This manga is stupid as sin but it made me laugh several times unintentionally with its completely garbage pacing and totally nonsense interactions. I constantly felt like I was missing something because no manga could be this stupid and disjointed. But it is, and I'm so lucky to have read it.

Super disjointed and cliche. Action happens FAR too quickly, even for a oneshot.
I don't expect realism from manga, but this was just too ridiculous to overlook with no redeeming qualities. For example, the girl's mother dies and her main concern is her (nonexistent) relationship with her friend's older brother.
There was absolutely no attachment to the characters because they felt so flat and airheaded.
The only nice thing is the art, but even that I found to not be Rinko Ueda's best.

Oka, it has only been a one-shot, which often have nearly no substance since the are one-shots. But this one was plain unrealistic and childish.
The curse of action was super fast, for example the death of the mother. I didn't realized it at first.
If ths manga was only a bit realistic, it would admit that this love has no future at all. Which guy would react this calm and even happy when he finds out his love interest is an elementary kid...? Which guy would actually wait for 10 years for this elementary kid?
Which elementary kid sticks to its first love? Particular for many, man years in row.

No, no. This was bad.

I agree with morphin007's review. The romance was uninspired, the plot was dull and predictable. The only part I liked was the mother's adventures with the angel dude. They were kind of funny, I suppose. Also, the art was cute - as you'd expect from Rinko Ueda. Unfortunately, the rest of this one-shot is a disappointment after reading much of her other work.

... Last updated on July 20th, 2011, 7:40am

Hard to say if i liked it or not, but since i read it till the end i'll give at least an average note.
But i think the romance is really not good. I don't care about age gap, but ugh... so inconsistency, especially about the girl, she don't act like her age at all... plus i don't find that the mangaka put any weight in their love. It's like "oh i found a beauty that don't hate tram so i love her" and seriously i doubt she will really still love only him 10~15 years later. And seriously how can a normal guy react like that when he found that the girl he love is back to a 10 years old child in elementary school...