banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Smut authors

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ]  
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #340052 - Reply to (#340031) by StarlightDreams
user avatar
Member

9:44 am, Dec 6 2009
Posts: 332


Quote from StarlightDreams
Shinjo Mayu and Minami Kanan are possibly the two worst smut mangaka ever.
They have no creativity whatsoever. Who actually LIKES being raped in every chapter? >.>


Their art is pretty messy too. My eyes look like @_@ when looking at their pictures. I don't really see the appeal of their works.

user avatar
Member

10:41 am, Dec 6 2009
Posts: 36


I don't know if she qualifies, but I quite like Enjouji Maki shes kind of along the same lines as Yoshihara Yuki with the comedy and such.

Also, I tried to read some of Shinjo Mayu's work, and I got fed up with the main character getting raped and liking it in every chapter. Even the plots of her mangas are awful, somewhere around the level of Twilight-awful in my opinion.

user avatar
Member

11:47 am, Dec 6 2009
Posts: 54


I definitively love and recommend YOSHIHARA Yuki : 9 times out of 10 I can be sure she delivers both on the fun side and eyecandy and plot/characterization front , at least starting from her Oboretai anthology onwards... so I'd suggest to try all of her works, minus the very early ones unless you're a completionist.
The only stories of hers that left me a bit O_O are a handful of tragedy oneshots (for the mindf*ck factor up the wazoo) and Aisuru Hito (for featuring a triangle and the circumstances of said triangle members).
Usually her stories are at the core about Him and Her, pretty straightforward in this sense. No triangles. And it's a breath of fresh air : a clear-cut 'clean' romantic premise + crazy&oh-so-sensual execution combo that can make me root for the characters wholeheartedly. And characters that can have you facepalming - in a good way XD - but that you wouldn't bash repeatedly in the head with an anvil (as it happens to me instead while reading other smut authors).
And she has hard working, often proud women pouncing on pretty men biggrin . Self-assured , (mostly) career-accomplished women's sex drive ftw . Forget doormats characters here biggrin
Last but not least: humour is higly subjective. But Yoshihara's brand of humour on me works wonders. One of the few mangaka - in any genre and demographic- that has made me - literally - ROFL (a shiny example it's in the aforementioned Oboretai: the fateful meeting in the elevator smile wink grin ) . Oh, glorious crack *_* .
Other good titles: Darling Wa..., Chou Yo Hana Yo, Haa Haa, Itadakimasu. Ningyo Ouji for more controversial and more supernatural stuff. Sheet no Sukima instead if you want both comedy oneshots and darker ones.

---
SHIMAKI Ako: her story and characters are pretty simple and bordering on silly at times, and she tends to loose coherence/continuity in multi-chaptered works, but... boy, graphics and presentation are key here. Her art has a cinematic quality , gracing even the most trite plots with enough spark to lift her above 99% of smut (barring Yoshihara Yuki above , of course . Colour me biased XD ). One of my favourite sequence of hers is in the titular story of Iinazuke Ryokan : the nocturnal torch sequence eyes
While her girls usually falls under the 'naive, cute, not too sharp but good-hearted' type - with then bonus of looking quite shapely -, her boys are actually nice and courteous. In a genre infested with potential rapists such as smut, this makes a very welcome difference.

Mixed bag, but better than most:
1) OHMI Tomu of Midnight Secretary fame . I find her works to be swinging between very agreeable and appealing and bland and cliché. MS is a good example of that: I really like some parts of it , but it's very uneven overall. And the male protagonist's chauvinism is really pushing my tolerance at times. But I blame the editors and certain bad romance novels heritage for this bigrazz .
In other titles, for instance, her male leads are much better (Barairo my honey ) .
2) Kayono has often questionable plot elements, shallow and/or flat characters. But she used to (emphasis on past tense roll ) churn out some pretty art in some of her works , and she's good at exotic, '1001 Nights' kinds of setting: her best works to me are B-Men Kazoku and the Otoko Hime to Mahou no Lamp anthology , in which she managed to dodge most of her flaws and to showcase most - if not all - of her strengths : chemistry, some hot sex scenes, luscious backgrounds, detailed clothes and accessories, delectable bodies, action scenes and a bit of suspance, some jokes and jabs at various manga genres (from magical girls to harem boob-grabbing leads to action/adventure to her own stylistic quirks) and (in these two titles at least ) NO RAPE YAY.

Last edited by elianthos at 12:07 pm, Dec 6 2009

________________
Motomi Kyousuke is DA (WO)MAN ;D
http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=14467&p ost=382161
Post #346410
user avatar
Member

11:54 pm, Jan 4 2010
Posts: 991


For months, I've been fascinated by Monkey Strip, but I haven't been able to find any other works by Ohkura Kaori. Still, just with that oneshot, she's my favorite smut mangaka.

EDIT: I've now located a couple other series by her, although they don't seem to be smut. I wonder what those series are about. *_*

Last edited by Odette at 6:48 pm, Jan 7 2010

________________
Avatar by tassyn.livejournal.com

Reading: Kingdom, Sangokushi, Historie
Nyl
Post #347116
Member

6:33 pm, Jan 7 2010
Posts: 2


Yoshihara Yuki for me as well and Tomu Oomi. I think they are the best, much more mature than the rest.

user avatar
Member

3:21 am, Jan 10 2010
Posts: 49


ARGH! Hates Shinjo Mayu. She writes and draws the same thing each time. But she does have a new one out that isn't so bad. Let's hope it doesn't turn out to be a big piece of steaming crap like all the others. And surprisingly there is no smut so far.

