I don't usually give tens, but this one had mine.
Romance stuff doesn't usually touch me, but
this one sort of did. If anyone had seen my face
when I read this, I think they would've cried either
of sympathy or fear.
I read all 5 volumes in a line and it was 1 AM
when I stopped. Now I must go and try to survive
today's classes. Also, I rarely get to read stuff like
this. I didn't waste my time. I am sure that I will
remember this one.

Incest is a topic that I find hard to stomach, even during the course of the series I find myself squirm with discomfort due to the subject matter.
But the story itself is an excellent portrayal of an incestuous relationship. The mangaka did an amazing job addressing and exploring issues that arise from the forbidden relationship that is incest. The problems that the couple face as brother and sister in romantic love with each other are dealt in a realistic and somewhat bittersweet manner. I've read other mangas that try to portray an incestuous relationship, but Koi Kaze by far does the best job in dealing with the sensitive issue.
Another aspect that deserves praise in this manga is the main characters' relationship development. As well as their development as characters. Some might think it is slow, but I personally think that the development is just at the right pace. And by the end of the series you look back and realise that Koshiro and Nanoka have both grown and matured a lot. All in all, this is a great manga in dealing with a sensitive subject matter.

even though this may not suit everyone's taste (incest themed), i thought this was one of my most favorite mangas. I agree with a lot of people that i don't support incest in real life, but i picture most incest themed mangas as if your crush/love is unfortunetely your relative -_-'. Great story, great characters, awesome read . I'd recommend it.

A twenty eight year old guy falls in love with his teenage sister ? Sorry but that`s gross and simply not right. This manga implies it`s right to have sex with your 12 years younger sister, the first manga I wanted to vomit when I finished it

This was definitely an odd one. Even though it's incest, it didn't seem bad like I thought it would. Odd is definitely the word I would use.

Good read though.

ooookay..... this one creeped me out a lot because first of all she's way too young! plus she doesnt look good together with that guy,.. i really wish that they made him look better, he looks like a dad.. this is just my opinion of course

... Last updated on August 4th, 2007, 2:21pm

I found Koi Kaze very weird.
It was hard for me to read sometimes just because of how weird it was having a man in his late twenties having a relationship with a teenaged girl, who was also his sister, it just creeped me out.
Other then the weirdness of the manga I found it very interesting and a nice read, it dealed with everything in a serious way which made the manga readable for me. The romance and drama were great and kept me reading.
If you want to read a good romance manga and don't mind a lot of incest then I strongly suggest Koi Kaze (I would have given it a higher score but the whole incest thing really creeps me out).

... Last updated on January 7th, 2008, 7:04pm

I read 20 something pages and realized this was going to be bad and stopped.
I have read plenty of incest manga, and one with a very similar premise.
Why did I stop reading? Because the logic was fail.
Are you telling me a highschool girl will fall in love with a big fat old loser with one glance?! REALLY!? He looks like some creepy pedophile!
AND THEN, to make everything better she asks him on a date and he is with a female friend/co worker and she encourages this older man living at home with his father to date a high school girl. Will NO ONE be the voice of reason in this?

After that I couldn't read it anymore because I realized the author was just lol'ing while he made this.

MAYBE there is some deeper meaning somewhere down the road, but I'm not going to put up with stupidity in the first chapter.

Poor introverted bastard. The god of that world had a hateful sense of humor indeed. The devil tempted him and he resisted but he just couldn't resist no more. Now he'll be livin' life with the Japanese equivalent of a banjo and little brown jug. All joking aside, the story is actually touching considering the ephebophilia and incest.

I feel like this is a manga for pedophiles (i'm not saying anyone who read this is). The guy looks like he's in his 30s and the girl is barely a teenager and she's his sister. You can't tell me a pedophile won't be turned on by this.

I want to read this because of the good comments yet too repulsed at the same time