The jokes are funny not lame, the story is a bit........... Unstable... It does not have any specific plot, the characters have no goals which makes it really funny xD so this manga is for no smart pals, its more for pass time and for those whose looking for fun new breeze NOT stressful manga xD
9.5/10 (^_^)

This series is hilarious. The main character is so funny and laid back. She's not the typical damsal in distress, overly emotional, wishy-washy, boy-crazed, girly girl character that usually appears in most shoujo mangas. Rather, the main character is more like a guy that could care less about being surrounded by a group of hot guys. There is just enough romance in this series, but not too much that it gets overly dramatic and tiring. The focus is probably more comedy with a touch of romance. It's a very good series!

This manga didn't amuse me. I found the humor to be slapstick, not subtle or witty in the slightest. I don't see the purpose behind having so many main characters; most of them don't serve much of a purpose, other than to hang around and look pretty.

Anyway, that would all be perfectly acceptable, if that's what you prefer in a manga; however, I couldn't get over the fact that there seemed to be no overlying plot, no arc, nothing. It was just a chapter-by-chapter storyline, almost like one of those crime/police TV shows (that is to say, if you miss a week's episode, you're not losing out on anything).

Simply put, I didn't really like it all. The humor didn't appeal to me, and the fact that THERE IS NO PLOT was a little... irritating. I didn't care about it's similarity to Ouran (which I don't really like, either), as I'm pretty sure this was published a year earlier.

Maybe I'm missing something?

... Last updated on December 17th, 2010, 7:22pm

this manga is funny great read but really there is nothing to do with hockey... all they do is make up excuses to travel around. Rich kids have nothing better to do then to travel around and waste money.

Zomgg
never in my life have i laughed so much and for so long.
Seriously, every page of this manga i'm like BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA and my lil brada next door will start shouting for me to shut up while i keep on laughing and i end up unconsciously having a screaming match with him

I LOVE THIS MANGA!
its seriously sooo hilarious and there wasn't much romance but that there is a slow progress.
i think everyone who want a good laugh in a shoujo should read this. promise.

this is one of the best mangas out there.
why is it not famous? so underrated.

for those who compare it with ouran, heads up guys, GOKU STARTED FIRST accd to wiki.
GOKU: year 2002
ouran: year 2003
so who copied who? well, it doesn't really matter.
let's just enjoy both series. ^^,

somebody mentioned about the lack of romantic chemistry.
i do get your point since this manga focused more on the comedy rather than the romance.
so their chemistry may not be really visible for some people.
i know, their nonstop bickering and elementary school antics are not the most romantic thing.
and being unaware of their feelings towards each other doesn't help either.
but for me though, i find the two main casts suited for each other.
they have this weird connection.
they just need a little more push from others to realize their feelings.
good thing the romance gets better in the later volumes. XD

the humor in this manga is amazing.
i can't help but laugh.
the plot is so random and nonsensical that it boosts the comedy factor in this manga.
another funny thing to note is that no matter how irrational some plot is, the other characters are still aware of reality.
for example in one chapter, a bear became their goalie. the readers are convinced by the main cast that it is already an accepted circumstance in the manga.
but when the ending came, reality strikes.
a bear can never be a hockey player. LOL.

i've already read up to volume 9.
but i just really want to ask,
will they ever get to play a decent hockey game and win their first victory? XD

This is probably my 2nd favorite (shoujo) manga right now! I absolutely love all the awkward/sweet moments between Izumi and Hana. Not only is this manga awkward/sweet it's also hilarious! I laughed so hard on some parts! By the way I think everyone needs to stop comparing it to Ouran... yes they ARE similar... but we've all established that. And well My Heavenly Hockey Club actually came first... So maybe Ouran should be the one with all the comparisons. Anyway this is great manga, a total MUST read!

Ai Morinaga is my favorite shojo mangaka, and this manga is really good. I like the obscene amounts of food, the comedy can be pretty funny and the core cast is pretty likeable. The only problem is...the two leads have NO romantic chemistry at all. None! Nada! Zilch! They're more like siblings, or friends who don't like each other all that much. It makes the romantic scenes really awkward and unconvincing, but Morinaga improves matters by keeping such scenes few and far between. Hope she keeps the status quo as it is or this manga could go down the drain in a hurry.

This manga is so funny. I wonder why it isn't as, if not more, popular than Ouran. Though this manga is similar to Ouran, I like this manga more. I find it funnier, in a nutty kind of way, but I also like how the characters are actually developed. I like the strong personality of the female lead, and I think that everyone's distinct personality ties the story.

And this manga is sooo funny I couldn't stop laughing!! I highly recommend this.

I love this manga. the story is similar to OHSHC but it has a different... i dunno, FEEL i guess. But it's so hilarious and i think it's much simpler than ouran host club, even though it's just as good. FUNNINESS!