This was actually a touching and sweet story. I just wish Shinjo made it much longer so the development was much better. The female lead isn't weak and the love interest is as far from her previous smut "heroes" as you can get.I really enjoyed this one and recommend it. Shinjo's non smuts never disappoint.

At many parts of this manga, you can just figure what is coming, the way it leads is very predictable. The only good point, is that you want to know about her past (you can jump to the final to know it, without loosing anything). Thanks that it is very short, or I'd just jump to the last chapter/volume.

This is actually a decent manga. I'm surprised by it because Shinjo's works usually have no plot, have horrible male leads, and weak female characters. This was a sweet story and I really enjoyed it.

... Last updated on August 24th, 2012, 8:57pm

to be honest i like shinjo mayu's art and how she draws her bishies so i read this.. because i dont like her typical stuff wherein the weak girl get raped by the awesome, godlike boy.
so anyway.. it made me laugh on some parts that seem a bit over the top.. it kindda reminded me of some old drama, wherein the girl collapses and the guy holds her and then she whispers to him and then faints again and then the boy screams to the top of the heanvens and something like that.. and why do they all have dark pasts? why cant they make it jolly for once? well i like happy boys.. well aside from all that mellow drama its pretty readable mainly because of all the eye candy and me trying to clear my wish and reading list.. and the heroine is tolerable so.. yup.. stil worth a read!!
>edit<
what a bunch of crap. it was insert incest here as a twist of somekind but hell it is so predictable and the love rivals just disappear and appear out of nowhere and the story felt like its written by an eight year old who didnt knew better its just so.. ugh.. so full of cheese. i wanna puke and it felt so boring and i didnt felt anything for the characters they are so 2 dimensional, sterotypical.. i mean i was like, "uhuh, so she remembered, so they got together in the end, uhuh, the end? gonna comment on how bad this is", and here we are, there are so many good mangas out there dont waste time on this one except if your only in it for the bishies, which i am in the beginning but i realized how odd looking and disproportioned they were.

... Last updated on June 13th, 2012, 7:05am

Moved to the bottom of the list.





And @ guy below me:

Uhh, all mangaka's artwork remains similar in their series, plus, her female characters are kawaii . . . Guess someone doesn't know Shinjou Mayu's ecchi-shounen equivalent, romance author, Kawashita Mizuki, creator of Ichigo 100%, Hatsukoi Limited., Lilim Kiss, Ane-Doki, and many more series.

... Last updated on December 12th, 2011, 4:54am

Why does everyone like her art? The characters are almost always drawn horribly. All her manga's have this same art! The only thing keeping me reading this is the main girls mysterious past. The fact that the guys were idols is also quite pointless and only stands to complicate things (jealous fan girls, anyone?).
I can barely count on fingers manga that I've read from her and liked. I'll try with this one though.

Guy above me;
Point noted. Fact remains that I don't feel the same way.

... Last updated on July 22nd, 2012, 12:30am

Didn't like this series a lot. The girl is not weak as some of Mayu Shinjo's other heroines, but not strong either. Cliche plot and I didn't like her art this time. I think the heroine is ugly ==. So his the guy - looks the same as all the other heros in Shinjo Mayu's work.
Don't recommend reading this unless you're a fan.

... Last updated on February 13th, 2011, 3:12am

yeh i did not like this because its the same old story where the girl falls in love with the guy that she shouldnt fall in love with. he says stay away from me and still they end up together in the end. and the heroine ignores the guy that likes and treasures her and in the end he gets hurt!!! nothing new. and they said that she lost her memories of the last three years then why doesnt she remember her own name, parents, house, family, friends, school, & etc. the plot doesnt add up!!!!!!!! its so frustrating i just stopped reading it after the first 3 chapters!!! i give it a 1/10 i know harsh ratings. im sorry fans.

I was surprised in a good way that Shinjo Mayu actually had a work that's not smut. the art is fine as always, but all the characters look the same as her previous works just with different hair. the story isn't particularly engrossing and the heroine is pretty much like all of Shinjo's other heroines. all in all, standard shoujo.

I think it's very refreshing to see Mayu Shinjo focusing on plot and character development, not smut. Her drawings are beautiful and top notch.