The beginning was bleh--nothing special. Then you learn about the characters' pasts, and everything gets interesting.
The plotline is very interesting, and the ending gives you hope for love. Overall, a good read.

I really enjoyed this manga because some of it was rather twisted, which was a nice change. The ending was a let down for me since one of the main male leads rubbed me the wrong way the entire manga, but I wont just focus on that.

... Last updated on January 6th, 2009, 2:18pm

Anything that makes me feel like this deserves a 10, yet is such a sad feeling. Through out the story I found myself cheering on each of the guys, and I couldn't ever blame her for not choosing either of them, but when she finally did, it was so unexpected. The ending was unbelievable, and even though it was a happy one, I can't stop feeling so sad. The author made an amazing work; (spoiler) consider this Yann lived for a very long time and watched many girls he loved live and die, so every time one of them died he must have felt really lonely; through this story I really felt like losing someone I really cared about.
To sum up this is one of the best and original stories I’ve ever read and I highly recommend it.

... Last updated on September 14th, 2008, 8:28am

I dunno about this series... i thought in the beginning its would be one of those incredibly dumb girls goin for the most popular guy... but it kept pulling out twists that draw u in. The series made me so sad it was amazing and it feels so complete which many series lack.

I loved how it ended it was so heartwarming.

In the beginning volume, the story leads you to believe that it is a typical shoujo with some little element of mystery. Boy, were we wrong. This manga is far deeper than what it seems like. It does start off slow, but in the middle of volume 2, we learn more of the backstory ... And the ending... Good job mangaka. Melancholic but beautiful and perhaps hope for the future. This is a story that can not be missed out on, even if it is boring in the beginning.

wow. it really has twists and turns.. and well i admit, the manga title kinda gave me clues about the story..

it start off as a little bit confusing, and you just want to keep reading cos you really REALLY wanna know what the hell's going on.. haha

and i really dont know which of the two guys to root for either.. and gosh.. the ending.... sob sob.

I cried at the end....i anticipated the ending to be happy..and it was, but it somehow left me feeling really depressed.

Anyways, this is an amazing series, and i recomend it to all manwa/manga readers

... Last updated on May 28th, 2008, 6:51pm

the 'description' written above does this manga no justice. it doesn't even begin to describe how amazing this manga is.

i was constantly surprised by all the twists...it unraveled very smoothly. it was exactly how the mangaka described. at the end of the plot, it was suddenly like all the pieces of puzzle just came together.

the ending was short but satisfying...it wouldn't have hurt to have seen a few more pages but its good to know the curse was finally broken...that means he'll die normally like a human huh...

for a short 3 volume manga im amazed how thoroughly planned and developed it was. in other words, its definitely not ur typical cliche boring nonsense, where you could practically see the ending through the manga description.

This story is truly something, it makes you belive in fairytales and that karma truly does exist. I really loved the way the characters developed and how complex the relationships were....yes there is a bit of drama but it's worth it in this case. Really happy to have seen things turn out the way it did at the end, afterall love is the greatest thing!

I loved it! The story developed very well. I feel sorry for Mr.Lee but he did obtained her love and i agree with Chira00, it seems like their love will go on. It would be good the author extended the ending but the ending wasn't bad.