Scientia

in a world where science is corrupted by financial interests it's a nice reminder of how pure advancements can be to actually help society. those bittersweet tears.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Filled with great stories

by kiriee
9 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

I'm not a fan reading collection of stories or oneshot the reason is simple, how can they bring out the good in such short amount of page, but I guess I have to change my believe. Scientia is collection of short story, this is not a story where human abuse technology to do bad thing, Scientia is a story of human that take advantage of science to make live better. I personally really love chapter 2 and 4, but rest is also good it just leave more impression when I read that chapter.

Definitely must read.

... Last updated 9 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

hopeful

by whitespade
11 years ago

Rating: 9.2 / 10.0

from the summary and the tags, i thought it will be about hopeless, bleak, world as usual with futuristic setting, but it is actually full of hope, im pleasantly surprised. i do love the dark stories but it is great too to have futuristic manga that are optimistic. this is a good read. some people might not like it because there is not much drama or conflict, but i think it is commendable for this manga to restrain itself from going the usual 'science is EVIL' route and paint a better light of the future.

the art is pretty rough and the girls look like guys, but the unpolishedness is quite endearing in a way. try it!

... Last updated 11 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

Missed potential.

by MondSemmel
11 years ago

Rating: 6.0 / 10.0

Scientia is a collection of short stories about a successful utopia.
Sadly, the story wastes most of its potential by showing basically no moral conflict whatsoever, and by not taking its premises to their logical conclusions. [Tiny spoilers follow.]

For instance, one chapter is about affordable, rentable robots who learn from humans and become more human-like, yet none of the interesting questions are even touched upon (e.g. revolutionizing society; robots competing with/potentially totally replacing manual labor; robot rights, ...).

Also, c7 repeats the utterly discredited urban legend that we only use a small portion of our brains. Seriously: if our ancestors hadn't needed to use their brains, evolution would have made their brains smaller.
Oh, and most damning of all,

c7 has protagonists use an intelligence-enhancing device to, OF ALL THINGS, make MUSIC. Not saving the world, not making money, no, they make music. WHAT THE HELL?

'Scientia' is the story's 'goddess of science', and this image is a great metaphor for the story itself: it praises science for making life convenient, but doesn't engage in any scientific virtues, like investigating the consequences of its premises, thinking deeply about problems, and so on.
Disappointing.

... Last updated 11 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

Dark side

by xhenriholimar
11 years ago

Rating: 10.0 / 10.0

I really liked this manga, but at the same time that I was touched by the good of science and by the mensage, You have to work hard, i couldn't see the dark side o thechnology. I wonder if that is weird?

... Last updated 11 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes