OK WTF I WAS READING HAPILLY. AND THEN ALL THE SUDDEN THERE'S A NEW FREKIN MC!!! AND SHE WAS WEAK TOO. UGHHHHHH ARE YOU SERIOUS.
Anyways, don't read this unless you like when THEY SWITCH THE MC WHEN IT GETS GOOD!!! UGH.
Case closed.

This manga is a really good read. And it's amazing how it shows us how important a main character is.

Hehe wondering why I am saying that ?

Ahem. Let me explain : I really enjoyed this manga until volume 7... then the main character changed and it became a lame-ass shoujo like the thousands we've already read.

*sigh* I'm soooooo freaking frustrated !!... How can it become so stupid, cliche, cheesy, shallow, ridiculous, boring, predictable and annoying ??... WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT AUTHOR-SAN ?!?
Yui is your typical irritating shoujo female character. Being more annoying than her is impossible. Especially when Hana was the former mc.
She was everything in this serie, and she's the reason why I liked it so much. She was unusual and thus endearing and charismatic. Her personality made it really interesting ! Straight forward, honest, energetic, cool, independant, mature, devoted... If you're like me and you've already read a lot of shoujos involving male idols with the mc as the manager, then let me assure you that this one was different and refreshing, thanks to the fantastic mc.

Moreover, despite the fact that the band's boys were really stereotypical (the arrogant/stupid one, the cute one, the cheerful one, the sexy one and the cool/aloof one), they entertained me and even managed to surprise me ! I really appreciated their relationship (between them and with Hana), and enjoyed that each member got his own screentime.

Then volume 8 came...
I feel betrayed. As if everything has been ruined... Replacing Hana by Yui only made me love Hana more, and loathe Yui more... We can't even compare them as they're on such different levels.
Please, let's just get rid of this fraud.
Hana-chan was such a great main character !! I want her back !! Otherwise I'm dropping this.

Edit : Humpf. I don't care. For me, it ended at volume 7. That's why I rated 8.

... Last updated on March 24th, 2017, 2:28pm

HAve no idea the main character couple with whom? and How possibly be replaced at the end by other? Such Disturbing
P.S: *Warning* A Band Group perform singing, traditional dancing (with fan), modern breakdancing, playing violin, playing magic at once ? ? ? ? ?

... Last updated on March 2nd, 2016, 8:00pm

it's more than hate.. best word would be loath.. I totally love this manga but my interest died instantly when Hana is being replaced by Yui as the main character!! I miss Hana! the character that you have loved for so many chapters is not easy to replace you know! I stopped reading the manga just now.
P.S. rating should be 10 if Hana is still the main character...

I REALLY love this manga .
It's funny, I love the main lead(she's hilarious), and I love her special ability xD!!!

ITS JUST GOOD.
The guys are all nice, and sure, it's a harem, but it isn't one of those stretched-out-almost-like-a-game harem. It's just the fact she hangs out with the guys a lot, and that they're her friends. c: A NORMAL HAREM FOR ONCE (though I do like some stories with those extreme harems xD)
SO TO THE POINT
*Good art (I like the style It's cute(hehebishies)
*GREAT PLOT (I love idol mangas, and this one is unique! AND its actually funny xD )
*FANTASTIC CHARACTERS!!!!!! (I LOVE HANA! She's such a great person! Her personality is fun, and she's strong! Of course she has faults, but so does everyone! It makes her that much real ^^! AND OMG THE BAND. ALL OF THE GUYS ARE AWESOME. Each has their own personality, and unlike most mangas, this one doesn't center around one of them. It doesn't even center around Hana! In Crash!, each person is an equal, and I'm amazed th e manga-ka has balanced out the characters so well! GAH ITS JUST SOOO GOOD)

I just re-read the manga scans available sense a new chapter came out, AND IT RESPARKED MY LOVE FOR THIS MANGA!

CHOCOLATE FUDGE SCANS, keep on SCANLATING!!

So I think you should read it. C: ALL shoujo fans will love this!!!

(THEY NEED TO UPDATE SOON > DID THEY ABANDON THIS OR SOMETHING!? )
SO READ~!

HOLY SH*T. THEY UPDATED>

*MAJOR HAPPY DANCE WHILE CRYING TEARS OF JOY*
\( ; u ; )/

... Last updated on August 31st, 2012, 11:54am

Pretty average for a manhua... but if it's a manga so I dunno. That pattern is the exact same as 90% of showbiz manhuas out there. Random unexplained unrelated power (not exactly supernatural though), a bit airheaded girl with sometimes a bit of trauma or some trouble in the past but either overcame it or overcomes it with her harem of hot guys, all different personalities. Honestly... it's boring. It's the kind of boring that is acceptable, if I'm making sense.

Personalities are way too stereotypical, made by book kinda ones. Nothing much more to say, I'm sure you all have read those once or twice.

Well, it's average. Strictly average. And story + art I just somehow end up treating it as a manhua but it's a manga ><;; Something's wrong there and I dunno what. I lost interest within 5 chapters... well there's the scan quality and raws used (Simplified Chinese, and of course it's pissing me off), but the story itself wasn't anything special. The art is the same as you'll see in many shoujo mangas and manhuas, especially manhuas, not too shabby but nothing to catch your attention. For all I care that girl has only one face: a stupid large smile on her face.

If your bored, lying around, in a good mood perhaps somewhat sleepy, you might be able to read it till the end and even like it. As for me, I'm a bit numbed by the unexpected good ones found in a loonng~ time, this one will probably simply piss me off more and more atm. I'll come back when I got nothing better to do and get back into the reality that masterpieces are stuff that are waited for and not sought for.

... Last updated on June 19th, 2012, 11:52am

same Olivezx
I love Hana's charecter very much.
I like Rei*Hana too and I won't read Crash since Volume 8 up !!

same Olivezx everything ..

I don't like Yui !
because I love Hana's character
and I like when Rei love Hana
I won't read Crash since Volume 8 up because I hate Yui
When Hana come back , I'll think to come back or not
Many friends and fan of this manga that I know have stopped read like me

it's not the best. i skimmed most of it because it didn't really grab my attention much.

the art is nice though

but yeah, i kind of got bored mid-way.

A wonderful plot and the drawing is easy on the eyes as well! =) One of the few shoujo mangas that doesn't have the female lead blushing every few panels.

I've read the raws all the way to the end, I really really wished that the mangaka made this series a little longer! >.< The ending just kinda... left me hanging, and wanting for more... I'm hoping that the sequal gets scanlated soon...