You have mysticism, bestiality, lots of sex scenes, a half-baked plot that drags on and as the cherry on top:
It's a mind numbing series that I would only recommend to someone really bored, willing to appreciate the story as an example of unintentional absurd comedy.

This manga was such a drag, I forced myself to read a couple more chapters after I got bored. I do not like the female character... she can't do sh*t, and that one time where they almost did it while he was in dog form... ugh beastiality much?

... Last updated on March 16th, 2016, 11:48pm

The only reason I finished reading this manga was because I read the other ones. In truth it was a pain to have to yet and finish it.. It was filled with 40 chapters of stupid stories surrounding a odd couple that have sex a lot . The only part I liked was the ending two chapters honestly. Artistry was okay for that time.

So sweet. Took me five days to read, with me being busy and all. But I loved it. Reminds me of another romance where the girl had to leave her immortal lover. Oh yeah Hana To Akuma... So sad!!! Gah!!! Those always make me tear up! But you know what they should have done, with all the mystical creatures and all, they should've searched for a vampire to turn her immortal so they can stay together haha.
But on a serious note this was a great read. Idk what others be thinking but Yato is hot! Well he gets hotter. And the storyline gets better too throughout the manga. The only thing that I didn't like was the sudden ending. It didn't feel like a real ending. I think they should've drawn more or show a glimpse of how she grew old and then end. But the next thing I knew the next page was her grave scene. O.o I did tear up though. I tend to get emotionally attach to mangas now lol. Welps, I loved it 9/10. Ok now that I'm done reading this my life is bland.

okay readin all prequals to the very end and squeals i came to love this manga. it was entertaining. you dont get bored and i just kept reading and readin . it pulls u in . awesome art work.. i like the ending it was reasuring that they were always going to be together im glad it wasnt one of thes ama cry ending.. i really wish they have another one ... so yea go read it.no regetion

There seems to be a missing chapter. See chapter 29 page 4 table of contents. The extra chapter "Let's Go on a Forbidden Trip" appears to either be missing or unscanlated. If it is unscanlated then the manga cannot be considered completely scanlated.

SO it's much different than Midnight Secretary (which I absolutely love) but I like it. The story and the characters felt light and airy. And I loved how they loved so passionately. Made me very jealous lol At first I wasn't so keen on the art.. but I grew to like it. After all it's from the mangaka of Midnight Secretary. That's all I needed lol

I loved how in the beginning Yato seemed so fierce! but by the end his expressions were so soft and lovely.. Hisako was something of a ditz, but I don't think that she was stupid. The ending for me was bitter sweet. And I did get a little misty eyed. I must admit, but I held it in lol I wish they could have found some other way to be together.. that would've been happier.

But the story was quite lovely. I did enjoy it :-)

... Last updated on March 30th, 2012, 5:45pm

It's not horrid. There are worse mangas out there. At most points it's an average, mediocre read but at other points it's awkward when it borderlines beastiality.

I don't know about some of you, but:

But hey, if you don't have a problem with potential zoophilia, give it a try! In that sense it stands out from the crowd.

The ending was it's downfall. I seriously didn't enjoy the whole replica thing. Kinda killed off all the feelings I had for the chars... I dunno, it's not to the point where I'm disgusted, but on it's way...

Honestly... this isn't the type of manga I'd recommend. I'm not a sucker for those cliche dramas, or corny lines and stuff... I don't usually read smut either, they tend to make the plot shallower and focus on sex, and in general, too clingy to their lovers for my taste = =. Well... I dunno, there just was somewhere I didn't quite like about this. Never to the point where I'm annoyed or hating it though.

I never quite got to the point where I loved the story, but for a smut this was unexpectedly good. I'm sure I would've given it at least an 8 if it weren't for the ending... It's not the ending ending that's bad, it's the story they chose = =. ARG! I already mentioned this, but pretty much ruined my impressions on the characters.
I also do realize this is a sequel, but I would have loved if they at least explained a lil more about the relationships... I never quite understood how the characters relate. Which in turn, makes the romance and other stuff more shallow and sex-drived.

The art is amazing. Although wolves are one of those better drawn manga animals, it's still pretty darn amazing. In general, manga animals usually aren't drawn quite as well, this is especially with horses I find. I find it incredible how detailed and real the wolves actually looks. Although I don't draw canines much, at first glance the anatomy doesn't seem to too far off. The poses are natural and much varied, instead your usual just standing and walking.
Well... other than that, the humans... especially the females, they look way too masculine... I won't go as far as saying they suck, but like I said, they do look weird at times. Other times though, the guys are hot and the girls are passable.

All in all, it's not a bad manga, but I probably won't recommend it to anyone else. I didn't have too high expectations for this one, and I fully got what I paid my time for back. Worth the read.

Seriously this is the worst introduction I have ever seen in a manga , I thought this would be great because of the reviews but Omg I'm 23pages in and I'm seriously finding it hard to read that yet alone go on , the manga isn't looking promising the art sucks and for me its a no no.