A tear flowed down my cheek... Well I give this a rating of 10 for the story, and a -1 for the ending... God, I somehow hate and love stories like this at the same time. Why.......?

... Last updated on July 27th, 2008, 1:41am

Although i dont really like tragedies, this one is still very good. I liked every part, i was really sad at the end, but it still carried some happiness after. plus this manga Tomoyo After, entertained me instead of bore me and im not implying the main story as boring but implying some other manga that are

One of the best I've read before, It went into so much depth, and the words being used were really touching and sad. Tomoyo and Tomoya went so well together. Even though this is a side story I think the pairing is better than the main story one. It has many twists of reality involved, and it made me cry >.< and I re-read it too.

This is a manga worth every minute spent reading it. Its short but the story is complete and made me quite emotional towards the final chapter. The art is good and the authors message is delivered through the story.

real good, made me have a warm yet horrible feeling after reading it though... i recommend this and dont to those who want the basic happy endings, i understand why a few people gave this a low rating because of the way it ended.

... Last updated on February 11th, 2008, 8:33pm

wow, that was pretty good, last chapter was shocking... but the story was good, the ending was also good for the type of ending they wanted to leave off, but its more of a symbolism ending then physical.. if u know wat i mean.


Side note:: this was good, but it is good that in the main story Tomoya chooses Nagisa...