Post #351646 - Reply to (#340066) by elianthos
user avatar
Member

9:49 pm, Jan 21 2010
Posts: 981


Quote from elianthos
I definitively love and recommend YOSHIHARA Yuki : 9 times out of 10 I can be sure she delivers both on the fun side and eyecandy and plot/characterization front , at least starting from her Oboretai anthology onwards... so I'd suggest to try all of her works, minus the very early ones unless you're a completionist.
...
And she has hard working, often proud women pouncing on pretty men biggrin . Self-assured , (mostly) career-accomplished women's sex drive ftw . Forget doormats characters here


I second all your praise of Yoshihara-sensei. My favorite titles are Chiyou yo Hana yo and Haa Haa. Her short "Sheherazade" in the collection Sheet no Sukima is one of the best stories I've read anywhere. It is a perfect gem.

Stroke Material by ATSUTA Kotobuki is very good, though I don't know any of her other works. It is from the viewpoint of the man, and he is every bit as angsty as the typical shoujo heroine. Very funny.

I also like OHMI Tomu (Midnight Secretary and the oneshot Love Cruise).

I read a lot of SHINJO Mayu when I ran out of better things. I do highly recommend Akuma na Eros if you read it as a comedy. The heroine is a high school girl who falls in love with Satan. I'm not kidding. She actually says, twice, "Could it be ... Satan?" Other immortal lines: "I guess I need to realize that having the devil for a boyfriend means I shouldn't be surprised by anything.." and "If I told him about my summoning the devil, and the exchanging contract...he would probably think badly of me." You think? Another character declares "Satan and I are sex friends."

Post #366211
user avatar
Member

10:34 pm, Mar 24 2010
Posts: 6


well, I only now a few:
Shinjo Mayu
Minami Kanan
Ukyou Ayane
Go Ikeyamada
Miyagi Riko

I wrote them on my list so I have a record..biggrin


user avatar
Kunoichi Hime
Member

6:36 am, Mar 25 2010
Posts: 67


*coughs* I have a few favorites!! These write really hot stories (well for my tastes anyway):

Ohkura Kaori
Yamada Kana
Yoshihara Yuki
Narukami Yutta
Katsumoto Kasane
and Tsuzuki Moe


aaaaaaaah, I wish there was more smut!!

PS: We should totally have a blushing smiley, eh?

ejo
Post #366780
user avatar
Member

8:46 am, Mar 27 2010
Posts: 116


I know three Smut authors(they either made something cute or terrifying that made me remember them) :
- Shinjo Mayu
- Go Ikeyamada (I love Moe Kare, Suki Desu Suzuki and Uwasa No Midori-kun)
- Katsumoto Kasane (Deep Sex - really good XDD) laugh

user avatar
Hime-chan~♥
Member

12:09 am, Mar 31 2010
Posts: 672


I love Yoshihara Yuki as well. Her scenes always get me all hot and bothered, but just when I think I'm about to go crazy, I go crazy in a different way, and by different I mean that I start laughing my ass off. laugh

Ikeyamada Go and Enjouji Maki are also two more favorites. Well-known yes, but I do like them.

Shinjo Mayu on the hand is just...ugh.

________________
User Posted Image

*__* I'll have what she's having... please~♥
Member

9:07 pm, May 3 2010
Posts: 1


My TOP 5 are:

I really LOVE the story and characters of
SHINJO Mayu,
MINAMI Kanan,
AIKAWA Saki,
IKEYAMADA Go and
SUMOTO Amu

I love SMUT Mangas w/ handsome and possesive guys like,

"SAKUYA" of Kaikan Phrase
"TAMAKI" of Ren-ai Shijou Shugi
"KAGURA" of Iinchou no Himegoto
"TAKARA" of [m]Moe Kare![/m]
"MEGANE" of Watashi no Megane-kun
...and many more!
YOSHIHARA Yuki is good for me but I don't like too much "comedy", and her characters are look like adults... I more prefer High Schoolers so I can relate to them... biggrin

...and I kinda like the rape or force scene... and the Love Triangle Concepts! biggrin eyes

user avatar
Member

8:05 am, May 21 2010
Posts: 31


haruko kurumatani, shigano iori, miyagi riko (i don't like her stuff though) and the person who wrote
Dekiai Paradox

user avatar
Member

8:27 am, Jun 9 2010
Posts: 76


I think YOSHIHARA Yuki is great <3
I love her mangas <3 I am still searching for a new mangaka who is a bit like Yoshihara Yuki.

And I also read 3 mangas of MINAMI Kanan who ain't bad.
except Renai Shijou Shugi << Don't like that one.

Smut cult
Member

8:04 am, Nov 28 2022
Posts: 1


Some of the top tier early work I loved were definitely done by,


Ohmi tomu
OSAKABE Mashin
MINAMI Kanan
AKEGAMI Takara
ENJOUJI Maki

I really do enjoyed all of the work done by them and YOSHIHARA Yuki cuz among them she had most realistic and hilarious plots!

Last edited by Sugar_daddy at 8:05 am, Nov 28 2022

________________
Kirai to sukii
Pages (2) [ 1 2 ]  
You must be registered to post!