This manga was super cute and made me happy to read. I agree with the other comments that said the ending wasn't satisfactory, and the manga as a whole wasn't flawless, but I'm glad I read it.

Couldve been so much more! The ending honestly did it no justice.. and it 100% seems like the author had to rush through the last few chapters just to finish it. So many things left unexplained Dx! But it was a good read in the least i'd have to say. Buuut ,if your look for a lot of romancey manga, this isnt for you. There's only a little dab of it here & there.

... Last updated on March 17th, 2011, 11:22am

It's an amazing manga but the only thing that kills you is but otherwise amazing read.

I expected much of this and was really disappointed with the end.
'Sides that, the manga isn't so bad at all, it has its ups and down, of course.
But if you're looking for great romance developing you've got the wrong manga indeed.
I'm as disappointed as in ''Penguin Brothers''...Silly penguins.

... Last updated on December 19th, 2010, 12:56pm

I agree, it's not very realistic, but I gave it a 10 anyways.

The ending was indeed rushed (so typical of this mangaka(?)) , but I thought the overall story was really good. It was an interesting plot with few, but very likable, characters.
The main reason why I like the story so much is because it gives me a warm fuzzy feeling. It's a very fluffy story. It's not too heavy, not tragic, not deep - just very light, simple and cute. Not too many characters which is good.

Before you read this, you should know... there is NO resolution to any of the potential relationships. The ending was sudden and half-baked; all of a sudden it's "10 years later" (where they all look exactly the same) and there's no real conclusion. Other than the ending it was good--not amazing, but very solid. The plot can be ridiculous (but still believable), the art is nice, and the characters are definitely likable. It's fluffy and sparkly and cute, but a light, airy shoujo was just what I wanted.

I'm kind of frustrated because the entire thing was absolutely adorable, but the mangaka really ruined it by just cutting the series off like that... if she just had 1 more volume to tie up the loose ends it would've been a lot better.

... Last updated on August 27th, 2010, 12:55am

okay so this manga might not seem much for its cover and in the first chapter but as you read along you will get the idea. This manga is very interesting in the beginnning but if you wish for romance, it's not much. I mean like you would know who likes who eventually but its not really mainly that... There's like new stories that pop up and then some are no not ended and the main idea kinda changes.

The story was not entirely solid but if you just go with the flow and dunt be so demanding it can become addicting. I'm completely obssesed with Aya because he is so cool and HOT! Just enjoy it.

It gets confusing but noone such just criticize about there are good points, geez noone understand how rough it is for a manga author and artist for me i think this manga was a cute showbiz kinda manga totally loved it
Also the ending is something...

throughout this series, i kept alternating between laughing, smiling ang going 'awwhh'! it was simply MAGNIFICENT!! man the characters were so cool. and Yukari is my favorite female lead so far, next to Kiri Koshiba from Beauty Pop.
The character growth was really amazing in this series. each of the characters' past just simply added to the awsomeness of this manga. I LOVED IT!
ahh man i wish it was longer! and that the ending was a little more...shoujo-shiny romantic and that . Penguin Revolution is a great, but kinda short, read for all manga-lovers! ^___^

I really enjoyed this series. It's actually one of my favorites. The art is beautiful, in my opinion, and Yukari is cute, strong and smart. And, although there wasn't too much outright romance in it (a fact I really regret, since I would really want to see a relationship!), it did have it, and the story was really enjoyable to read. I liked all the characters, too. The crossdressing didn't seem to fit in perfectly, but it certainly made it more interesting. The ending was a bit abrupt, and you don't really get to see the developments in character that you would normally want, but I still loved the series. It's not as if the mangaka like, randomly killed off a bunch of characters, so it's not as if it was a bad ending. I really just wish for more, though!
So, in conclusion, I really, really, really liked this series. I had to think a bit for the negative, but if it was just the level of my enjoyment while reading the series, I would've given it a 10!

I love this manga so much and it's one of my favourites...
I even wanted it to have more chapters BUT the ending was rushed (i think)
BUT again for me it has a great story plot, bishie (especially the guy with black hair) , and it's worth a read. I think i'll rate it 9.5/10 (^_^)