Going for the karma explanation just killed it for me. Done.
He did manage to somehow wrap it up.
As usual I don't find the ending good enough.

The characters.... are realistic (in other words, n00b), I guess. It just seems like they change and act one way at a certain point so it all fits in with the storyline. I kept on thinking "Why did you go do that back then ?? Are you stupid?" and/or"Why didn't you do that back then ?? It was so obvious you newb---!" ( I don't like to swear).
This did make it realistic, in a lame way, just like a real human would do. Whenever this happens, it feels like the author is controlling the characters and the story, not the characters themselves writing the story. But he did in such a way that he almost had it.

Of course this is just my personal opinion. It was good in general, it's just not something I would like to read again.

... Last updated on January 4th, 2012, 5:49pm

Tbh I was holding only a slight interest in the plotline for most of it, but as it was pulled together I was speechless about how good it was... the lines between good and evil blur, plot is well explained, and could even be written off as a hallucination for those who prefer it that way..... the character growth was amazing, the small twists that completely deny expectation are amazing, and the ending was astounding.... one of my all time favorites, but one I will rarely reread... several points of the story make it feel like my heart is ripping apart ;-;.

This was prettttty damn good. That ending was supers, especially that ending, who would known?!?! Definitely recommend this to anyone who likes: character growth, sweetish romance, amazing twists in story, war, bloodshed, awesomeness in general

This was a very nice Manhwa with an unexpected turn. Unfortunately It took a while to develop and get the whole story going, which is why I had to deduct two points. The art was really nice, too. I definitely recommend reading it, because of the very interesting and different ending. Didn't see that one coming; in a good way though.

... Last updated on June 4th, 2013, 7:33am

Reading this one right now at v6 .Just finished 20th century boys and Bokko so this one pales in comparison but is still alright . It seems a bit over the top at times but the art is nice . The comedy is misplaced and seems awkward mostly but is more than made up by some amazing action sequences . If you want to read something good but not great this is for you .

... Last updated on October 27th, 2011, 7:20pm

Paced neither too fast nor too slow. Read the whole thing in one go
and of course, the ending was worth it. It's well worth reading the whole thing JUST for the ending.
The mangaka knew exactly what he/she was doing.
I'd reccommend this series

... Last updated on December 21st, 2011, 3:50pm

I may hate tragic story but i really loved this one. It a really good read~! It was able to touch my heart and get my mind thinking about what my past life was about. It was worth my time reading something like this and i WILL find something similar. This made me wanna give tragic stories a shot.!! ;D

Great Manhwa. The main character is someone to enjoy reading about. He is at first a confused boy, then tragic boy, then a devil warhero, and lastly a funny and appreciative guy. The romance plays quite a bit in this story, but even if there is no romantic scenes, this still makes for a must read for people who like romance and action. Story gets a little confusing at times (many names), but it will leave you very satisfied, oh, there is a little tragedy, but nothing big.

OMFG I don't think I ever read a manga quite like this one. All I can say is holy mother of god... It was so unexpected.
I loved the drawings. kind of reminded me of berserk. It's a MUST READ.. coming from a girl who prefers romance, shoujo, lovey dovey manga LOL
Although the ending was so abrupt.. obviously the black haired girl near the end was the sister that brought him back in time.. and it was so ironic how he was like.. I'm sure I'll never see her again.. when it was her reincarnation that gave him a love letter haha. And the last page was really..heartwarming. The two love birds found their way back to each other.

... Last updated on February 16th, 2010, 7:51pm

One of the best manwha of all time; this manga has a mix of romance and self-conscious. This manga deserves a 10 for the ending; it came to such a surprise that we all know who Moon Bim really is in the end. That...somewhere deep inside of Sali Tayi wasn't just a man full of hate for his parents who had once forgotten about him but he was also full of love yet he feel he couldn't express.

The artwork is beautifully drawn; I'm not such a big fan of manga that has do to with any kind of wars (such as Suikoden III or Gundam Wing) but the war in this story was easy to follow. I can imagine the pain, the suffering, Sa-kyung goes through as he fights for the man who murdered his family. Better yet, I'd be shocked to death if I knew who I was in my past life...

This story had a really good ending, yet shocking. It left me wanting more yet, somehow, I'm satisfied with the ending... That even though Sali Tayi is long dead, somewhere, through Moon Bin, he still loves and long for Atan Hadas.