I found this manga really cliche and typical. The artwork is pretty nice but the storyline happens in so many mangas that it just ruins it. Basically, I didn't really like it, but if this was the first manga I read, it'd be pretty interesting, too bad it wasn't.

Some of this manga is really SICK. I don't think I've ever read a more bland shoujo manga than this. She falls in love in with him,,,,for what?!? Whatever. The only thing that I liked about this manga is some of the art, but then again, sometimes the art is lazy and it turns me off. x[[

This is horrible and an absolute waste of time. She falls in love with him way tooo fast, and even though they just met it seems that all they do is kiss,kiss,kiss ughh annoying. I just like the art but other than that this is below average.

This was on level...7 or so when it comes to cringe worthiness. I'd probably give it a solid 10 on that scale if I would have actually read what the characters were saying after chapter 1. Oh man, it was bad. The lines were so bad. I could tell what the characters were saying just from looking at their facial expression because I've seen this plot a bajillion times. To be honest, I couldn't make it past chapter 2. My attempt to read the one shot at the end of it was also a bust as I could tell the plot line from just the second page of it.

Well, when i feel bad or tired after long day study, that kind of romantic story make me feel very very relaxing. It's tender and so sweet. I think i like this story and i like the art too.
Erhm.. To draw a story is not easy at all. Of course, there are many shoujo manga have a better story But with a oneshot story, i think she did a good job. Thank KAORI

The art is pretty good, but there's no deep love progressing between the characters. And the girl looks "easy" -__-"
Don't read it if you don't want to waste your time

Honestly, after reading so many shoujo mangas with similar plot this story was nothing special. The naive and weak heroine falls for the bad boy type of guy how is her first love. I have to admitt I did not enjoy this. Why? The romance was way to quick for my liking, the girl fell in love with the guy on like the first chapter. The story only had three chapters so I didn't really expect much but I didn't expect it to be so quickly. I understand that 1 volume stories usually have to be pretty rushed but what bugged me about this story is that the mangaka tried to fit too much into a such a short story. Also, I did not like the characters, even for short story characters, they were bad.

This manga had super duper fast development (unlike the other manga that builds up)...The art was nice...it just had weird Smut (trying to say=> girl= too easy...But at least the girl was strong willed (more or less)

she falls in love with him kind of fast..but well that is generally what happens in most..if not all shoujo mangas.

Other than that...it was an average manga, nothing stood out to me particularily

... Last updated on March 21st, 2009, 5:41pm