If you are into shoujo full of cliches, then this work is perfectly paced and balanced. Don't expect anything complicated as Full Moon or Shinshi Doumei Cross though, like I said, it's really cliche'd.

I don't know...I think its hard to judge her series because the first two mangas I read from her was full moon and gentalmen's alliance...which I think were both absolutely amazing and for me her other series just kind of dull in comparison. Her art is always amazing though ^^ always taking my breath away hehehe
(though I agree with most comments from her other series that her characters look a little alike and her plots seem to be very similar)

I seem to be one of the only people who actually liked this. XD Oops!

I'm a sucker for Arina Tanemura's artwork. It's always phenomenal. But that's something everyone is agreeing on here - the artwork is good, as always.

It's the plot and the characters where opinions seem to differ. I didn't think the characters were really particularly unique or exciting, but I didn't think they were bad, either. For lack of a better way to put it: They got the job done. As for the plot... Again, not the best plot ever, but I don't think it's as bad as some reviewers say. It's a bit cheesy, a bit cliche... but I saw it more as an homage to the whole "Magical Girl" genre than an uninspired pastiche of overtread material. And maybe that's where the difference in opinion lies.

At any rate, if you're a fan of Arina Tanemura's... Well, you're probably going to give this a shot no matter what anyone says But I think it's worth a try for anyone who likes cute, fluffy shoujo or the Magical Girl genre

Bad, this manga is really bad and the worse of Tanemura-sensei ---___---. Of course she has nice arts like everytime and you really can count on that aspect in each of her mangas, but this one was a pure disappointment, story and plots were...bad; I can't express it more clearly. I think, Fullmoon was her best one.

Uh, yes, all her stories are wonderfully drawn...but you can't enjoy the drawing without a good plot. this is one of the stories that wasn't particularly good. -___-
i mean, she's REALLY good at drawing, but i think all of her stories are essentially the same in the end, not to mention, a lot of her characters look like ppl from her previous mangas

I like full moon better then her last manga
and this manga is just too cheery...
I hope her future manga are good....

I totally concur with ps92 and Twilight_Moon; this is absolutely the most disappointing Tanemura Arina manga she's ever drawn.

While the art is top notch, the story, or better the lack therof, is totally predictable, clichee and cheezy.
The only plus that it's really short with 3 chapters...^^

Not recommened, unless you're an Arina addict.

This.. this manga practically made me lose all my respect for Arina-sama -_-

The art was absolutely wonderful! That much you can count on. But the characters, story, everything else sucked.

Yes, I love the artwork, and yes the story is adorable. But it's such a cheesy shoujo stuffed with so many cliches in just 3 chapters... I disliked it.

This is my first comment, so bear with me.

So, I really enjoyed this series! As excepted from Arina-sensei, It delivers a very cute romantic story, good characters (love it when Kisaki and Giniro are together), and a lot more. One gripe about it is that is way too short and the ending is indeed cute but it's lacking something. but nonetheless, a great story.

So if your a fan of Arina-sensei's works, give this one a try! ^__^

... Last updated on August 31st, 2008, 2:09am